Concentration Bounds for the Collision Estimator

Maciej SkorskiarXiv 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a powerful new theoretical tool for analyzing the "collision estimator," a fundamental building block in areas like cryptography and property testing. The authors provide the first strong concentration bounds for this estimator, showing it can achieve reliable results on its own without needing multiple runs, which was a significant limitation of prior work.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "collision estimator" is a statistical tool that counts how often identical items appear in a sample drawn from some underlying distribution. This is crucial for tasks like checking if a distribution is uniform (e.g., a fair coin flip) or estimating the "entropy" of a distribution, which measures its randomness. While the average behavior (variance) of this estimator has been studied, understanding its high-probability behavior – how likely it is to be close to the true value – has been a major challenge. Previous methods could only provide weak guarantees, forcing researchers to run the estimator many times in parallel and take a majority vote (a technique called "boosting") to get reliable results. This paper aims to close this gap by providing tight concentration bounds, effectively showing the estimator is much more reliable than previously thought.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of sophisticated mathematical techniques. A key innovation is the use of "negative dependence" properties, which allow them to treat certain parts of the estimator as if they were independent, simplifying analysis. They also delve into "subtle moment methods," moving beyond standard concentration inequalities that struggle with the quadratic nature of the collision estimator and the rarity of the events involved. This involves techniques like "centering," "symmetrization," and "decoupling" to relate the estimator's moments to those of binomial distributions. Finally, they leverage sharp bounds on binomial moments and introduce an "auxiliary function" to manage the complexity of the analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The collision estimator is more reliable than we thought: The paper demonstrates that the collision estimator, on its own, can provide strong high-probability guarantees. This means we can often avoid the computationally expensive "boosting" techniques previously required.
  • New theoretical tools for quadratic forms: The paper introduces elegant techniques for bounding the moments of quadratic forms of random variables, particularly when those variables are "rare" or have low probability. This has broader implications beyond just the collision estimator.
  • Bridging the gap between variance and concentration: By bounding higher moments, the authors provide a more complete picture of the estimator's behavior, connecting its variance to its overall concentration properties.
  • "Sub-gamma" distributions are key: The analysis reveals that the collision estimator's behavior can be characterized by sub-gamma distributions, a class of distributions with well-behaved tails that allows for strong concentration bounds.

Key Results

The paper's main contribution is Theorem 1, which provides a strong concentration bound for the collision estimator. Specifically, it shows that the probability of the estimator deviating from its true value by more than $\epsilon$ is bounded by $O(1) \exp(-\Omega(\min(\epsilon^2/v^2, \epsilon/b, n\sqrt{\epsilon})))$, where $v^2$ and $b$ are parameters derived from the underlying distribution. This bound is significantly tighter than what was previously achievable and implies that the estimator can achieve high-probability guarantees with a sample size $n$ that is often sublinear in the domain size. Corollaries derived from this theorem show that this leads to optimal or near-optimal sample complexity for applications like uniformity testing and Rényi entropy estimation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their techniques are primarily theoretical and focus on deriving these strong concentration bounds. While they demonstrate the implications for uniformity testing and entropy estimation, further work could explore practical implementations and optimizations based on these new theoretical guarantees. The paper also suggests that the techniques developed could be applicable to other problems where standard concentration inequalities are insufficient, hinting at broader future research directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We prove a strong concentration result about the natural collision estimator, which counts the number of collisions that occur within an iid sample. This estimator is at the heart of algorithms used for uniformity testing and entropy assessment. While the prior works were limited to only variance, we use elegant techniques of independent interest to bounds higher moments and conclude concentration properties. As an immediate corollary we show that the estimator achieves high-probability guarantee on its own and there is no need for boosting (aka median/majority trick).
BibTeX
@misc{skorski2020concentration,
  author = {Maciej Skorski},
  title = {{Concentration Bounds for the Collision Estimator}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2006.07366},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.07366},
}

Loading related content...

Figure