Computational and Image Processing Methods for Analysis and Automation of Anatomical Alignment and Joint Spacing in Reconstructive Surgery

Usamah Chaudhary, Cambre Kelly, Benjamin Wesorick, Cameron M. Reese, Ken Gall, Samuel B. Adams, Guillermo Sapiro, J. Matías Di MartinobioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel histogram-based metric and associated algorithms for automatically analyzing joint spacing and realigning anatomical structures in reconstructive surgery. This approach significantly reduces manual effort in pre-surgical planning, achieving results comparable to expert technicians and paving the way for more efficient and scalable treatment solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reconstructive surgeries, particularly those involving 3D printed implants, require meticulous pre-surgical planning to ensure accurate anatomical alignment and joint spacing. Currently, this process is highly manual, time-consuming, and prone to inter-engineer variability. Engineers spend hours manually aligning patient anatomy to a "healthy" state, a critical but labor-intensive task. This is further complicated by the fact that CT scans, the primary imaging modality, often capture anatomy in a non-weight-bearing position, requiring engineers to infer weight-bearing alignment. The paper aims to automate this complex alignment process, making it more efficient, affordable, and scalable.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in two main components:

  1. Global Alignment (Iterative Closest Points - ICP): The authors leverage a standard ICP algorithm to perform an initial coarse alignment of the articulating surfaces between two bones. This step establishes a basic correspondence between the anatomical structures.
  2. Novel Joint Space Refinement: This is the paper's key innovation. Instead of relying solely on absolute positional errors (translation and rotation), they introduce a histogram-based metric to characterize the "health" of a joint. This metric is derived from the distribution of distances between corresponding points on the articulating surfaces. A healthy joint, they hypothesize, will exhibit a narrow, uniform distribution of these distances, indicating consistent spacing. This metric is then used as an objective function to optimize the alignment. They employ a multi-grid optimization strategy to efficiently search for the optimal six-dimensional pose (three for translation, three for rotation) that minimizes the difference between the pathological joint's histogram and a pre-defined "healthy" template histogram.

Datasets

The study utilizes CT scans from a dataset of 9 healthy weight-bearing scans and 9 pathological scans of the foot-and-ankle region. These scans were manually segmented to generate 3D point clouds representing individual bones. The authors do not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather use real clinical data for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Histogram-based metric as a proxy for joint health: The central idea is that the distribution of distances between articulating bone surfaces, when visualized as a histogram, provides a more robust and informative measure of joint health than simple translation and rotation errors. This is particularly true for joints with complex kinematics, where a healthy state can be represented by a manifold of positions.
  • Automation of a critical manual step: The paper demonstrates that a significant portion of the manual pre-surgical planning, specifically the anatomical re-alignment, can be automated. This has direct implications for reducing costs and increasing throughput in reconstructive surgery.
  • Performance comparable to experts: The quantitative results show that the automated method achieves alignment accuracy that is on par with, and in some cases better than, that of experienced human engineers.

Key Results

  • Reduced Misalignment Errors: The algorithms achieved a reduction in misalignment errors of 22% in translation and 19% in rotation for the full foot-and-ankle, and 37% in translation and 39% in rotation for the hind-foot only, when compared to ground truth healthy anatomies.
  • Significant Histogram Deviance Improvement: The normalized L2 histogram deviance, a key metric for assessing alignment quality, was improved by 86.0% across all tested cases.
  • Comparison to Expert Engineers: The automated method achieved a normalized deviance of 0.12, significantly outperforming the average deviance of 0.85 achieved by 5 expert engineers in approximately 1 hour per case.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Two-Body Problem Focus: The current work focuses on the alignment of individual two-body joints. The authors acknowledge that a critical next step is to address the global alignment of all anatomical components simultaneously to solve the multi-body problem.
  • Data Dependency: The accuracy of the histogram-based metric relies on having representative "healthy" templates. The authors suggest the need for a larger and more diverse database of anatomies to ensure templates are available for a wide range of patients (age, sex, demographics).
  • Theoretical Guarantees: Future work will also involve studying theoretical guarantees for the convergence of the proposed methods.
  • Data-Driven Approaches: The extensive database could also enable the exploration of entirely data-driven approaches, potentially leveraging advances in deep learning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Purpose Reconstructive surgeries to treat a number of musculoskeletal conditions, from arthritis to severe trauma, involve implant placement and reconstructive planning components. Anatomically matched 3D printed implants are becoming increasingly patient-specific; however the preoperative planning and design process requires several hours of manual effort from highly trained engineers and clinicians. Our work mitigates this problem by proposing algorithms for the automatic re-alignment of unhealthy anatomies, leading to more efficient, affordable, and scalable treatment solutions. Methods Our solution combines global alignment techniques such as iterative closest points (ICP) with novel joint space refinement algorithms. The latter is achieved by a low dimensional characterization of the joint space, computed from the distribution of the distance between adjacent points in a joint. Results Experimental validation is presented on real clinical data from human subjects. Compared with ground truth healthy anatomies, our algorithms can reduce misalignment errors by 22% in translation and 19% in rotation for the full foot-and-ankle and 37% in translation and 39% in rotation for the hind-foot only, achieving a performance comparable to expert technicians. Conclusion Our methods and histogram-based metric allow for automatic and unsupervised alignment of anatomies, a major step toward a fully automated and data driven re-positioning, designing, and diagnosing tool.
BibTeX
@misc{chaudhary2021computational,
  author = {Usamah Chaudhary and Cambre Kelly and Benjamin Wesorick and Cameron M. Reese and Ken Gall and Samuel B. Adams and Guillermo Sapiro and J. Matías Di Martino},
  title = {{Computational and Image Processing Methods for Analysis and Automation of Anatomical Alignment and Joint Spacing in Reconstructive Surgery}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.04.04.438341},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure