Computational modelling of COVID-19: A study of compliance and superspreaders

Faith Lee, María Pérez‐Ortiz, John Shawe‐TaylormedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

The success of social distancing implementations for SARS-CoV-2 depends heavily on population compliance. This study investigates the role of "superspreaders"—highly connected individuals—in viral transmission across various compliance levels. Using a SEIRS-inspired social network model, we observe infected links in populations with and without superspreaders. By adjusting local and global connection parameters, we simulate close contact networks and travel restrictions. Results indicate that increased compliance among superspreaders significantly reduces infections. Furthermore, assuming long-lasting immunity, superspreaders may initially accelerate spread but eventually slow it down due to their high connectivity.

Introduction

Traditional epidemiological models often assume "uniform mixing," where every individual has an equal probability of interacting with others. However, real-world human social networks are "scale-free," characterized by a few highly connected "hubs" or superspreaders. This study addresses the gap between idealized models and the stochastic reality of SARS-CoV-2 transmission, specifically examining how compliance with non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) by these hubs influences the pandemic's trajectory.

Methods

The researchers employed a SEIRS Network model, treating individuals as nodes within a graph. This approach captures the heterogeneity and locality of social interactions.

The SEIR model flow representing transitions between Susceptible, Exposed, Infected, and Recovered states.

Network Topologies and Parameters

Two primary network types were compared:

  1. Erdos-Renyi Networks: Homogeneous and random, representing a population without superspreaders.
  2. Scale-free (Barabasi-Albert) Networks: Representing a population containing superspreaders.

Connectivity was defined by two parameters:

  • $p_{local}$: Represents close contacts, such as family and housemates.
  • $p_{global}$: Represents casual or random contacts, such as those encountered during travel or in public spaces.
Illustration of local ($p_{local}$) and global ($p_{global}$) network connections in the social network model.

Compliance Scenarios

Four levels of adherence were simulated:

  • 100% Compliance: Minimizing both local and global links.
  • Partial (i): Adhering to travel restrictions (low global) while maintaining local links.
  • Partial (ii): Reducing local links but increasing global/casual encounters.
  • 0% Compliance: Ignoring all distancing guidelines.

The simulations involved 10,000 nodes with an average of 12 connections per node, calibrated to an $R_0$ of 2.2 based on early COVID-19 literature.

Key Insights

The Hub Paradox

In populations with superspreaders, the infection peak is higher and arrives sooner. However, if long-lasting immunity is assumed, these hubs become immune quickly, potentially acting as "firewalls" that protect the rest of the network from further transmission.

Global vs. Local Transmission

The model demonstrates that "global" interactions (casual encounters) are significantly more dangerous for community spread than "local" interactions. Targeted compliance—where the most connected 20% of individuals limit global travel—can be nearly as effective as population-wide compliance.

Results

The study found that in a homogeneous population with 0% compliance, the total infection rate reached 83.71%. In contrast, the heterogeneous (superspreader) population under the same conditions saw a lower total of 75.63%, despite a much sharper peak.

Full compliance reduced total infections to 26.22% in homogeneous populations and 39.37% in heterogeneous ones. Notably, reducing global travel (Partial i) was consistently more effective than reducing local contacts (Partial ii) across all scenarios.

Discussion and Limitations

While the model provides valuable insights into network dynamics, it has limitations. It assumes long-lasting sterile immunity, which may not hold true given the emergence of new variants and waning immunity. Additionally, the model does not account for demographic factors like age or pre-existing conditions, nor does it fully capture the variability of asymptomatic transmission.

Conclusion

Superspreaders play a central role in epidemic dynamics. Adjusting social distancing measures to target high-traffic social settings and ensuring compliance among highly connected individuals are crucial strategies for preventing future outbreaks. These measures should be accompanied by population-wide testing and effective contact tracing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background The success of social distancing implementations of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-Cov-2) depends heavily on population compliance. Mathematical modelling has been used extensively to assess the rate of viral transmission from behavioural responses. Previous epidemics of SARS-Cov-2 have been characterised by superspreaders, a small number of individuals who transmit a disease to a large group of individuals, who contribute to the stochasticity (or randomness) of transmission compared to other pathogens such as Influenza. This growing evidence proves an urgent matter to understand transmission routes in order to target and combat outbreaks. Objective To investigate the role of superspreaders in the rate of viral transmission with various levels of compliance. Method A SEIRS inspired social network model is adapted and calibrated to observe the infected links of a general population with and without superspreaders on four compliance levels. Local and global connection parameters are adjusted to simulate close contact networks and travel restrictions respectively and each performance assessed. The mean and standard deviation of infections with superspreaders and non-superspreaders were calculated for each compliance level. Results Increased levels of compliance of superspreaders proves a significant reduction in infections. Assuming long-lasting immunity, superspreaders could potentially slow down the spread due to their high connectivity. Discussion The main advantage of applying the network model is to capture the heterogeneity and locality of social networks, including the role of superspreaders in epidemic dynamics. The main challenge is the immediate attention on social settings with targeted interventions to tackle superspreaders in future empirical work. Conclusion Superspreaders play a central role in slowing down infection spread following compliance guidelines. It is crucial to adjust social distancing measures to prevent future outbreaks accompanied by population-wide testing and effective tracing.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2021computational,
  author = {Faith Lee and María Pérez‐Ortiz and John Shawe‐Taylor},
  title = {{Computational modelling of COVID-19: A study of compliance and superspreaders}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.05.12.21257079},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure