Constraining Black Hole Populations in Globular Clusters Using Microlensing: Application to Omega Centauri

John Zaris, Doğa Veske, Johan Samsing, Zsuzsa Márka, I. Bartos, Szabolcs MárkaThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes using gravitational microlensing of stars within globular clusters (GCs) to constrain the population of black holes (BHs) residing there. By simulating microlensing events in the massive GC Omega Centauri, the authors estimate an observable rate of events, suggesting that future observations could reveal crucial details about the distribution and properties of these elusive BHs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The origin of binary black hole (BBH) mergers detected by gravitational wave observatories like LIGO and Virgo remains a significant puzzle. While GCs are theorized to be excellent "factories" for BHs and BBHs due to their dense stellar environments, direct evidence for a substantial population of stellar-mass BHs within GCs, especially those massive enough to contribute to GW events, is still limited. Existing methods for detecting BHs in GCs, such as X-ray observations or radial velocity studies of companion stars, have limitations. This paper addresses the need for an independent method to probe and constrain the BH population within GCs, which could shed light on their formation channels and their contribution to the observed GW merger rate.

Methods

The authors employ a two-pronged approach:

  1. Analytical Toy Model: They first derive a simplified, order-of-magnitude estimate for the microlensing rate of GC stars by BHs. This model uses standard lensing equations and makes approximations regarding the velocity dispersion and spatial distribution of BHs and stars within the GC. This provides a foundational understanding of how factors like the number and mass of BHs, and the cluster's velocity dispersion, influence the microlensing rate.
  2. Monte Carlo (MC) Simulation: To refine the estimate, they develop a more sophisticated MC simulation. This simulation models the GC using observational data for stellar density and velocity dispersion profiles. For the BH population, they adopt an "energy equipartition" model, acknowledging that GCs may not perfectly achieve this state. The simulation generates realistic scenarios of BHs and stars interacting and calculates the probability and characteristics of microlensing events, specifically focusing on the magnification threshold for detectability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing observational data for the globular cluster Omega Centauri (e.g., stellar density and velocity dispersion profiles) and theoretical models of BH populations in GCs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Microlensing as a BH Probe: The core idea is that BHs within GCs can act as gravitational lenses, temporarily magnifying the light from background stars. By observing these microlensing events, we can infer properties of the lensing BHs.
  • Omega Centauri as a Prime Target: The massive GC Omega Centauri is identified as an ideal candidate for this study due to theoretical predictions of it harboring a significant BH population (around 10⁵ M☉).
  • Observable Event Rates: The simulations predict an observable microlensing event rate of approximately 0.1–1 year⁻¹ for Omega Centauri, making it a feasible target for current and future observational surveys.
  • Constraining BH Properties: The rate and duration of these microlensing events are sensitive to the BH mass spectrum, their spatial distribution, and the magnification threshold for detection. This means that observing (or not observing) such events can place constraints on these unknown BH population parameters.
  • Distinguishing BH Lenses: The paper notes that microlensing events caused by BHs can be distinguished from those caused by stars, as BH lenses are unobservable optically.

Key Results

  • The analytical toy model estimates a microlensing rate of approximately 0.2 yr⁻¹ for Omega Centauri, assuming a BH population of 10⁴ BHs with 10 M☉ each.
  • The more detailed MC simulations confirm this rate, predicting a range of 0.1–1 yr⁻¹ for Omega Centauri, depending on the magnification threshold and BH distribution parameters.
  • The simulations suggest that microlensing events typically last on the order of several weeks.
  • The rate is found to increase with BH mass and is influenced by the BHs' proximity to the cluster's center, where star density is higher.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Independence: While the authors strive for model independence, they acknowledge that the BH mass spectrum and exact distribution are not well constrained, and they adopt an "energy equipartition" model for BHs, which may not be perfectly realized in GCs.
  • Crowding: Observations near the GC core may face issues with stellar crowding, potentially leading to ambiguities in localizing the lensed stars and thus increasing uncertainty in BH population parameter estimation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest optimizing current and future search strategies for observing such BH microlensing events. They also plan to further investigate how to optimize current and future search strategies for observing such BH microlensing events.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We estimate the rate of gravitational microlensing events of cluster stars due to black holes (BHs) in the globular cluster NGC 5139 ( ωCen ). Theory and observations both indicate that ωCen may contain thousands of BHs, but their mass spectrum and exact distribution are not well constrained. In this Letter we show that one may observe microlensing events on a timescale of years in ωCen , and such an event sample can be used to infer the BH distribution. Direct detection of BHs will, in the near future, play a major role in distinguishing binary BH merger channels. Here we explore how gravitational microlensing can be used to put constraints on BH populations in globular clusters.
BibTeX
@article{zaris2020constraining,
  author = {John Zaris and Doğa Veske and Johan Samsing and Zsuzsa Márka and I. Bartos and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Constraining Black Hole Populations in Globular Clusters Using Microlensing: Application to Omega Centauri}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ab89a3},
}
Figure