Conformal and pure scale-invariant gravities in d dimensions

Anamaria Hell, Dieter LüstJournal of High Energy Physics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the behavior of conformal and scale-invariant gravitational theories in higher dimensions (d > 4). The authors find that while pure scale-invariant gravity has no propagating degrees of freedom in flat spacetime, it does in curved spacetime, resembling Einstein gravity. Conformal gravity, however, reveals a richer spectrum of propagating modes in higher dimensions compared to its 4D counterpart, including additional scalar and vector modes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The existence of extra spatial dimensions is a key feature in many theoretical frameworks aiming to unify fundamental forces and solve puzzles like the hierarchy problem. While the behavior of gravitational theories in four dimensions is well-understood, their generalization to higher dimensions, particularly for higher-derivative theories like conformal and scale-invariant gravities, remains less clear. Specifically, understanding the degrees of freedom (i.e., the fundamental propagating particles or fields) in these theories in d > 4 dimensions is crucial for their physical interpretation and potential observational consequences. This paper aims to clarify this by analyzing the structure and propagating modes of these theories in d dimensions.

Methods

The authors employ a standard technique in gravity research: transforming to different "frames" (e.g., Jordan frame vs. Einstein frame) to simplify the theory and identify propagating degrees of freedom. For scale-invariant gravity, they show that in the presence of a non-zero Ricci scalar, the theory can be recast into an Einstein-frame action with a scalar field and a cosmological constant. For conformal gravity, they find a frame where the action becomes bilinear in the Weyl tensor and coupled to a cosmological constant, which is then extended to more general $f(W^2)$ theories. The analysis of degrees of freedom involves perturbing the metric around various backgrounds (flat, conformally flat, and anisotropic) and analyzing the resulting linearized equations of motion and constraints. For a specific five-dimensional conformal gravity model, they derive and solve the background equations of motion analytically and numerically, and then analyze the perturbations around these solutions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scale-Invariant Gravity in d > 4: In flat spacetime, pure scale-invariant gravity (involving only the Ricci scalar) is surprisingly "trivial" in the Jordan frame, propagating no degrees of freedom. However, in curved spacetime, it can be transformed into an Einstein frame, revealing a scalar and two tensor modes, akin to Einstein gravity plus a cosmological constant. The sign of this cosmological constant is restricted to be positive in higher dimensions, unlike in 4D.
  • Conformal Gravity in d > 4: This theory exhibits a richer spectrum of propagating modes in higher dimensions than its 4D counterpart. While the scalar sector can be constrained, the theory generally propagates vector and tensor modes. Notably, in d > 4, there exist frames where conformal gravity can be written as Weyl-squared gravity with a cosmological constant, and this framework can be extended to $f(W^2)$ theories.
  • Anisotropic Solutions in 5D Conformal Gravity: The paper presents analytical and numerical solutions for a specific anisotropic cosmological background in 5D conformal gravity. These solutions exhibit interesting behaviors like super-Hubble and exponential expansions, with some directions showing phantom-like equations of state.
  • Increased Degrees of Freedom in Higher Dimensions: The analysis of perturbations in the 5D conformal gravity model reveals that the theory propagates additional scalar and vector modes compared to the 4D case. This suggests that higher-derivative gravity theories in higher dimensions can host a more complex spectrum of physical degrees of freedom.

Key Results

  • Pure scale-invariant gravity in d dimensions propagates no degrees of freedom in flat spacetime but propagates a scalar and two tensor modes in curved spacetime (in the Einstein frame).
  • Conformal gravity in d dimensions (d > 4) can be reformulated in a frame resembling Einstein gravity with a cosmological constant.
  • A specific 5D conformal gravity model admits anisotropic cosmological solutions with super-Hubble and exponential expansions.
  • Perturbation analysis of the 5D conformal gravity model indicates the presence of three scalar modes and three vector modes per index, in addition to tensor modes, which is more than in the 4D case.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the analysis of conformal gravity in conformally flat spacetimes is complicated by the non-decoupling of modes. The transformation to the alternative frame is valid for non-conformally flat spacetimes. Future work could explore the implications of adding other terms to the action or investigate methods to remove ghost degrees of freedom, potentially using boundary conditions in the alternative frame. The increased spectrum of modes in higher dimensions warrants further investigation into their physical implications and potential observational signatures.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We consider conformal and scale-invariant gravities in d dimensions, with a special focus on pure R 2 gravity in the scale-invariant case. In four dimensions, the structure of these theories is well known. However, in dimensions larger than four, the behavior of the modes is so far unclear. In this work, we explore this question, studying the theories in conformally flat spacetimes as well as anisotropic backgrounds. First, we consider the pure theory in d-dimensions. We show that this theory propagates no degrees of freedom for flat space-time. Otherwise, we find the theory in the corresponding Einstein frame and show that it propagates a scalar field and two tensor modes, that arise from Einstein’s gravity. We then consider conformal gravity in d dimensions. We argue on the number of degrees of freedom for conformally flat space-times and show that for d > 4, there exists a frame in which this theory can be written as the Weyl-squared gravity with a cosmological constant, and also generalize this formulation to the f ( W ) 2 theories. Then, we consider the specific model of conformal gravity in five dimensions. We find the analytical and numerical solutions for the anisotropic Universe for this case, which admits super-Hubble and exponential expansions. Finally, we consider the perturbations around these solutions and study the number of the degrees of freedom.
BibTeX
@article{hell2025conformal,
  author = {Anamaria Hell and Dieter Lüst},
  title = {{Conformal and pure scale-invariant gravities in d dimensions}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep09(2025)202},
}
Figure