Conflicting Interactions among Protection Mechanisms for Machine Learning Models

Sebastian Szyller, N. AsokanAAAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Machine learning models are increasingly protected by multiple security and privacy mechanisms, but these mechanisms can interfere with each other, degrading overall effectiveness. This paper introduces a framework to analyze these conflicts and empirically demonstrates that common protection methods like differential privacy and adversarial training can negatively impact model ownership verification techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As machine learning (ML) models become more prevalent and valuable, they face a growing number of threats. Researchers have developed various defense mechanisms to protect against specific issues like model theft (ownership verification), privacy breaches (differential privacy), and adversarial attacks (model evasion). However, in real-world deployments, a single ML model often needs to be protected against multiple threats simultaneously. The critical problem this paper addresses is that these individual protection mechanisms, when combined, might not work as intended. A mechanism optimized for one security concern could inadvertently weaken another, leading to a net decrease in security or privacy. This potential for conflicting interactions has been largely overlooked.

Methods

The authors propose a framework for systematically analyzing pairwise interactions between ML protection mechanisms. Their core idea is to evaluate if a combination of mechanisms can achieve a sufficiently high level of protection for all concerns, alongside maintaining acceptable model performance (accuracy). They define "conflict" as a situation where combining mechanisms leads to a significant degradation in the effectiveness of one or more of them, or a substantial drop in model accuracy, beyond predefined acceptable thresholds.

They then apply this framework to study the interactions between:

  • Ownership Verification (OV) Mechanisms: Model Watermarking (WM), Dataset Inference (DI), and Radioactive Data (RADDATA).
  • Regularization-based Mechanisms: Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (DPSGD) and Adversarial Training (ADVTR).

The paper theoretically hypothesizes potential conflicts based on the underlying principles of these mechanisms and then empirically verifies these hypotheses through experiments. They also explore strategies to mitigate these conflicts, such as adjusting hyperparameters or decoupling the training objectives of different mechanisms.

Datasets

The study utilizes three benchmark datasets for training and evaluation:

  • MNIST: A dataset of handwritten digits.
  • FashionMNIST (FMNIST): A dataset of clothing articles.
  • CIFAR10: A dataset of small color images of animals and vehicles.

For the watermarking experiments, they use MNIST and FMNIST as the primary training data and the other as out-of-distribution (OOD) data for watermarks. For CIFAR10, they use GTSRB (German Traffic Sign Recognition Benchmark) as the OOD dataset for watermarking, following prior work.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interactions are Crucial: The paper strongly emphasizes that evaluating ML protection mechanisms in isolation is insufficient. Real-world deployment necessitates understanding how they interact when used together.
  • Conflicting Objectives: Many protection mechanisms rely on fundamentally different principles. For instance, watermarking often benefits from memorization of specific data patterns, while differential privacy aims to limit the influence of any single data point, creating a direct conflict.
  • No Universal "Sweet Spot": Attempts to resolve conflicts by simply relaxing hyperparameters of one mechanism often fail to find a balance that significantly improves the other without sacrificing too much.
  • Decoupling as a Potential Solution: Separating the training objectives for different mechanisms (e.g., training the watermark on OOD data while using DPSGD for the main dataset) can sometimes mitigate conflicts, particularly between watermarking and differential privacy.
  • RADDATA is Particularly Vulnerable: The Radioactive Data (RADDATA) watermarking technique appears to be highly susceptible to conflicts, especially with adversarial training, often becoming completely ineffective.

Key Results

The paper presents several key findings regarding pairwise interactions:

  • DPSGD vs. WM: DPSGD significantly degrades watermark effectiveness (drops by over 30pp), indicating a conflict.
  • DPSGD vs. RADDATA: RADDATA's effectiveness is reduced but remains high enough for verification, suggesting a minor conflict.
  • DPSGD vs. DI: Dataset Inference (DI) remains unaffected and shows no conflict with DPSGD.
  • ADVTR vs. WM: ADVTR does not significantly interfere with watermark effectiveness, but it does reduce model accuracy on adversarial examples.
  • ADVTR vs. RADDATA: RADDATA is rendered ineffective when combined with ADVTR, as ADVTR drops almost to zero. This is a clear conflict.
  • ADVTR vs. DI: DI remains unaffected and shows no conflict with ADVTR.

Overall, model accuracy (ACC) generally remains close to baseline levels when mechanisms are combined, but the effectiveness of specific protection mechanisms can be severely impacted.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Focus on Pairwise Interactions: This study primarily examines pairs of mechanisms. Future work should explore combinations of three or more mechanisms, which could lead to a combinatorial explosion of potential conflicts.
  • Model Size and Convergence: While they ensured models reached low training loss and expected accuracy, they suggest that insufficient model capacity or convergence issues could theoretically contribute to conflicts, though their experiments didn't strongly indicate this.
  • Specific Mechanisms: The study focuses on a subset of popular protection mechanisms. The landscape of ML security is vast, and many other mechanisms and their interactions remain unexplored.
  • Practical Deployment Considerations: The paper touches upon the complexity of real-world ML deployments with multiple stakeholders and the need for communication about compatible mechanisms.

Future work should extend the analysis to more complex combinations, investigate novel mechanisms, and develop more robust strategies for resolving or avoiding these conflicts in practical ML systems. The authors also highlight the need for researchers to evaluate protection mechanisms in the context of other common concerns, moving beyond isolated assessments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{szyller2023conflicting,
  author = {Sebastian Szyller and N. Asokan},
  title = {{Conflicting Interactions among Protection Mechanisms for Machine Learning Models}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v37i12.26771},
}

Loading related content...

Figure