Consequence of COVID-19 on Cryptocurrency Returns

Umesh Kumar, Biqing HuangJournal of Finance Issues 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study scrutinizes the COVID-19 measures and their effect on leading cryptocurrency returns. Our direct measures of COVID-19 show that cryptocurrency returns are significantly influenced by COVID-19 and are most visible throughout pre-vaccination phase. The intraday price movement becomes wider during vaccination period compared to cryptocurrency returns. The findings demonstrate that even negative news of COVID-19 did not deter investors from being optimistic in the pre-vaccination period. Further, COVID-19 impacts on the cryptocurrency market diverge depending on the size of currency once vaccination begins. It reflects a different underlying dynamic process in cryptocurrency trading.

Introduction

While the pandemic's impact on traditional financial markets has been extensively documented, the direct relationship between specific health metrics—such as hospitalization rates and ICU admissions—and cryptocurrency returns remains a critical area of inquiry. Often characterized as "digital gold" or inflation hedges, cryptocurrencies faced a unique test during the COVID-19 global black swan event. This research investigates whether the intensity of the pandemic drove price movements and how the introduction of vaccines altered market dynamics for digital assets.

Methodology and Data

The study utilized daily pricing data (open, close, high, low) and volume for the top 10 cryptocurrencies by market capitalization, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana, from January 22, 2020, to August 31, 2022. To measure pandemic intensity, the researchers tracked U.S.-based metrics for new cases, deaths, and hospitalizations per million people.

Figure 2: Daily new COVID-19 cases illustrating the intensity of the pandemic waves.

To analyze these relationships, the authors employed several econometric models:

  • Multivariate Regressions (OLS & SUR): To establish baseline correlations.
  • GARCH-M & EGARCH Models: To account for volatility clustering and the asymmetric impact of "bad news."
  • Impulse Response Functions (IRF): To simulate the duration of market shocks following spikes in COVID-19 cases.

Key Insights: The Regime Shift

The Pre-Vaccine "Optimism Bias"

In the early stages of the pandemic, the study found a surprising positive association between rising COVID-19 intensity and cryptocurrency returns. This suggests that during the initial period of global uncertainty, investors viewed crypto as a "risk-on" speculative vehicle or a potential hedge against the perceived instability of traditional fiat systems.

The Vaccine Regime Shift

Following the rollout of vaccines in December 2020, the market dynamic flipped. High ICU and hospitalization rates began to correlate negatively with returns. The initial speculative honeymoon phase ended as the market began to price in the actual economic drag caused by a prolonged health crisis.

Figure 4: Comparative performance of the Ten Crypto Index versus the MSCI World Index.

Market Size and Intraday Volatility

The impact of the pandemic diverged based on market capitalization. Large-cap coins like Bitcoin demonstrated higher liquidity and more efficient price adjustments. Conversely, smaller coins exhibited higher fluctuations. Interestingly, while daily returns moderated during the vaccination period, the intraday price movement (the spread between daily highs and lows) widened from an average of 4.47% to 5.70%, indicating increased "noise" within trading days.

Key Results and Conclusions

Statistical models showed a significant association between COVID-19 intensity and crypto returns, with Adjusted R-squared values reaching 0.90 in specific pre-vaccination models. Impulse Response Functions revealed that shocks from sudden spikes in COVID-19 cases typically took approximately one week to dissipate from the cryptocurrency index returns.

While the study provides a robust look at the top 10 currencies, it acknowledges limitations regarding the geographic scope of COVID-19 data and the focus on high-cap assets. Future research is suggested to explore Decentralized Finance (DeFi) and the specific influence of government policy responses beyond vaccination efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study scrutinizes the COVID-19 measures and their effect on leading cryptocurrency returns. Our direct measures of COVID-19 show that cryptocurrency returns are significantly influenced by COVID-19 and are most visible throughout pre-vaccination phase. The intraday price movement becomes wider during vaccination period compared to cryptocurrency returns. The findings demonstrate that even negative news of COVID-19 did not deter investors from being optimistic in the pre-vaccination period. Further, COVID-19 impacts on the cryptocurrency market diverge depending on the size of currency once vaccination begins. It reflects a different underlying dynamic process in cryptocurrency trading.
BibTeX
@article{kumar2023consequence,
  author = {Umesh Kumar and Biqing Huang},
  title = {{Consequence of COVID-19 on Cryptocurrency Returns}},
  journal = {Journal of Finance Issues},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.58886/jfi.v21i2.5445},
}
Figure