Computing Cumulative Rewards Using Fast Adaptive Uniformisation

Frits Dannenberg, Ernst Moritz Hahn, Marta Z. KwiatkowskaCMSB 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper extends a technique called Fast Adaptive Uniformisation (FAU) to efficiently compute cumulative reward properties in continuous-time Markov chains (CTMCs). This allows for more accurate and faster analysis of complex biological and computer systems by directly calculating expected rewards over time, without needing to artificially inflate the model's complexity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Analyzing the behavior of complex systems, especially those modeled as continuous-time Markov chains (CTMCs), often involves not just understanding the probability of being in a certain state at a specific time, but also quantifying cumulative rewards. These rewards can represent things like the total number of reactions that have occurred or the total time spent in a particular state. Traditional methods for analyzing CTMCs, like uniformization, can become computationally expensive, especially for models with a very large or infinite number of states. While a technique called Fast Adaptive Uniformization (FAU) was developed to handle such large models for transient probabilities (probability of being in a state at time t), it was not directly applicable to cumulative reward properties. The challenge was to extend FAU to efficiently compute these cumulative rewards without resorting to computationally costly workarounds, such as adding extra states to the model to track rewards.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the extension of the Fast Adaptive Uniformization (FAU) method to handle cumulative reward properties in CTMCs. FAU, originally developed by Mateescu, works by dynamically discretizing the CTMC and adaptively exploring only the relevant states, thus managing large state spaces.

The authors achieve this extension by:

  • Time-Extended CTPMs: They introduce a theoretical framework using "time-extended CTPMs." This involves creating a new model where additional states are added to track the time spent in each original state. This allows them to formally reason about residence times and cumulative rewards.
  • Residence Time Theorem: They prove a theorem that relates the residence time in a state (how long the system stays in that state) to the FAU framework. This is crucial for accumulating rewards over time.
  • Cumulative Reward Definition and Approximation: They define cumulative rewards and then provide a method to approximate them using the extended FAU. This approximation leverages the discrete-time distributions computed by FAU and the residence time information.
  • Error Bounds: The paper also provides theoretical error bounds for the cumulative reward approximation, similar to how bounds were established for instantaneous rewards. This ensures that the approximations are quantifiable.

The key novelty lies in adapting the FAU's state-space exploration strategy to incorporate the accumulation of rewards over time, without explicitly constructing the time-extended model in practice.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their method on several case studies:

  • Discrete Stochastic Model Test Suite: A collection of models encoded in Systems Biology Markup Language (SBML). The authors used 35 of these models, focusing on analyses with a time bound of 50.
  • DNA Strand Displacement (DSD) models: Used for computation with DNA molecules, specifically transducer gates.
  • DNA Walkers: Models used to design logic circuits on the nanoscale, involving movement along tracks of DNA strands.

The paper notes that the SBML import functionality was used to convert SBML models to PRISM files. The "ext. 001-01" model mentioned in Table 1 was not originally from the test suite but was used for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FAU's Versatility: The paper demonstrates that FAU, initially designed for transient probabilities, can be effectively extended to handle cumulative reward properties, significantly broadening its applicability.
  • Avoiding State-Space Explosion: The core advantage of FAU is its ability to manage large or infinite state spaces. The extension to cumulative rewards maintains this advantage, avoiding the need to artificially inflate the model's state space to track rewards.
  • Theoretical Foundation for Cumulative Rewards: The introduction of "time-extended CTPMs" provides a solid theoretical basis for understanding and approximating cumulative rewards within the FAU framework.
  • Practical Performance Gains: The case studies show that the extended FAU method offers superior performance compared to existing techniques, especially for larger models, by efficiently exploring the state space.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the practical applicability and performance of their extended FAU method through several case studies:

  • Biological Models (Discrete Stochastic Model Test Suite): For models like "001-01" and "001-07," the extended FAU achieved significantly better performance (faster analysis, fewer states) compared to a naive approach that involved adding an extra species to track reactions. For instance, the "ext. 001-01" analysis, which used the extended FAU, was much faster than a modified "001-01" model that introduced a new species to track reactions.
  • DNA Strand Displacement: The FAU method was able to handle larger models than existing PRISM engines, achieving better performance for larger model instances. For example, in Table 2, FAU consistently shows competitive or superior performance in terms of time and states explored for various parameters (N, T).
  • DNA Walkers: The method was applied to complex XOR circuits, analyzing expected steps and signal probabilities. The results in Table 3 show that FAU can handle models with millions of states, which are too large for symbolic model checking engines.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Precision vs. Performance Trade-off: The paper acknowledges that FAU, like other approximation methods, involves a trade-off between precision (controlled by parameters $\epsilon$ and $\delta$) and computational cost (time and memory). Reducing $\epsilon$ and $\delta$ generally leads to higher memory requirements.
  • Comparison with Simulation: The authors mention that they did not compare their method against simulation-based approaches. While simulation offers advantages like not requiring generator matrix construction, it provides probabilistic guarantees rather than deterministic error bounds. The paper suggests that investigating the trade-off between FAU and simulation-based techniques is a promising area for future work.
  • Further Optimization: The performance figures in the tables reflect relative speeds at the time of writing and are subject to change with further optimization of the underlying engines.
  • SBML Events: The SBML import functionality used did not yet support events, limiting the number of models that could be analyzed from the SBML test suite.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dannenberg2013computing,
  author = {Frits Dannenberg and Ernst Moritz Hahn and Marta Z. Kwiatkowska},
  title = {{Computing Cumulative Rewards Using Fast Adaptive Uniformisation}},
  booktitle = {CMSB},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-40708-6\_4},
}
Figure