Conserved and Opposite Transcriptome Patterns during Germination in Hordeum vulgare and Arabidopsis thaliana

Yanqiao Zhu, Oliver Berkowitz, Jennifer Selinski, Andreas Hartmann, Reena Narsai, Yan Wang, Peisheng Mao, James WhelanInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares the gene expression patterns of barley and Arabidopsis thaliana during seed germination, revealing both conserved and surprisingly opposite transcriptional strategies. While core germination processes like RNA metabolism and mitochondrial biogenesis are largely conserved, significant differences in energy metabolism, photosynthesis, and regulatory pathways highlight distinct evolutionary adaptations that could be exploited for crop improvement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Seed germination is a fundamental process for plant life cycles and global food security. While we understand much about the hormonal regulation of germination (like gibberellic acid and abscisic acid), the precise molecular mechanisms, especially at the transcriptome level, and how these mechanisms might differ between major crop species and model plants, remain areas of active investigation. Specifically, understanding the conserved and divergent transcriptional programs that enable a quiescent seed to rapidly transition to active growth is crucial for improving germination efficiency, grain quality, and storage longevity. This paper addresses this by performing a detailed, time-course transcriptome comparison between barley (a major cereal crop with starch-rich seeds) and Arabidopsis thaliana (a model dicot with oil-rich seeds), species separated by over 140 million years of evolution.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • RNA Sequencing (RNAseq): This was the core technique, used to profile gene expression in barley embryos at multiple time points (0, 3, 6, 12, 24, 36, and 48 hours post-imbibition). This data was then compared to existing RNAseq data for Arabidopsis germination.
  • Hierarchical Clustering and Self-Organizing Maps (SOM): These algorithms were used to group genes with similar expression patterns over time, both within each species and across species.
  • Orthology Analysis (OrthoFinder): To compare genes between barley and Arabidopsis, orthologous genes (genes with shared ancestry) were identified. This allowed for the direct comparison of gene families and their expression trends.
  • Gene Ontology (GO) Enrichment Analysis: This was used to identify the biological functions and pathways that were significantly over-represented in specific gene clusters or groups, helping to interpret the biological significance of the observed expression changes.
  • Biochemical and Proteomic Analyses: To complement the transcriptome data, the study also involved immunoblotting to quantify specific mitochondrial proteins and mass spectrometry to analyze the mitochondrial proteome. Oxygen consumption measurements were also performed.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • Barley ( Hordeum vulgare ) transcriptome data: Generated by the authors for this study, covering multiple time points during germination.
  • Arabidopsis thaliana transcriptome data: Publicly available data from a previous study (Narsai et al., 2017) on Arabidopsis germination.
  • Protein sequence databases: IBSCv2 for barley and TAIR10 for Arabidopsis were used for orthology analysis.
  • Mitochondrial protein databases: SUBA4 and Croppal were used for identifying mitochondrial proteins.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing datasets were leveraged for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Germination is a conserved process, but the "how" differs: While the overall pattern of gene expression changes during germination is remarkably similar between barley and Arabidopsis, the specific genes and regulatory pathways involved show significant divergence. This suggests that evolution has found multiple successful strategies to achieve this critical transition.
  • Mitochondrial biogenesis is a universal early step: Both species show increased expression of genes involved in mitochondrial biogenesis early in germination, underscoring its critical role in providing energy for the transition from a dormant state to active growth. However, the timing of this biogenesis appears to vary between species.
  • Energy and photosynthesis pathways are key divergence points: The most striking differences lie in how energy metabolism and photosynthesis are regulated. Arabidopsis appears to ramp up autotrophic growth (photosynthesis) more rapidly, possibly due to its smaller seed size and reliance on stored oils, while also activating alternative energy pathways early on. Barley, with its larger starch reserves, seems to have a more gradual activation of these processes.
  • Regulatory differences hint at evolutionary trade-offs: Divergent expression patterns in transcription factor families like bZIPs and AP2/EREBPs suggest distinct high-level regulatory mechanisms are at play, potentially reflecting adaptations to different storage reserves and environmental conditions.

Key Results

  • Approximately 6000 genes showed conserved early peaking expression patterns in both species, enriched in RNA metabolism.
  • Over 3000 orthogroups (containing nearly 4000 genes) displayed similar expression patterns, involved in mitochondrial TCA cycle, carbohydrate and RNA/DNA metabolism, autophagy, and protein modifications.
  • More than 1800 orthogroups (representing ~2000 genes) showed opposite patterns in transcript abundance, particularly in energy metabolism, photosynthesis, protein synthesis/degradation, and gene regulation.
  • Arabidopsis showed a more rapid upregulation of photosynthesis-associated genes compared to barley.
  • Arabidopsis activated alternative mitochondrial energy pathways earlier, potentially indicating a greater reliance on amino acid catabolism for energy production in early germination.
  • Differences were observed in the expression of bZIP and AP2/EREBP transcription factors, suggesting distinct regulatory control mechanisms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Annotation differences: The authors acknowledge that differences in the availability and accuracy of GO term annotations between barley and Arabidopsis might influence the interpretation of some results.
  • Species-specific physiology: The differences in seed reserves (starch in barley vs. oil in Arabidopsis) are a significant factor, but the study also points to other physiological and molecular differences that contribute to the observed transcriptomic divergence.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that understanding these divergent regulatory processes could provide opportunities to modify germination and grain quality traits in crops. Further research could focus on dissecting the specific roles of the oppositely regulated genes and transcription factors to enable targeted improvements in seed traits. The study also highlights the need for more detailed biochemical and proteomic analyses to fully understand the functional implications of these transcriptomic differences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Seed germination is a critical process for completion of the plant life cycle and for global food production. Comparing the germination transcriptomes of barley (<i>Hordeum vulgare</i>) to <i>Arabidopsis thaliana</i> revealed the overall pattern was conserved in terms of functional gene ontology; however, many oppositely responsive orthologous genes were identified. Conserved processes included a set of approximately 6000 genes that peaked early in germination and were enriched in processes associated with RNA metabolism, e.g., pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR)-containing proteins. Comparison of orthologous genes revealed more than 3000 orthogroups containing almost 4000 genes that displayed similar expression patterns including functions associated with mitochondrial tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, carbohydrate and RNA/DNA metabolism, autophagy, protein modifications, and organellar function. Biochemical and proteomic analyses indicated mitochondrial biogenesis occurred early in germination, but detailed analyses revealed the timing involved in mitochondrial biogenesis may vary between species. More than 1800 orthogroups representing 2000 genes displayed opposite patterns in transcript abundance, representing functions of energy (carbohydrate) metabolism, photosynthesis, protein synthesis and degradation, and gene regulation. Differences in expression of basic-leucine zippers (bZIPs) and Apetala 2 (AP2)/ethylene-responsive element binding proteins (EREBPs) point to differences in regulatory processes at a high level, which provide opportunities to modify processes in order to enhance grain quality, germination, and storage as needed for different uses.
BibTeX
@article{zhu2020conserved,
  author = {Yanqiao Zhu and Oliver Berkowitz and Jennifer Selinski and Andreas Hartmann and Reena Narsai and Yan Wang and Peisheng Mao and James Whelan},
  title = {{Conserved and Opposite Transcriptome Patterns during Germination in Hordeum vulgare and Arabidopsis thaliana}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms21197404},
}
Figure