Computational Study on the Catalytic Performance of Single-Atom Catalysts Anchored on g-CN for Electrochemical Oxidation of Formic Acid

Abdul Qadeer, Meiqi Yang, Yuejie Liu, Qinghai Cai, Jingxiang ZhaoCatalysts 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computational methods to investigate single-atom catalysts (SACs) supported on graphitic carbon nitride (g-CN) for the electrochemical oxidation of formic acid (FAOR). They found that Ru/g-CN exhibits promising catalytic activity with a low limiting potential, suggesting a new avenue for developing cost-effective and efficient catalysts for formic acid fuel cells.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The direct formic acid fuel cell (DFAFC) is a promising technology for portable electronics due to its high energy density and safe fuel storage. However, the efficiency of DFAFCs is heavily reliant on effective catalysts for the formic acid oxidation reaction (FAOR). Currently, platinum (Pt) and palladium (Pd) are the most efficient catalysts, but their high cost and susceptibility to poisoning limit their widespread adoption. This research aims to address this by exploring alternative, low-cost electrocatalysts, specifically single-atom catalysts (SACs) anchored on graphitic carbon nitride (g-CN), to achieve high FAOR activity.

Methods

The researchers employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) computations to systematically investigate the catalytic performance of various transition metal single atoms (TM/g-CN) for the FAOR. Key computational techniques included:

  • Geometry Optimization: Determining the most stable structures of the TM/g-CN catalysts and reaction intermediates.
  • Binding Energy Calculations: Quantifying the stability of the single-atom catalysts on the g-CN support.
  • Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD): Assessing the dynamic stability of the Ru/g-CN catalyst at elevated temperatures.
  • Band Structure and Projected Density of States (PDOS) Calculations: Analyzing the electronic properties and conductivity of the catalysts.
  • Free Energy Profiles: Mapping out the thermodynamic landscape of the FAOR pathway, identifying potential-determining steps (PDS) and rate-determining steps (RDS).
  • Kinetic Barrier Calculations: Determining the activation energy for elementary reaction steps.
  • Computational Hydrogen Electrode (CHE) Model: Calculating Gibbs free energy changes for electrochemical reactions.
  • Conductor-like Screening Model (COSMO): Simulating the realistic aqueous environment for the FAOR.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • g-CN as a Stable and Conductive Support: The graphitic carbon nitride (g-CN) substrate provides stable anchoring sites for single transition metal atoms through strong hybridization with nitrogen atoms. This interaction also enhances the electrical conductivity of the material, which is crucial for electrocatalysis.
  • Direct Pathway Dominance: The FAOR on these TM/g-CN catalysts predominantly proceeds via a direct pathway, involving the cleavage of the O-H bond to form HCOO* as a key intermediate, rather than pathways that might lead to CO poisoning.
  • Ru/g-CN as a Superior Catalyst: Ruthenium (Ru) anchored on g-CN emerged as a highly promising catalyst, exhibiting a low limiting potential of -0.15 V. This is attributed to its optimal binding strength with reaction intermediates.
  • Electronic Descriptors for Activity: The study highlights the importance of the d-band center and polarized charge on the transition metal atom as key descriptors for predicting FAOR catalytic activity. A moderate d-band center and polarized charge lead to optimal interactions with intermediates.

Key Results

  • High Stability of SACs: The computed binding energies (Ebind) indicated good thermodynamic stability for the TM/g-CN systems, with values ranging from -5.79 to -2.57 eV. AIMD simulations further confirmed the dynamic stability of Ru/g-CN.
  • Enhanced Conductivity: Anchoring transition metal atoms significantly reduced the band gap of g-CN, leading to enhanced electrical conductivity, particularly for Ru/g-CN which showed a band gap of approximately 0.03 eV.
  • Low Limiting Potential for Ru/g-CN: Ru/g-CN demonstrated a low limiting potential (UL) of -0.15 V, identifying the dehydrogenation of HCOOH to HCOO as the potential-determining step.
  • Moderate Kinetic Barrier: The rate-determining step for Ru/g-CN was the formation of CO2*, with a kinetic barrier of 0.89 eV, which is considered moderate and comparable to or better than some reported FAOR catalysts.
  • Optimal Binding Strength: Ru/g-CN exhibited an optimal binding strength with reaction intermediates, avoiding both too strong (leading to poor desorption) and too weak (leading to poor activation) interactions. This was visualized through a volcano plot showing the relationship between limiting potential and the difference in adsorption energies of HCOO and HCOOH.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study is based on theoretical DFT calculations. While AIMD simulations were performed to assess dynamic stability, experimental validation is crucial to confirm the predicted catalytic performance and stability of these SACs. The study focused on a specific g-CN structure; variations in g-CN morphology or doping could influence catalytic activity.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that these findings open a new avenue for developing novel catalysts for sustainable FAOR in formic-acid-based fuel cells. Future work should focus on experimental synthesis and characterization of these Ru/g-CN SACs and their performance evaluation in actual DFAFC devices. Further theoretical investigations could explore a wider range of transition metals, different support materials, and more complex reaction environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The electrochemical formic acid oxidation reaction (FAOR) has attracted great attention due to its high volumetric energy density and high theoretical efficiency for future portable electronic applications, for which the development of highly efficient and low-cost electrocatalysts is of great significance. In this work, taking single-atom catalysts (SACs) supported on graphitic carbon nitrides (g-CN) as potential catalysts, their catalytic performance for the FAOR was systemically explored by means of density functional theory computations. Our results revealed that the strong hybridization with the unpaired lone electrons of N atoms in the g-CN substrate ensured the high stability of these anchored SACs and endowed them with excellent electrical conductivity. Based on the computed free energy changes of all possible elementary steps, we predicted that a highly efficient FAOR could be achieved on Ru/g-CN with a low limiting potential of −0.15 V along a direct pathway of HCOOH(aq) → HCOOH* → HCOO* → CO2* → CO2(g), in which the formation of HCOO* was identified as the potential-determining step, while the rate-determining step was located at the CO2* formation, with a moderate kinetic barrier of 0.89 eV. Remarkably, the moderate d-band center and polarized charge of the Ru active site caused the Ru/g-CN catalyst to exhibit an optimal binding strength with various reaction intermediates, explaining well its superior FAOR catalytic performance. Hence, the single Ru atom anchored on g-CN could be utilized as a promising SAC for the FAOR, which opens a new avenue to further develop novel catalysts for a sustainable FAOR in formic-acid-based fuel cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qadeer2023computational,
  author = {Abdul Qadeer and Meiqi Yang and Yuejie Liu and Qinghai Cai and Jingxiang Zhao},
  title = {{Computational Study on the Catalytic Performance of Single-Atom Catalysts Anchored on g-CN for Electrochemical Oxidation of Formic Acid}},
  booktitle = {Catalysts},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/catal13010187},
}
Figure