Conformational Dynamics and Stability of U-Shaped and S-Shaped Amyloid β Assemblies

Gianvito Grasso, Martina Rebella, Stefano Muscat, Umberto Morbiducci, Jack A. Tuszyński, Andrea Danani, Marco A. DeriuInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced molecular dynamics simulations to compare the stability and dynamics of two proposed structural models (U-shaped and S-shaped) of amyloid-beta (Aβ) fibrils, key players in Alzheimer's disease. The findings suggest that the S-shaped Aβ fibril is significantly more stable and ordered than the U-shaped variant, offering crucial insights into the molecular basis of Aβ toxicity and potential therapeutic targets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a devastating neurodegenerative disorder linked to the aggregation of amyloid-beta (Aβ) peptides in the brain. While Aβ<sub>1-40</sub> is common, the slightly longer Aβ<sub>1-42</sub> is more toxic and forms fibrils faster. Understanding the precise molecular structure and dynamics of these Aβ fibrils is critical because their conformation is thought to directly correlate with their toxicity and the progression of AD. Previously, Aβ<sub>1-40</sub> fibrils were primarily described as U-shaped, while Aβ<sub>1-42</sub> was found to adopt both U-shaped and a more recently proposed S-shaped, three-stranded configuration. This paper aims to computationally investigate and compare the conformational dynamics and stability of these U-shaped and S-shaped Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> fibril models to determine which structure is more stable and why, thereby shedding light on the molecular underpinnings of Aβ toxicity.

Methods

The researchers employed Replica Exchange Molecular Dynamics (REMD) simulations. REMD is a powerful computational technique that runs multiple simulations of the same system at different temperatures (replicas). These replicas are periodically swapped based on their temperatures, allowing the system to explore a wider range of conformational states and overcome energy barriers that might trap standard molecular dynamics simulations. This method is particularly useful for studying complex systems like protein aggregation where many stable and metastable states can exist.

Specifically, they simulated pentameric (five-peptide) models of both the U-shaped (derived from PDB ID: 2BEG) and S-shaped (derived from PDB ID: 2MXU) Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> fibrils. These simulations were performed in an explicit water and ion environment to mimic physiological conditions.

To analyze the simulation data, they used several metrics:

  • Root Mean Square Fluctuation (RMSF): Measures the average atomic movement of each residue, indicating flexibility and instability.
  • Secondary Structure Probability: Assesses the likelihood of residues adopting specific secondary structures (like beta-sheets or coils) over time.
  • Solvent Accessible Surface Area (SASA): Quantifies the exposed surface area of the fibril to the solvent, relating to compactness.
  • Interatomic Interactions: Analyzed contact probabilities, hydrophobic, and hydrophilic interactions between peptide chains to understand stabilizing forces.
  • Order Parameter (ordP): Quantifies the overall alignment of the fibril chains along the fibril axis, indicating structural order.
  • Functional Mode Analysis (FMA): A technique to identify collective motions that drive the structural changes and destabilization of the fibril.

Datasets

The study utilized existing structural models of Aβ fibrils as starting points for their simulations:

  • U-shaped Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> pentamer: Extracted from the PDB file 2BEG.
  • S-shaped Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> pentamer: Extracted from the PDB file 2MXU.

No new experimental datasets were generated or used for training/evaluation in this computational study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • S-shaped Fibril Dominance: The S-shaped Aβ fibril emerges as the more stable and ordered structure, challenging the notion that U-shaped conformations are universally stable for Aβ.
  • C-terminal Interactions are Key: The enhanced stability of the S-shaped model is strongly linked to maximized hydrophobic and hydrophilic interactions involving the C-terminal residues (I41 and A42). This suggests that these specific residues play a crucial role in locking the S-shaped structure.
  • U-shaped Fibril Instability: The U-shaped model exhibits significant distortions and higher fluctuations, particularly in its core and C-terminal regions, leading to a more disordered assembly.
  • Structural Polymorphism Matters: The existence of different fibril structures (polymorphism) is not just an academic curiosity; it directly impacts stability and likely toxicity, highlighting the importance of understanding these distinct conformations.
  • REMD's Power: The study underscores the utility of extensive REMD simulations (6 µs per model) in providing a more accurate and comprehensive picture of protein conformational landscapes compared to shorter simulations.

Key Results

  • RMSF Analysis: The C-terminal tail (V36–A42) of the U-shaped model showed significantly higher fluctuations (RMSFA42 = 0.87 ± 0.10 nm) compared to the S-shaped model (RMSFA42 = 0.56 ± 0.17 nm).
  • SASA: The U-shaped model had a slightly higher Solvent Accessible Surface Area (76.07 ± 4.17 nm²) than the S-shaped model (70.62 ± 3.71 nm²), suggesting the S-shaped model achieves a more compact arrangement.
  • Inter-chain Interactions: The S-shaped model demonstrated a higher probability of inter-chain contacts, particularly in the core and C-terminal regions, with specific hydrophobic contacts (I41–K28, I41–G29, A42–K28) found only in the S-shaped model.
  • Order Parameter: The S-shaped model exhibited a sharp distribution of the order parameter (peak near 0.95), indicating high structural order, while the U-shaped model showed a broader distribution (peak around 0.8), signifying distortion.
  • Functional Mode Analysis: FMA revealed that the U-shaped model undergoes more significant conformational changes and distortions, particularly in the core and C-terminal regions, leading to a loss of its original conformation. The S-shaped model, while showing some distortion in the N-terminal region, maintained overall better structural integrity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Size: The study focused on pentameric Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> fibrils. While this provides valuable insights, larger fibril assemblies might exhibit different dynamics and stability profiles.
  • Fragment of Aβ: The simulations used the Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> fragment. The full Aβ<sub>1-42</sub> peptide, including the unstructured N-terminal region (E11–K16), might influence the overall stability and interactions. The authors acknowledge that the presence of the E11-K16 structured domain in the S-shaped PDB model (2MXU) could potentially strengthen inter-chain hydrogen bonds in the L17-V24 region, a hypothesis supported by a comparison with an S-shaped<sub>11-42</sub> model.
  • Experimental Validation: While the computational findings support recent experimental proposals, direct experimental validation of the observed dynamics and stability differences would strengthen the conclusions.

Future work could involve simulating larger fibril assemblies, incorporating the full Aβ<sub>1-42</sub> sequence, and exploring the impact of potential therapeutic compounds on the stability of these different fibril structures. The authors suggest that the S-shaped model should be considered a target for rational drug design and optimization of compounds aimed at treating Alzheimer's disease.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alzheimer's disease is the most fatal neurodegenerative disorder characterized by the aggregation and deposition of Amyloid β (Aβ) oligomers in the brain of patients. Two principal variants of Aβ exist in humans: Aβ<sub>1-40</sub> and Aβ<sub>1-42</sub>. The former is the most abundant in the plaques, while the latter is the most toxic species and forms fibrils more rapidly. Interestingly, fibrils of Aβ<sub>1-40</sub> peptides can only assume U-shaped conformations while Aβ<sub>1-42</sub> can also arrange as S-shaped three-stranded chains, as recently discovered. As alterations in protein conformational arrangement correlate with cell toxicity and speed of disease progression, it is important to characterize, at molecular level, the conformational dynamics of amyloid fibrils. In this work, Replica Exchange Molecular Dynamics simulations were carried out to compare the conformational dynamics of U-shaped and S-shaped Aβ<sub>17-42</sub> small fibrils. Our computational results provide support for the stability of the recently proposed S-shaped model due to the maximized interactions involving the C-terminal residues. On the other hand, the U-shaped motif is characterized by significant distortions resulting in a more disordered assembly. Outcomes of our work suggest that the molecular architecture of the protein aggregates might play a pivotal role in formation and conformational stability of the resulting fibrils.
BibTeX
@article{grasso2018conformational,
  author = {Gianvito Grasso and Martina Rebella and Stefano Muscat and Umberto Morbiducci and Jack A. Tuszyński and Andrea Danani and Marco A. Deriu},
  title = {{Conformational Dynamics and Stability of U-Shaped and S-Shaped Amyloid β Assemblies}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms19020571},
}
Figure