Cone Semantics for Logics with Negation

Özgür Lütfü Özçep, Mena Leemhuis, Diedrich WolterIJCAI 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel way to represent ontologies (structured knowledge) using geometric shapes called "al-cones" in a vector space. This approach allows for a more faithful representation of logical negation and concept relationships, bridging the gap between symbolic knowledge representation and machine learning techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional methods for embedding knowledge graphs and ontologies into vector spaces often struggle to capture the full expressivity of logical reasoning, particularly when it comes to negation and complex concept relationships. While some approaches can embed relationships, they often simplify or omit crucial logical structures, leading to a loss of information. This paper aims to address this by developing a geometric embedding method that can faithfully represent ontologies expressed in the description logic ALC, including concept negation and disjunction, while maintaining a connection to machine learning.

Methods

The core of this paper is the introduction of "al-cone models" for representing ALC ontologies. Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Al-Cones: These are specific types of geometric shapes (axis-aligned cones) in a multi-dimensional vector space. They are derived from unions of hyperoctants and projections onto axes.
  • Polarity for Negation: Instead of standard set complement, the paper proposes using the "polar cone" operation to represent logical negation. This is motivated by the idea that polarity provides a more intuitive model of negation in similarity-based structures, ensuring that the negation of a concept is maximally disjoint from the original concept.
  • Boolean ALC Embedding: For the propositional fragment of ALC (dealing with conjunction, disjunction, and negation), the authors show that an ontology is satisfiable classically if and only if it can be represented by an al-cone interpretation. This involves mapping atomic concepts to specific al-cones and defining operations like intersection and negation based on geometric operations on these cones.
  • Non-Boolean ALC Embedding: The paper extends this to the full ALC logic, including existential and universal quantifiers. This is achieved by defining quantifiers based on the universal quantifier and ensuring certain properties hold for the geometric interpretation of roles and concepts. They also introduce the concept of "faithful geometric models" to ensure that the geometric representation accurately reflects the ontology's logical entailments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical foundations and formal proofs rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometric Negation: Using the polar cone for negation is a key insight. It offers a more robust way to model logical negation in a geometric setting than simple set complement, especially when dealing with convex sets.
  • Al-Cones as a Bridge: Al-cones provide a flexible yet structured geometric representation that can capture complex logical relationships, acting as a bridge between symbolic logic and continuous vector spaces used in machine learning.
  • Faithfulness is Crucial: The concept of "faithful geometric models" highlights the importance of ensuring that the geometric embedding not only represents the ontology but also accurately reflects its logical consequences, including partial information.
  • Partial Models for Uncertainty: The al-cone approach naturally leads to partial models, where some objects might not be definitively assigned to a concept. This is valuable for representing uncertainty inherent in real-world knowledge.

Key Results

The paper's main results are theoretical:

  • Satisfiability Equivalence: An ALC ontology is classically satisfiable if and only if it is satisfiable by a geometric model based on al-cones. This is proven for both the Boolean fragment and the full ALC logic.
  • Construction of Models: The paper provides constructive methods for building these geometric models, demonstrating how to map logical concepts and relationships to al-cones and their operations.
  • Faithful Embeddings: The authors show that strongly concept-faithful and tbox-faithful geometric models can be constructed for satisfiable ALC ontologies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Role Interpretation: While the paper defines semantics for roles and quantifiers, it notes that roles are interpreted as crisp relations, not cones. An open problem is whether roles can be interpreted by cones or other feasible geometric structures.
  • Computational Feasibility: The paper focuses on theoretical completeness. The practical computational complexity of constructing and using these al-cone models for large ontologies is not deeply explored.
  • Handling Uncertainty: The paper mentions that the partial models naturally arising from this approach could be further enhanced by epistemic operators to distinguish between instances known to be in a concept versus those that could be.
  • ML Applications: While the motivation is to link KR and ML, the paper primarily lays the theoretical groundwork. Future work could explore how these al-cone embeddings can be directly utilized in machine learning tasks like prediction or classification.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{ozcep2020cone,
  author = {Özgür Lütfü Özçep and Mena Leemhuis and Diedrich Wolter},
  title = {{Cone Semantics for Logics with Negation}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2020/252},
}
Figure