TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel method for clustering data that comes from multiple sources (views) but has missing information in some of those sources. By simultaneously imputing missing data and learning a consensus clustering decision that respects the consistency between views, the method significantly improves clustering performance compared to existing approaches.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In many real-world scenarios, data is available from multiple perspectives or modalities, known as "multiview data." For instance, a webpage can be described by its text and images, or a patient's health can be assessed through various medical tests. Clustering this multiview data can lead to more robust and accurate groupings than using a single view alone. However, a significant challenge arises when some of these views are incomplete, meaning certain data points are missing for specific views. This incompleteness can severely degrade the performance of standard multiview clustering algorithms. While some existing methods attempt to handle this by either learning a shared subspace or imputing missing data, they often overlook the crucial aspect of between-view consistency, which is a fundamental property of multiview data. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that effectively handles incomplete multiview data while explicitly modeling and leveraging the consistency across different views.
Methods
The proposed method, "Consensus Kernel K-Means Clustering for Incomplete Multiview Data," tackles the problem by integrating two key components: kernel imputation and consensus clustering.
- Unified Learning Framework: Unlike methods that separate imputation and clustering, this approach integrates them into a single optimization problem. This allows the imputation process to be guided by the clustering objective and the desired between-view consistency.
- Between-View Consistency Modeling: The core novelty lies in how consistency is modeled. The authors propose learning a "consensus clustering decision" that is similar to the kernel k-means clustering result of each individual view. The similarity between each view's clustering result and the consensus decision is measured, and the sum of these similarities is maximized. This explicitly enforces that the clustering from different views should align.
- Kernel Imputation: The method simultaneously learns to fill in the missing parts of the kernel matrices for incomplete views. This imputation is not arbitrary but is driven by both the clustering objective within each view and the overall between-view consistency.
- Alternating Optimization: The complex optimization problem is solved using an alternating optimization strategy. The variables (consensus clustering decision $U^*$, individual view clustering decisions $U_j$, and incomplete kernel matrices $K_j$) are updated iteratively. Each subproblem is designed to have a closed-form solution or can be solved efficiently using eigenvalue decomposition.
Datasets
The paper evaluates its method on one real-world incomplete multiview dataset and three synthetic incomplete multiview datasets.
- 3 Sources: A real-world dataset compiled from three news sites (BBC, Reuters, Guardian), containing 416 news stories with missing articles from some sites.
- Digital: A synthetic dataset generated from a complete multiview dataset.
- Flower 17: A synthetic dataset generated from a complete multiview dataset.
- Flower 102: A synthetic dataset generated from a complete multiview dataset.
For the synthetic datasets, incomplete multiview data is generated by randomly selecting a proportion of samples to be incomplete. Precomputed kernel matrices are used for Digital, Flower 17, and Flower 102, while Gaussian kernels are generated for the 3 Sources dataset.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Consistency is Key: The paper strongly advocates for the importance of between-view consistency in multiview clustering, especially when dealing with incomplete data. Ignoring this property, as some prior methods do, can lead to suboptimal clustering performance.
- Imputation Guided by Consensus: The imputation of missing kernel entries is not an independent step but is intrinsically linked to the goal of achieving a consistent clustering across all views. This synergistic approach is a major strength.
- Unified Framework Benefits: Integrating imputation and clustering into a single framework allows for a more effective learning process where each component directly benefits the other.
- Robustness to Incompleteness: The proposed method demonstrates a significant improvement in performance even as the incompleteness ratio (ISR) increases, highlighting its robustness.
Key Results
The proposed method consistently outperforms state-of-the-art methods on both real-world and synthetic datasets.
- Significant NMI Boost: On the 3 Sources dataset, the proposed method achieved a significant NMI (Normalized Mutual Information) boost of about 30% compared to MKKIK, a leading imputation-based method.
- Superiority over Subspace Methods: On the Digital dataset, the proposed method consistently outperformed other methods, including subspace-based approaches like PVC and IMG, by around 20% for certain incomplete sample ratios.
- Generalizability: The method shows strong performance across various datasets with different numbers of views and samples, demonstrating its generalizability.
- Convergence: Theoretical analysis and empirical validation show that the proposed alternating optimization algorithm converges to a local minimum within a reasonable number of iterations.
Limitations and Future Work
- Parameter Sensitivity: While the method generally performs well, the parameter $\beta$, which balances the importance of single-view clustering and between-view consistency, can influence performance. The paper suggests that a larger $\beta$ is generally beneficial when views share substantial common information. Further research could explore adaptive methods for setting this parameter.
- View Weighting: The current formulation assumes all views are equally important. The authors note that if prior knowledge about view importance exists, the method can be adapted to incorporate view weights. This could be a direction for future work, especially in scenarios with noisy or less informative views.
- Computational Cost: While the alternating optimization is efficient, optimizing for a large number of views or samples might still be computationally intensive. Exploring more scalable optimization techniques could be beneficial.
Summary updated