Concepts, Structure and Developments of High-Reliability Cyber-Physical Fusion Based Coordinated Planning for Distribution System

Chong Gao, Tianlin Wang, Huazhen Cao, Ziyao Wang, Tao Yu, Ran ChengFrontiers in Energy Research 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Coordinated control is imperative for the distribution network with the integration of wind power, photovoltaic system, and energy storage system. Meanwhile, the advanced automation terminal, intelligent control technology, and information communication technologies have greatly promoted the informatization of distribution networks which also increase the correlation between the physical system (primary system) and the cyber system (secondary system). Hence, it is critical to comprehensively coordinate the planning of the cyber-physical system for building a highly reliable power grid. This work summarizes a series of challenges brought by the highly coupled cyber-physical system, such as the primary and secondary collaborated planning models and solution algorithms. Then, the reliability assessment theories of cyber-physical systems and their application in distribution network planning models are introduced. Finally, three development directions of distribution network planning in the future are proposed, considering primary and secondary system coordinated planning.

Introduction: The Shift to Cyber-Physical Fusion

Traditionally, power system engineering treated the "primary system" (physical infrastructure like wires and transformers) and the "secondary system" (sensors, communication, and control) as independent domains. However, the modern distribution network, characterized by volatile renewable energy sources like wind and solar, requires high-speed automated coordination. This shift necessitates a "cyber-physical fusion" approach.

The coupling between these systems introduces new vulnerabilities. As demonstrated by incidents like the 2015 Ukraine blackout, failures in the cyber layer—whether from communication delays, hardware malfunctions, or malicious attacks—can directly trigger physical grid failures. Planning must now account for these interdependencies to ensure resilience against both physical faults and cyber disturbances.

Interaction between Cyber and Physical Systems under various disturbances.

A Unified CPS Architecture

To address these challenges, the paper proposes a structured Cyber-Physical System (CPS) architecture. This framework moves beyond isolated planning toward a unified model that treats the grid as a single integrated entity.

The Four-Layer Model

The proposed architecture is divided into four distinct layers that facilitate the flow of information and power:

  1. Backbone Layer: High-level management and wide-area communication (e.g., SCADA and MIS servers).
  2. Access Layer: Local substation and transformer communication networks using technologies like EPON or wireless networks.
  3. Interface Layer: Utilizing Intelligent Electronic Devices (IEDs) to bridge the digital and physical worlds.
  4. Physical Layer: The actual power distribution hardware, including renewable sources (WT, PV) and energy storage systems (ESS).
The basic four-layer structure of a Cyber-Physical System (CPS) in power distribution.

Coordinated Planning and Reliability

The core of this research is a multi-level optimization model for coordinated planning. The objective is to minimize a total cost function defined as: $Investment + Operating + Reliability$. This model accounts for binary investment variables (e.g., whether to build a new line) and continuous operating variables (e.g., power flow levels).

Redefining Reliability

Traditional "N-1" hardware reliability is no longer sufficient for modern grids. The authors advocate for advanced metrics such as "information entropy" and "delay reliability." Information entropy helps quantify the disordered state of physical nodes based on cyber-control signals, providing a more granular view of grid health than simple binary status checks.

Algorithmic Challenges

Coordinated planning is computationally intensive (NP-hard). The paper evaluates the trade-offs between classical mathematical optimization, which ensures global solutions but struggles with high-dimensional non-convexity, and intelligent algorithms like Genetic Algorithms, which offer flexibility at the risk of converging on local optima.

Key Insights and Future Directions

  • Secondary System Risks: Automation terminals, while intended to improve reliability, can expand fault ranges if they fail or are misconfigured. The "Three Remotes" strategy (tele-signaling, tele-metering, and tele-control) is essential but must be balanced against economic returns to avoid "blind allocation."
  • Cyber-Physical-Social Systems (CPSS): Future planning needs to evolve into CPSS, accounting for market mechanisms, policy changes, and human behavior in demand response.
  • Technological Integration: While technologies like IoT, Cloud Computing, and 5G are promising, their specific inherent defects (such as signal blocking in wireless communications) must be accurately modeled in grid planning.

Conclusion

High-reliability power grids in the renewable era are no longer just about "stronger wires." They depend fundamentally on the timeliness and accuracy of the data flowing through the secondary system. Coordinated cyber-physical planning is the only viable path to a resilient and efficient energy future.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coordinated control is imperative for the distribution network with the integration of wind power, photovoltaic system, and energy storage system. Meanwhile, the advanced automation terminal, intelligent control technology, and information communication technologies have greatly promoted the informatization of distribution networks which also increase the correlation between the physical system (primary system) and the cyber system (secondary system). Hence, it is critical to comprehensively coordinate the planning of the cyber-physical system for building a highly reliable power grid. This work summarizes a series of challenges brought by the highly coupled cyber-physical system, such as the primary and secondary collaborated planning models and solution algorithms. Then, the reliability assessment theories of cyber-physical systems and their application in distribution network planning models are introduced. Finally, three development directions of distribution network planning in the future are proposed, considering primary and secondary system coordinated planning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2021concepts,
  author = {Chong Gao and Tianlin Wang and Huazhen Cao and Ziyao Wang and Tao Yu and Ran Cheng},
  title = {{Concepts, Structure and Developments of High-Reliability Cyber-Physical Fusion Based Coordinated Planning for Distribution System}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2021.697959},
}
Figure