Introduction
In Natural Language Processing (NLP), the prevailing trend favors increasing model scale to achieve better performance. However, this scaling comes at a significant computational cost. Standard English text representation treats all characters with equal weight, resulting in large vocabularies and memory-intensive embedding layers. This paper explores a "consonant-centric" approach, inspired by Abjad writing systems like Arabic, to compress English text by stripping or masking vowels. The goal is to determine if English can be represented more efficiently without compromising the semantic integrity required for complex NLP tasks.
Methodology
The researchers evaluated three primary text representations:
- Standard English (S): Unmodified text.
- Consonants-only (C): Complete removal of vowels (A, E, I, O, U).
- Masked-vowels (M): Replacement of all vowels with a single placeholder symbol (e.g.,
#).
These representations were tested across various architectures, including n-gram models, Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs), and Transformers. The evaluation suite covered language modeling (Wikitext-2), text classification (IMDB, AGNews), sequence labeling (EWT for POS tagging, CoNLL2003 for NER), and Neural Machine Translation (Multi30K).
Analysis of Compactness
A primary advantage of consonant-based representations is the reduction in vocabulary size. By focusing on the consonantal "skeleton" of words, the models can operate with significantly fewer unique tokens.
As shown in the data, stripping vowels reduces vocabulary size by an average of 18%, reaching up to 23% in certain datasets. This reduction directly translates to smaller embedding layers and faster training cycles. For instance, training time per epoch was reduced from 82 seconds for standard text to approximately 67 seconds for the consonant-only version. Despite the compression, character-level entropy remains stable, suggesting that the "learnability" of the language is preserved.
Performance Evaluation
Despite the significant reduction in input data, the compact representations maintained high performance across most benchmarks. In text classification, the Consonants-only model slightly outperformed the standard model on the AGNews dataset (91.80% vs 91.70%), proving that vowels are largely redundant for categorizing text.
However, sequence labeling tasks revealed a critical nuance. The Consonants-only (C) approach struggled with Part-of-Speech (POS) tagging, largely due to the deletion of essential single-vowel words like the determiner "a" and the pronoun "I." The Masked-vowels (M) representation addressed this by preserving positional information.
As illustrated in the results, the Masked-vowels approach achieved a 94.54% accuracy in Named-Entity Recognition (NER), actually surpassing the 93.97% achieved by standard text. This suggests that while the specific identity of a vowel may be redundant for many tasks, its presence as a placeholder provides vital structural cues for the model.
Conclusion
The "Consonant is all you need" approach demonstrates that English text contains significant redundancy in its vowel structure for many NLP tasks. By adopting a more compact, Abjad-style representation, researchers can build leaner and more efficient models. While challenges remain regarding human readability and the need for reconstruction models in generative tasks, this research paves the way for more sustainable and computationally efficient NLP pipelines.
Summary updated