Computation and visualization of cell–cell signaling topologies in single-cell systems data using Connectome

Micha Sam Brickman Raredon, Junchen Yang, James Garritano, Meng Wang, Dan Kushnir, Jonas C. Schupp, Taylor Adams, Allison M. Greaney, Katherine L. Leiby, Naftali Kaminski, Yuval Kluger, Andre Levchenko, Laura E. NiklasonScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Connectome," an R software package designed to analyze and visualize cell-cell communication networks from single-cell RNA sequencing data. It addresses the challenge of extracting meaningful biological insights from complex, high-dimensional data by providing tools for quantifying and comparing signaling topologies across different tissues and conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how cells communicate is fundamental to comprehending tissue function, development, and response to injury. Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has opened up unprecedented possibilities for mapping these intricate communication networks, revealing which cells express specific ligands and receptors. However, translating this vast amount of data into actionable biological insights presents significant computational and conceptual hurdles. Existing methods struggle to efficiently quantify, visualize, and compare these complex signaling patterns, especially when dealing with multiple datasets or dynamic biological processes. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a robust and flexible software solution.

Methods

The core of this work is the "Connectome" R package. It operates by mapping scRNA-seq data against a curated database of known ligand-receptor interactions. The key methodological contributions include:

  • Edgeweight Calculation: Connectome calculates two primary edgeweights to represent the strength of a ligand-receptor interaction between cell types:
  • weightnorm: The product of normalized ligand and receptor expression. This is useful for direct comparisons across conditions.
  • weightscale: The mean of system-scaled gene z-scores for the ligand and receptor. This metric is better suited for exploring cellular "roles" within a single tissue system and comparing relative expressions across disparate datasets.
  • Differential Connectomics: The package facilitates the comparison of signaling networks between two conditions (e.g., healthy vs. diseased). It identifies differentially expressed ligands and receptors and calculates a "perturbation score" to quantify the overall change in an interaction.
  • Centrality Analysis: Connectome implements metrics like Kleinberg Hub and Authority scores to quantify the outgoing (ligand-producing) and incoming (receptor-expressing) signaling influence of individual cell types within a network. This helps in understanding the "roles" of different cell populations.
  • Visualization Tools: The software provides various plotting functions to visualize interactomes, cell-type-to-cell-type vectors, and niche networks, allowing for interactive exploration of the data.

Datasets

The authors demonstrate Connectome's capabilities using several publicly available datasets:

  • Human Pancreas Data: Used to showcase single-tissue connectomic analysis and centrality analysis.
  • IFN-stimulated vs. Control PBMC Data: Utilized for demonstrating differential connectomics.
  • Muscle Wound-Healing Dataset (from De Micheli et al. 2020): Applied to illustrate longitudinal connectomics and dynamic changes in signaling over time.

The software is designed to be flexible and can utilize any user-provided ligand-receptor list, not just the default FANTOM5 database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: Connectome provides a much-needed computational framework to move beyond simply identifying expressed genes to understanding the functional implications of cell-cell communication in complex biological systems.
  • Quantitative Network Analysis: The dual edgeweight system (weightnorm and weightscale) offers nuanced ways to quantify interactions, catering to different analytical goals (direct comparison vs. role identification).
  • Unveiling Dynamic Processes: The ability to perform differential and longitudinal connectomics is crucial for studying disease progression, tissue regeneration, and developmental changes, revealing how communication networks evolve.
  • Cellular Roles and Hierarchy: Centrality analysis provides a powerful way to rank cell types based on their signaling influence, offering insights into the hierarchical organization of communication within tissues.
  • Customization is Key: The flexibility to use custom ligand-receptor databases is vital for researchers investigating specific biological contexts or newly discovered signaling pathways.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates Connectome's utility through several case studies:

  • Pancreas Analysis: Visualized the overall signaling landscape and identified key cell types with high outgoing or incoming centrality for specific signaling families (e.g., mesenchymal cells as PDGF receivers, endothelial cells as VEGF receivers).
  • PBMC Analysis: Showcased differential connectomics, highlighting specific ligand-receptor pairs that were significantly altered upon IFN stimulation, leading to the identification of perturbed edges.
  • Wound-Healing Analysis: Illustrated how Connectome can track dynamic changes in signaling over time. For VEGFA signaling, it revealed a shift in dominant ligand producers from fibro/adipogenic progenitors (FAPs) to monocytes/macrophages during wound healing, while endothelial cells consistently acted as key receivers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Information: The authors acknowledge that single-cell suspension-based sequencing loses spatial information, which is critical for many ligand-receptor interactions that require direct cell-cell contact or close proximity. Connectome infers possible interactions, not definitive transduction.
  • Ground-Truth Database Quality: The accuracy of Connectome's output is dependent on the quality and completeness of the ligand-receptor database used. The paper emphasizes the importance of customizable databases for specific research questions.
  • Intracellular Transduction Complexity: While Connectome focuses on ligand-receptor interactions, the downstream intracellular signaling cascades are not modeled, which adds another layer of complexity to fully understanding communication.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further sub-clustering can help differentiate between population-wide shifts and the emergence of new phenotypic archetypes. The software is designed to be a fundamental tool for researchers, computational biologists, and tissue engineers, with ongoing development and community adoption expected.

Summary updated

Abstract

Single-cell RNA-sequencing data has revolutionized our ability to understand of the patterns of cell-cell and ligand-receptor connectivity that influence the function of tissues and organs. However, the quantification and visualization of these patterns in a way that informs tissue biology are major computational and epistemological challenges. Here, we present Connectome, a software package for R which facilitates rapid calculation and interactive exploration of cell-cell signaling network topologies contained in single-cell RNA-sequencing data. Connectome can be used with any reference set of known ligand-receptor mechanisms. It has built-in functionality to facilitate differential and comparative connectomics, in which signaling networks are compared between tissue systems. Connectome focuses on computational and graphical tools designed to analyze and explore cell-cell connectivity patterns across disparate single-cell datasets and reveal biologic insight. We present approaches to quantify focused network topologies and discuss some of the biologic theory leading to their design.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{raredon2022computation,
  author = {Micha Sam Brickman Raredon and Junchen Yang and James Garritano and Meng Wang and Dan Kushnir and Jonas C. Schupp and Taylor Adams and Allison M. Greaney and Katherine L. Leiby and Naftali Kaminski and Yuval Kluger and Andre Levchenko and Laura E. Niklason},
  title = {{Computation and visualization of cell–cell signaling topologies in single-cell systems data using Connectome}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-07959-x},
}
Figure