Computing probability intervals under independency constraints

Linda C. van der GaagUAI 1990

TL;DR

This paper introduces a method for computing probability intervals for uncertain events when only a partial specification of the joint probability distribution is known. It uniquely leverages independency relationships between variables, represented by graphical models, to derive tighter and more informative probability bounds than previous approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A common critique of applying probability theory in AI systems is its perceived inability to handle incomplete information, particularly distinguishing between uncertainty and ignorance. While probability intervals offer a way to express this incompleteness, existing methods often struggle when dealing with complex dependencies between variables. This paper addresses the challenge of computing meaningful probability intervals from a partial specification of a joint probability distribution, specifically by incorporating independency constraints that are often present in real-world scenarios. This is crucial because assuming full independence or complete specification can lead to overly wide or inaccurate probability bounds.

Methods

The core of the paper presents a framework for computing probability intervals by treating the given probabilities as constraints on an unknown joint probability distribution.

  1. Linear Algebra Formulation: The problem is transformed into a system of linear equations. The "constituent probabilities" (probabilities of the smallest atomic events in a Boolean algebra) are treated as unknowns. The given partial probabilities define constraints on these unknowns.
  2. Exploiting Independencies: The key novelty lies in incorporating independency relationships. These are represented by an "I-map" (a graph where missing edges imply independencies). The authors assume this I-map is "decomposable," meaning it has a specific graph structure (like a join tree) that simplifies computations.
  3. Marginal Distributions and Cliques: Independencies are exploited by focusing on marginal distributions over "cliques" (subsets of variables) in the decomposable graph. The problem is broken down into computing intervals for these marginals.
  4. Linear Programming: For each clique, a linear programming problem is formulated to find the maximum (or minimum) probability of an event of interest, subject to the constraints derived from the partial specification and independency relationships.
  5. Distributed Algorithm: A novel, distributed algorithm is proposed that operates on a "join tree" representation of the graph. This algorithm allows local computations at each clique, communicating information through independency constraints, effectively achieving a form of global knowledge without centralizing all data.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and algorithmic approach, not empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Independencies as Constraints: Independency relationships are not just assumptions but can be actively used as constraints to refine probability intervals, leading to more precise bounds.
  • Decomposable Graphs Simplify Complexity: The assumption of a decomposable I-map is critical. It allows the complex problem of global joint distribution constraints to be broken down into more manageable local computations on cliques.
  • Distributed Computation for Scalability: The proposed join-tree-based algorithm is a significant contribution, enabling computations to be distributed across nodes representing cliques. This is crucial for handling potentially large and complex dependency structures.
  • "Honest" Intervals: Even if the resulting probability intervals are wide, they are considered "honest" because they accurately reflect the remaining uncertainty and ignorance given the available information.

Key Results

The paper provides a theoretical framework and an algorithm for computing probability intervals that incorporate independency constraints. The key result is the demonstration that this can be done efficiently (in polynomial time if the maximal clique size is small) using linear programming and a distributed join-tree algorithm. While no specific quantitative results (e.g., accuracy improvements on a benchmark) are presented, the theoretical contribution is the development of a method that yields more precise intervals by leveraging structural independencies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Wide Intervals: The authors acknowledge that the computed probability intervals may still be "rather wide," though they emphasize their honesty in reflecting uncertainty.
  • Decomposable Graph Assumption: The method relies on the I-map being decomposable. Handling non-decomposable graphs would require further extensions.
  • Practicality of Small Maximal Clique Size: The algorithm's polynomial time complexity depends on the maximal clique size being small. The paper poses the question of how likely this restriction is to be met in practice.
  • Application to Belief Networks: The paper briefly suggests that the method can be useful for knowledge acquisition in belief networks, implying that further work could explore this application in detail. The authors note that current belief network models often require full quantification, and their method could help in stepwise quantification by providing intervals for missing probabilities.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{gaag1990computing,
  author = {Linda C. van der Gaag},
  title = {{Computing probability intervals under independency constraints}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1990},
}
Figure