Concentration dependent energy levels shifts in donor-acceptor mixtures due to intermolecular electrostatic interaction

Saientan Bag, Pascal Friederich, Ivan Kondov, Wolfgang WenzelScientific 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Recent progress in the improvement of organic solar cells has led to power conversion efficiencies exceeding 16%. A critical factor in this advancement is the favorable energy level alignment between donor and acceptor materials, highlighting the importance of the interfaces between these regions. Recent studies have shown that the energy levels of organic semiconductors shift significantly upon mixing with different materials, though the origin of this effect has remained unclear. This study utilizes multiscale simulation protocols to investigate the molecular basis of these mixing-induced shifts. The findings reveal that electrostatic properties—specifically higher-order multipole moments and polarizability—determine the magnitude of these shifts. These insights provide a roadmap for future material design aimed at optimizing device performance through the systematic modification of molecular properties.

Introduction

The efficiency of organic solar cells (OSCs) is fundamentally tied to the energy level alignment at the donor-acceptor interface. For efficient charge separation, the Ionization Potential (IP) and Electron Affinity (EA) of the constituent materials must be precisely tuned. However, it has been observed that these energy levels are not intrinsic constants of the materials but rather shift depending on the mixing ratio of the donor and acceptor. While experimental data have documented these concentration-dependent shifts, the underlying physical mechanisms—whether driven by molecular polarization or fundamental charge distribution—have been a subject of debate. Understanding these shifts is essential for the rational design of next-generation OSCs.

Methodology

To investigate the molecular environment of donor-acceptor mixtures, a multiscale simulation protocol was employed:

  1. Morphology Generation: Atomistically resolved amorphous morphologies of mixtures containing Fullerene ($C_{60}$) and various donor molecules were generated using a Metropolis Monte Carlo-based simulated annealing protocol.
  2. Quantum Patch Method: The "Quantum Patch" approach was used to calculate IP and EA levels. This method evaluates total energy differences between charged and neutral states within large molecular clusters, explicitly accounting for the surrounding electrostatic environment.
  3. Electronic Structure Calculations: Calculations were performed at the Hybrid Density Functional Theory level (B3-LYP/def2-SV(P)).
  4. Multipole Analysis: The electrostatic potential of the molecules was decomposed into a multipole expansion (dipole, quadrupole, octupole, and 16-pole moments) to identify the primary drivers of the energy level shifts.

Molecular Systems and Data

The study focused on a set of benchmark molecular systems widely used in organic electronics. The primary acceptor used was $C_{60}$, paired with various donor molecules including NPB, rubrene, bDIP, and sexithiophene (6T).

Chemical structures of the molecules investigated: a) C60, b) NPB, c) Rubrene, d) bDIP, and e) Sexithiophene (6T).

These systems were chosen to provide a range of symmetries and electronic properties, allowing for a comprehensive validation against existing experimental benchmarks.

Results and Discussion

The Dominance of Static Electrostatics

A key finding of this research is that "dynamic polarization"—the environment's response to a charge—is not the primary cause of concentration-dependent shifts. While polarization accounts for the absolute energy shift from vacuum to the solid state, it remains relatively constant across different mixing ratios.

Instead, the shifts are driven by the static electrostatic potential generated by the donor molecules. Molecules with lower symmetry, such as 6T and bDIP, possess significant quadrupole moments. These moments create a local negative electrostatic potential that shifts the orbital energies of neighboring molecules upward, effectively reducing their IP. In contrast, highly symmetric molecules like $C_{60}$ produce negligible net electrostatic potential.

Quantitative Analysis

The simulations successfully reproduced experimental trends. In mixtures with 6T and bDIP, large IP shifts were observed, whereas rubrene and NPB showed minimal changes. Specifically, in a mixture with 90% 6T, the IP of $C_{60}$ shifted by approximately -0.4 eV, a massive change in the context of solar cell energetics. Multipole expansion confirmed that the quadrupole moment was the dominant source of the net electrostatic potential, which exceeded -0.1 eV at the center of neighboring molecules for 6T and bDIP.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This study demonstrates that the energy level shifts in organic semiconductor mixtures are primarily an electrostatic phenomenon rooted in molecular multipole moments. By identifying the quadrupole moment as a key driver, this work opens the door to "electrostatic engineering." Chemists can now theoretically tune the energy levels of donor-acceptor mixtures by strategically adding functional groups to modify a molecule's multipole moments. Future research will likely focus on applying these principles to crystalline interfaces and exploring how systematic molecular modifications can further optimize solar cell efficiency.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent progress in the improvement of organic solar cells lead to a power conversion efficiency to over 16%. One of the key factors for this improvement is a more favorable energy level alignment between donor and acceptor materials, which demonstrates that the properties of interfaces between donor and acceptor regions are of paramount importance. Recent investigations showed a significant dependence of the energy levels of organic semiconductors upon admixture of different materials, but its origin is presently not well understood. Here, we use multiscale simulation protocols to investigate the molecular origin of the mixing induced energy level shifts and show that electrostatic properties, in particular higher-order multipole moments and polarizability determine the strength of the effect. The findings of this study may guide future material-design efforts in order to improve device performance by systematic modification of molecular properties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bag2019concentration,
  author = {Saientan Bag and Pascal Friederich and Ivan Kondov and Wolfgang Wenzel},
  title = {{Concentration dependent energy levels shifts in donor-acceptor mixtures due to intermolecular electrostatic interaction}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-48877-9},
}
Figure