Conductance and thermopower of ballistic Andreev cavities

Thomas Engl, Jack Kuipers, Klaus RichterPhysical 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a semiclassical approach to investigate how superconductors affect the electrical conductance and thermopower of chaotic quantum dots. They find that the presence of superconductors can significantly alter these properties, with the effects depending on the number of superconducting channels and their phase differences, offering new insights into quantum transport in hybrid systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The behavior of electrons in nanoscale electronic devices is a complex area of physics. When a superconductor, a material that conducts electricity with zero resistance below a critical temperature, is brought into contact with a normal conducting material, a phenomenon called Andreev reflection occurs. This process involves electrons entering the superconductor and creating a "hole" that travels back into the normal conductor. Understanding how these Andreev reflections influence the overall electrical properties, like conductance (how easily current flows) and thermopower (how temperature differences drive current), is crucial for designing future electronic devices. While previous work has explored these phenomena, this paper aims to provide a more comprehensive theoretical framework, particularly for systems with multiple superconductors and in the regime of many quantum channels, using a sophisticated semiclassical method.

Methods

The authors employ a "trajectory-based semiclassical approach." This method, building on prior work, allows them to analyze the quantum mechanical behavior of electrons by considering their classical trajectories. They extend existing techniques to systematically evaluate complex sums that arise from these trajectories, particularly focusing on "diagonal diagrams" that represent the main contributions to conductance. They introduce a diagrammatic language to represent these trajectories and their interactions, allowing them to systematically account for various configurations of normal and superconducting leads. This approach allows them to go beyond approximations used in earlier studies, particularly for systems with a larger number of superconducting channels.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Superconductors significantly modify conductance: The presence of even a single superconductor can alter the conductance of a quantum dot by an amount proportional to the number of superconducting channels.
  • Sign of quantum corrections is sensitive: The sign of the quantum correction to the standard Drude conductance depends critically on the relative number of channels in the superconducting and normal leads.
  • Phase matters for multiple superconductors: When two superconductors are present, their phase difference plays a crucial role in determining the conductance, leading to oscillatory behavior.
  • Superconducting leads mimic N-S junctions: Under specific conditions, when a superconductor shares the same chemical potential as a normal lead, the system exhibits behaviors similar to a simpler normal metal-superconductor junction.
  • Thermopower is antisymmetric: The thermopower of these systems is found to be antisymmetric with respect to the phase difference of the superconductors, a purely quantum mechanical effect.

Key Results

The paper provides a detailed theoretical framework for calculating the conductance and thermopower of ballistic chaotic quantum dots coupled to one or two superconductors. They reproduce existing results from random matrix theory and extend them to higher orders in the ratio of superconducting to normal channels ($N_S/N_N$). Key findings include:

  • The conductance correction can be positive or negative depending on the ratio of channels in the normal and superconducting leads.
  • For two superconductors, the conductance exhibits a 2π periodicity with respect to their phase difference, and the correction can change sign.
  • In the case where a superconductor shares the chemical potential with a normal lead, the conductance correction can become negative for certain ratios of lead channels, and it can also exhibit a sign change as the size of the superconductor increases.
  • The thermopower is found to be antisymmetric in the phase difference of the superconductors, a result that holds to all orders in the channel number ratio.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their results are primarily valid for leading order in the inverse channel number (1/N). They suggest that future work could involve calculating subleading order terms, particularly weak localization corrections, which would require developing new systematic methods for finding and evaluating diagrams. They also note that extending the calculation to a higher number of superconductors or incorporating non-zero Ehrenfest times (a measure of how long particles spend in a particular region) would be valuable future directions. Experimental verification of their theoretical predictions is also highlighted as an important next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

When coupling a superconductor to a normal conducting region the physical properties of the system are highly affected by the superconductor. We investigate the effect of one or two superconductors on the conductance of a ballistic chaotic quantum dot to leading order in the total channel number using trajectory-based semiclassics. The results show that the effect of one superconductor on the conductance is of the order of the number of channels and that the sign of the quantum correction from the Drude conductance depends on the particular ratios of the numbers of channels of the superconducting and normal conducting leads. In the case of two superconductors with the same chemical potential, we additionally study how the conductance and the sign of quantum corrections are affected by their phase difference. As far as random matrix theory results exist these are reproduced by our calculations. Furthermore, in the case that the chemical potential of the superconductors is the same as that of one of the two normal leads the conductance shows, under certain conditions, similar effects as a normal metal-superconductor junction. The semiclassical framework is also able to treat the thermopower of chaotic Andreev billiards consisting of one chaotic dot, two normal leads, and two superconducting islands and shows it to be antisymmetric in the phase difference of the superconductors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{engl2011conductance,
  author = {Thomas Engl and Jack Kuipers and Klaus Richter},
  title = {{Conductance and thermopower of ballistic Andreev cavities}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.83.205414},
}
Figure