Computing the Volume of a Restricted Independent Set Polytope Deterministically

David Gamarnik, Devin SmediraarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Computing the volume of a convex body is a foundational challenge in computational geometry and theoretical computer science. While calculating the exact volume of a polytope is known to be #P-hard, researchers have historically relied on randomized algorithms—specifically Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods—to provide a Fully Polynomial Time Randomized Approximation Scheme (FPRAS). However, a significant theoretical gap remains: the development of deterministic algorithms for volume estimation.

While it has been proven that deterministic algorithms cannot approximate the volume of general convex bodies described only by a membership oracle, the problem remains open for polytopes explicitly defined by linear inequalities. This paper presents the first deterministic, quasi-polynomial time approximation algorithm for a specific class of "restricted independent set" polytopes, bridging the gap between continuous geometry and discrete approximate counting.

The Restricted Independent Set Polytope

The study focuses on the linear programming relaxation of the independent set problem. For a graph $G = (V, E)$, the independent set polytope is defined by the constraints $x_u + x_v \leq 1$ for every edge $(u, v) \in E$, with $x_v \geq 0$. The authors introduce a restriction parameter $\alpha$, capping each variable such that $0 \leq x_v \leq 1 - \alpha$.

This restriction is crucial. When $\alpha \geq 1/2$, the constraints do not overlap, rendering the problem trivial. The research explores the regime where $\alpha$ is slightly less than $1/2$, a boundary where the geometric complexity increases significantly. The goal is to compute the volume of this restricted polytope deterministically.

Methodology: From Geometry to Discrete Counting

The authors employ a strategy that translates the continuous volume problem into a discrete counting problem through four primary steps:

  1. Discretization: The continuous volume is approximated by counting integer points within a finely scaled version of the polytope. By using a relaxation parameter $N$, the volume computation is transformed into a partition function estimation problem.
  2. Correlation Decay: Borrowing from statistical physics, the authors utilize the correlation decay method. This approach assumes that in certain systems, the state of a node in a graph is primarily influenced by its immediate neighborhood, with the influence of distant nodes decaying exponentially.
  3. Recursive Marginal Computation: The algorithm sets up a recursion to compute "marginals"—the probability that a specific variable takes a certain value within the discretized space.
  4. Contraction Mapping: The core technical innovation lies in proving that this recursion is a contraction. By demonstrating that the $L_1$ norm of the gradient of the recursive function is strictly less than 1, the authors ensure that errors do not propagate or explode as the algorithm traverses the graph.

Notably, the authors observe that the interpolation method—another prominent deterministic approach based on the complex roots of partition functions—fails for this specific problem. In a single-node graph, the roots of the associated polynomial cluster too densely around the value 1, making correlation decay the only viable deterministic path forward.

Theoretical Results and Complexity

The research produces a Fully Quasi-Polynomial Time Deterministic Approximation Scheme (FQPTDAS). The algorithm's performance is characterized by:

  • Efficiency: The algorithm runs in $|V|^{O(\log |V|/\epsilon)}$ time, where $|V|$ represents the number of vertices and $\epsilon$ is the error tolerance.
  • Applicability: The method is valid as long as $\alpha > 1/2 - O(1/\Delta^2)$, where $\Delta$ is the maximum degree of the graph. For example, in a graph with $\Delta = 3$, the algorithm functions when $0.488 < \alpha < 0.5$. As the graph density increases, the required buffer $\alpha$ must move closer to $0.5$.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work represents a significant step toward deterministic volume computation for combinatorial polytopes. By treating volume as the limit of idealized discrete counting, the authors have successfully ported tools from the field of approximate counting to continuous geometry.

The primary limitation remains the narrow range of the restriction parameter $\alpha$. The current "single-step" contraction analysis fails as $\alpha$ approaches 0 (the unrestricted independent set polytope). Future research will likely focus on improving the running time to truly polynomial and developing multi-step contraction or spectral independence techniques to handle the unrestricted case, potentially generalizing this approach to a broader array of combinatorial polytopes.

Summary updated

Abstract

We construct a quasi-polynomial time deterministic approximation algorithm for computing the volume of an independent set polytope with restrictions. Randomized polynomial time approximation algorithms for computing the volume of a convex body have been known now for several decades, but the corresponding deterministic counterparts are not available, and our algorithm is the first of this kind. The class of polytopes for which our algorithm applies arises as linear programming relaxation of the independent set problem with the additional restriction that each variable takes value in the interval $[0,1-α]$ for some $α<1/2$. (We note that the $α\ge 1/2$ case is trivial). We use the correlation decay method for this problem applied to its appropriate and natural discretization. The method works provided $α> 1/2-O(1/Δ^2)$, where $Δ$ is the maximum degree of the graph. When $Δ=3$ (the sparsest non-trivial case), our method works provided $0.488<α<0.5$. Interestingly, the interpolation method, which is based on analyzing complex roots of the associated partition functions, fails even in the trivial case when the underlying graph is a singleton.
BibTeX
@misc{gamarnik2023computing,
  author = {David Gamarnik and Devin Smedira},
  title = {{Computing the Volume of a Restricted Independent Set Polytope Deterministically}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2312.03906},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03906},
}
Figure