Conditions for the compatibility of channels in general probabilistic theory and their connection to steering and Bell nonlocality

Martin PlávalaPhysical 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We derive general conditions for the compatibility of channels in general probabilistic theory. We introduce formalism that allows us to easily formulate steering by channels and Bell nonlocality of channels as generalizations of the well-known concepts of steering by measurements and Bell nonlocality of measurements. The generalization does not follow the standard line of thinking stemming from the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox, but introduces steering and Bell nonlocality as entanglement-assisted incompatibility tests. We show that all of the proposed definitions are, in the special case of measurements, the same as the standard definitions, but not all of the known results for measurements generalize to channels. For example, we show that for quantum channels, steering is not a necessary condition for Bell nonlocality. We further investigate the introduced conditions and concepts in the special case of quantum theory and we provide many examples to demonstrate these concepts and their implications.

Introduction

In quantum mechanics, "incompatibility"—the inability to perform two operations simultaneously, such as measuring position and momentum—is the fundamental engine behind phenomena like steering and Bell nonlocality. Historically, these concepts were defined strictly for measurements, which are operations that transform a quantum state into a classical result.

However, measurements are merely a subset of quantum channels, which are more general processes that transform one state into another. While the relationship between measurement incompatibility and non-locality is well-understood, the operational connection between channel incompatibility, steering, and Bell nonlocality has remained less clear. This paper bridges that gap by creating a unified formalism within the framework of General Probabilistic Theory (GPT), applicable to quantum mechanics, classical theory, and other hypothetical models.

The Framework of General Probabilistic Theory

The research utilizes the mathematical framework of GPT, which treats state spaces as compact convex sets and effects (measurements) as affine functions. This abstraction allows the author to demonstrate that many "quantum" properties are actually general features of any theory with specific convex geometry, stripping away theory-specific peculiarities to reveal underlying logical structures.

Operational Compatibility

Two channels are defined as compatible if they can be viewed as "marginals" of a single joint channel. Operationally, this means a state can be passed through a single device, and the observer can later choose which channel's output to examine. The paper derives a general mathematical condition ($J(\Phi) = (\Phi_1, \Phi_2)$) to determine this compatibility across any GPT.

Steering and Bell Nonlocality as Incompatibility Tests

A key methodological shift in this work is the redefinition of steering and Bell nonlocality as entanglement-assisted incompatibility tests rather than following the historical Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox line of reasoning.

  • Steering is formulated as a one-sided test where one party uses entanglement to probe the incompatibility of another's channel.
  • Bell Nonlocality is formulated as a two-sided test.

For the specific case of quantum theory, the author formulates channel compatibility as a Semi-Definite Program (SDP), making it computationally checkable. A significant result in this area is the proof that any pair of incompatible quantum channels can be used to "steer" a maximally entangled state, providing a direct link between abstract mathematical incompatibility and the physical resource of steering.

The Breakdown of the Measurement Hierarchy

The most striking discovery of this research is the breakdown of the traditional hierarchy of non-classicality. In the world of measurements, there is a strict progression: Bell Nonlocality $\implies$ Steering $\implies$ Incompatibility.

However, the author proves that for channels, Bell nonlocality does not necessarily imply steering. Using a specific three-qubit entangled state known as the "W-state," the author constructs a scenario where a state is Bell nonlocal but cannot be steered by any pair of channels. This suggests that channels possess a more complex structure of non-classicality than measurements, where the ability to violate local realism (Bell nonlocality) can be decoupled from the ability to influence a distant state (steering).

Generalized CHSH Inequality

The paper introduces a version of the famous CHSH inequality specifically for channels. Remarkably, even in this generalized setting, the Tsirelson bound ($2\sqrt{2}$) still holds and is reachable. This consistency extends to the definitions themselves; when the new channel-based definitions are restricted to measurements, they perfectly recover the standard, well-known definitions of steering and Bell nonlocality.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work provides a robust theoretical foundation for understanding how general transformations—not just measurements—interact with entanglement and non-locality. While the results are currently restricted to finite-dimensional systems and two-channel compatibility, they set the stage for several future directions:

  • Extending the geometry to $N$ channels.
  • Addressing the definition of "complete positivity" within GPT tensor products.
  • Exploring the potential Bayesian connections between GPT conditional states and inference.

By proving these results in the abstract GPT framework, the research clarifies which aspects of non-locality are uniquely quantum and which are inherent to the geometry of probabilistic theories.

Summary updated

Abstract

We derive general conditions for the compatibility of channels in general probabilistic theory. We introduce formalism that allows us to easily formulate steering by channels and Bell nonlocality of channels as generalizations of the well-known concepts of steering by measurements and Bell nonlocality of measurements. The generalization does not follow the standard line of thinking stemming from the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox, but introduces steering and Bell nonlocality as entanglement-assisted incompatibility tests. We show that all of the proposed definitions are, in the special case of measurements, the same as the standard definitions, but not all of the known results for measurements generalize to channels. For example, we show that for quantum channels, steering is not a necessary condition for Bell nonlocality. We further investigate the introduced conditions and concepts in the special case of quantum theory and we provide many examples to demonstrate these concepts and their implications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{plavala2017conditions,
  author = {Martin Plávala},
  title = {{Conditions for the compatibility of channels in general probabilistic theory and their connection to steering and Bell nonlocality}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.96.052127},
}
Figure