Consistent negative response of US crops to high temperatures in observations and crop models

Bernhard Schauberger, Sotirios V. Archontoulis, Almut Arneth, Juraj Balkovič, Philippe Ciais, Delphine Deryng, Joshua Elliott, Christian Folberth, Nikolay Khabarov, Christoph Müller, Thomas A. M. Pugh, Susanne Rolinski, Sibyll Schaphoff, Erwin Schmid, Xuhui Wang, Wolfram Schlenker, Katja FrielerNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper validates that current crop models accurately capture the observed negative impact of high temperatures on US maize and soybean yields, primarily driven by water stress. It also highlights that elevated CO2 offers limited protection against these heat-induced yield losses, underscoring the critical role of irrigation for future crop resilience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Global warming is projected to increase the frequency and intensity of high-temperature events, posing a significant threat to agricultural productivity and global food security. While process-based crop models are widely used to predict these impacts, their ability to accurately represent the effects of high temperatures has been questioned. Specifically, there's a need to understand if these models can replicate observed yield declines and to identify the underlying mechanisms, particularly the role of water stress versus direct heat damage. This study aims to bridge this gap by comparing observed yield responses to high temperatures with simulations from an ensemble of crop models.

Methods

The researchers employed a statistical approach, specifically a panel regression model adapted from Schlenker and Roberts (2009), to analyze both observed historical yield data and simulated yields from nine global gridded crop models (GGCMs). This method allows for the estimation of the marginal effect of each day spent in specific temperature bins on crop yields.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Ensemble Modeling: Using an ensemble of nine GGCMs (eight for wheat) to capture a range of model behaviors and reduce uncertainty.
  • Statistical Validation: Comparing the coefficients derived from observed county-level yield data with those from simulated yields to assess model performance.
  • Rainfed vs. Irrigated Analysis: Conducting separate analyses for rainfed and irrigated counties to disentangle the effects of water availability.
  • Future Climate Projections: Utilizing climate projections under the RCP8.5 scenario to assess future yield responses under elevated temperatures and CO2 concentrations.
  • Mechanism Investigation: Using the model simulations to explore the underlying causes of yield declines, particularly the role of water stress.

Datasets

  • Historical Observed US County Yields: Data from 1980 to 2010 (or 2008 for wheat) obtained from the USDA Quick Stats tool.
  • Historical Weather Data: Daily temperature (maximum and minimum) and precipitation data from the AgMERRA climate dataset (1980-2010) at a 0.5° spatial resolution.
  • Future Climate Projections: Bias-corrected climate projections from the HadGEM2 climate model under the RCP8.5 scenario at a 0.5° spatial resolution for the period 2071-2099.
  • Crop Model Simulations: Yield simulations from nine GGCMs (EPIC-Boku, EPIC-IIASA, GEPIC, LPJ-GUESS, LPJmL, ORCHIDEE-crop, PAPSIM, PDSSAT, and PEGASUS) for historical and future periods, with varying CO2 levels.
  • Irrigated Area Data: MIRCA2000 dataset for mapping irrigated and rainfed areas.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Model Validation Success: A significant finding is that the ensemble of crop models successfully reproduces the observed negative temperature response of US maize and soybean yields, particularly under rainfed conditions. This validates the use of these models for future projections.
  • Water Stress as the Primary Driver: The study strongly supports the hypothesis that high temperatures negatively impact yields primarily through inducing water stress. This is evidenced by the significantly weaker negative response observed in irrigated areas or simulated under full irrigation.
  • Limited Role of Elevated CO2: Contrary to some assumptions, elevated CO2 levels offer only a weak attenuation of heat-induced yield losses. This suggests that while CO2 fertilization can be beneficial, it cannot fully compensate for the detrimental effects of extreme heat, especially when water is limited.
  • Wheat's Different Response: Wheat exhibits a different pattern, with no significant negative response to high temperatures observed or simulated under historical conditions. This is attributed to critical temperatures rarely being exceeded during its growing season. However, future projections indicate a decline even for wheat under high temperatures.
  • Future Yield Declines: Projections indicate that yields for all three crops (maize, soybean, and wheat) are likely to decline at temperatures above 30°C in the future, even with elevated CO2.

Key Results

  • Maize and Soybean Yield Loss: Each day above 30°C can diminish rainfed maize and soybean yields by up to 6%.
  • Irrigation Mitigation: The negative impact of high temperatures on yields is significantly reduced under irrigated conditions.
  • Wheat's Historical Resilience: Under historical conditions, wheat shows no clear negative temperature response, with critical temperatures rarely exceeded.
  • Future Yield Loss Estimates: Based on projected temperature shifts, future yield losses below 36°C are estimated to be around 49% for maize, 40% for soybean, and 22% for wheat.
  • CO2 vs. Irrigation: While elevated CO2 has a limited effect on mitigating heat stress, irrigation shows a substantial capacity to reduce yield declines.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Direct Heat Damage: The study acknowledges that current crop models may not fully represent direct damage to plant tissues from extremely high temperatures, which could become more relevant in the future. Further model development to incorporate these mechanisms is suggested.
  • Leaf Temperature: The models do not explicitly account for differences between air temperature and leaf temperature, which can be influenced by evaporative cooling. Future work could explore this aspect.
  • Management Adaptation: The study's future projections do not fully account for potential farmer adaptation strategies (e.g., changes in fertilizer application, cultivar selection), which could influence actual yield outcomes.
  • CO2 Overestimation Debate: The authors note the ongoing discussion about whether crop models might overestimate the yield response to elevated CO2.
  • Model Intercomparison Nuances: While an ensemble was used, the authors mention that models from the same families might share development histories, and future simulations were based on a single climate model, which could introduce some biases.

The authors suggest further field experiments to investigate the limited effect of elevated CO2 under water stress and recommend incorporating explicit leaf temperature representations in models to improve understanding of high-temperature impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

High temperatures are detrimental to crop yields and could lead to global warming-driven reductions in agricultural productivity. To assess future threats, the majority of studies used process-based crop models, but their ability to represent effects of high temperature has been questioned. Here we show that an ensemble of nine crop models reproduces the observed average temperature responses of US maize, soybean and wheat yields. Each day >30 °C diminishes maize and soybean yields by up to 6% under rainfed conditions. Declines observed in irrigated areas, or simulated assuming full irrigation, are weak. This supports the hypothesis that water stress induced by high temperatures causes the decline. For wheat a negative response to high temperature is neither observed nor simulated under historical conditions, since critical temperatures are rarely exceeded during the growing season. In the future, yields are modelled to decline for all three crops at temperatures >30 °C. Elevated CO<sub>2</sub> can only weakly reduce these yield losses, in contrast to irrigation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schauberger2017consistent,
  author = {Bernhard Schauberger and Sotirios V. Archontoulis and Almut Arneth and Juraj Balkovič and Philippe Ciais and Delphine Deryng and Joshua Elliott and Christian Folberth and Nikolay Khabarov and Christoph Müller and Thomas A. M. Pugh and Susanne Rolinski and Sibyll Schaphoff and Erwin Schmid and Xuhui Wang and Wolfram Schlenker and Katja Frieler},
  title = {{Consistent negative response of US crops to high temperatures in observations and crop models}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms13931},
}
Figure