Conformational Dynamics of the D53−D3−D14 Complex in Strigolactone Signaling

Simiao Liu, Jia Wang, Bin Song, Xinqi Gong, Huihui Liu, Qingliang Hu, Junhui Zhang, Qianqian Li, Jie Zheng, Hong‐Wei Wang, H. Eric Xu, Jiayang Li, Bing WangPlant 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of understanding how plants perceive strigolactones (SLs), crucial hormones for growth and development. By reconstituting the full D53-SKP1-D3-D14 signaling complex and using cryo-EM and hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS), the researchers reveal dynamic conformational changes and propose a model for how this complex assembles, offering insights into a key plant signaling pathway.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Strigolactones (SLs) are a class of plant hormones that play vital roles in regulating plant architecture, including shoot branching, root development, and responses to environmental stress. The perception and subsequent signal transduction of SLs involve a multi-protein complex. While the individual components like the SL receptor DWARF14 (D14) and its interacting partners D3 (an F-box protein) and D53 (a transcriptional regulator) have been studied, and some structural information exists for partial complexes (e.g., D14-D3), the complete "holo-complex" involving D53 has remained elusive. Determining the structure and understanding the dynamic assembly of this full complex is crucial for deciphering the precise biochemical mechanisms of SL perception and signaling. Previous structural studies have been limited to D14 and D3 interactions, leaving the role and structural contribution of D53 largely unknown.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of biochemical and structural biology techniques:

  • Protein Expression and Purification: Full-length D53, SKP1, D3, and D14 proteins were expressed and purified using various chromatography methods (ion-exchange, gel-filtration, Ni-NTA affinity).
  • Complex Reconstitution: The D53-SKP1-D3-D14 holo-complex was reconstituted in vitro in the presence of the SL analog rac-GR24.
  • Negative-Stain Electron Microscopy (nsEM): Used for initial visualization and assessment of particle homogeneity and size of the reconstituted complex.
  • Cryo-Electron Microscopy (cryo-EM): Employed to determine the high-resolution structure of the SKP1-D3-D14 complex in the presence of D53. This allowed for the construction of a 3D map.
  • Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry (HDX-MS): A powerful technique to probe protein dynamics and conformational changes. By monitoring the rate at which amide hydrogens exchange with deuterium in the solvent, researchers can identify regions that are more exposed (flexible) or buried (stable) within the complex and how these change upon binding of different components or ligands.
  • Thermal Shift Assays (TSA) and Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS): Used to assess the thermostability of D53 and the reconstituted complex, providing insights into their structural integrity.
  • Structural Superposition and Modeling: The determined cryo-EM structure was compared to existing crystal structures of related complexes (e.g., ASK1-D3-AtD14). Additionally, computational modeling (using AlphaFold2) and docking methods were used to propose a model for the full D53-SKP1-D3-D14 complex.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as distinct datasets in the paper, but the study relies on:

  • Purified recombinant proteins: D53, SKP1, D3, and D14 were produced for complex formation.
  • Existing structural data: Crystal structures of related complexes (e.g., ASK1-D3-AtD14, PDB code 5HZG) were used for comparison and modeling.
  • AlphaFold2 database: Used for predicting the structure of D53.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • D53 is inherently flexible: Apo-D53 exhibits significant flexibility, making its structural determination challenging. This flexibility is a key characteristic that influences its role in complex formation.
  • SL-induced assembly leads to enhanced stability: The reconstituted D53-SKP1-D3-D14 complex shows significantly increased thermostability compared to apo-D53, indicating that complex formation stabilizes the protein.
  • Subtle but significant conformational shifts: While the overall structure of the SKP1-D3-D14 complex in the presence of D53 is similar to previously solved ASK1-D3-AtD14 structures, a notable ~9Å rotation between D14 and its ortholog AtD14 is observed. This suggests species-specific or complex-specific adjustments.
  • D53 acts as a dynamic scaffold: HDX-MS reveals that D53 undergoes significant conformational changes and appears to interact with interfaces between D14 and D3, potentially stabilizing the entire complex and influencing its dynamics.
  • Identification of key interaction interfaces: The study pinpoints specific regions within D53 (N and D2 domains) and its interactions with D14 and D3, providing crucial information for understanding the molecular basis of SL signaling.

Key Results

  • Successful reconstitution of the holo-complex: The D53-SKP1-D3-D14 complex was successfully reconstituted in vitro and visualized by negative-stain EM.
  • Cryo-EM structure of SKP1-D3-D14 with D53: A 7.09Å resolution cryo-EM map of the SKP1-D3-D14 complex in the presence of D53 was obtained, allowing for the building of an atomic model of SKP1, D3, and D14. D53's density was not clearly resolved, indicating its flexibility.
  • HDX-MS reveals dynamic interplay: HDX-MS data demonstrated dynamic changes in D14, D3, and D53 upon sequential addition of SLs and interacting partners, highlighting specific regions involved in stabilization and destabilization.
  • Proposed model of holo-complex: Based on the structural and dynamic data, a model for the D53-SKP1-D3-D14 holo-complex was proposed, suggesting a "sandwich" binding mechanism where D53 interacts with the D3-D14 interface.
  • Conservation of interaction regions: Key interaction regions identified in D53 were found to be highly conserved across different plant species, underscoring their functional importance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • D53 flexibility hinders direct structural visualization: The high flexibility of D53 prevented its clear visualization in the cryo-EM map, necessitating the use of modeling and HDX-MS to infer its role and interactions.
  • Resolution limitations: The 7.09Å resolution of the cryo-EM map, while useful for overall architecture, limits detailed atomic-level insights into the D53-protein interactions.
  • Species-specific differences: The observed ~9Å rotation between rice D14 and Arabidopsis AtD14 might reflect species-specific adaptations or differences in experimental conditions, requiring further investigation.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Further structural studies: Aiming for higher resolution structures, potentially of D53-bound sub-complexes or using advanced cryo-EM techniques to better resolve D53.
  • In vivo validation: Investigating the proposed interaction interfaces and conformational changes in living plant systems using genetic and biochemical approaches.
  • Engineering D53: Exploring the possibility of engineering D53 proteins with minimized active motifs to better understand its role in ubiquitination, degradation, and SL signaling.
  • Elucidating the role of other domains: Investigating the potential involvement of other D53 domains (like D1M) in complex formation and signaling specificity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Strigolactones (SLs) play fundamental roles in regulating plant architecture, which is a major factor determining crop yield. The perception and signal transduction of SLs require the formation of a complex containing the receptor DWARF14 (D14), an F-box protein D3 and a transcriptional regulator D53 in an SL-dependent manner. Structural and biochemical analyses of D14 and its orthologs DAD2 and AtD14, D3 and the complexes of ASK1-D3-AtD14 and D3CTH-D14 have made great contributions to understanding the mechanisms of SL perception. However, structural analyses of D53 and the D53-D3-D14 holo-complex are challenging, and the biochemical mechanism underlying the complex assembly remains poorly understood. Here, we found that apo-D53 was rather flexible and reconstituted the holo-complex containing D53, S-phase kinase-associated protein 1 (SKP1), D3 and D14 with rac-GR24. The cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structure of SKP1-D3-D14 in the presence of D53 was analyzed and superimposed on the crystal structure of ASK1-D3-AtD14 without D53. No large conformational rearrangement was observed, but a 9Å rotation appeared between D14 and AtD14. Using hydrogen-deuterium exchange monitored by mass spectrometry, we analyzed dynamic motifs of D14, D3 and D53 in the D53-SKP1-D3-D14 complex assembly process and further identified two potential interfaces in D53 that are located in the N and D2 domains, respectively. Together, our results uncovered the dynamic conformational changes and built a model of the holo-complex D53-SKP1-D3-D14, offering valuable information for the biochemical and genetic mechanisms of SL perception and signal transduction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023conformational,
  author = {Simiao Liu and Jia Wang and Bin Song and Xinqi Gong and Huihui Liu and Qingliang Hu and Junhui Zhang and Qianqian Li and Jie Zheng and Hong‐Wei Wang and H. Eric Xu and Jiayang Li and Bing Wang},
  title = {{Conformational Dynamics of the D53−D3−D14 Complex in Strigolactone Signaling}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1093/pcp/pcad067},
}
Figure