Comprehensive Substantiation of the Impact of Pre-Support Technology on a 50-Year-Old Subway Station During the Construction of Undercrossing Tunnel Lines

Bin Zhang, Shaohui He, Jianfei Ma, Jiaxin He, Yiming Li, Jinlei ZhengInfrastructures 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates a pre-support technology for constructing new subway lines that pass under existing, aging subway lines. By combining field monitoring and advanced numerical simulations, the study demonstrates that this method significantly controls settlement and stress on the older infrastructure, ensuring operational safety and minimizing damage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban areas are experiencing rapid growth, leading to increased demand for public transportation like subways. This often necessitates building new subway lines that must pass beneath or near existing, operational lines. Older subway systems, like Beijing's 50-year-old Line 2, are particularly vulnerable to the stresses and deformations caused by new construction. The challenge is to implement new infrastructure projects without compromising the safety, stability, and functionality of these critical, aging transit networks. Traditional construction methods can cause significant ground disturbance, leading to settlement and stress issues in existing structures. This paper addresses the need for a construction method that minimizes these negative impacts, specifically focusing on a "close-fitting undercrossing" scenario.

Methods

The research employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Field Monitoring: On-site measurements were taken on the existing Line 2 and the new Line 3 during the construction of the undercrossing. This involved both manual (gauge ruler, spirit level) and automated monitoring systems to track track gauge, crosslevel, and deformation of bearing columns and floor slabs.
  • Numerical Simulation: A detailed three-dimensional finite difference model was created using FLAC3D software. This model incorporated the geological conditions, the existing subway structure (Line 2), and the new tunnel construction process. Material parameters were derived from geotechnical investigations and laboratory tests on concrete samples from the existing structure.
  • Laboratory Tests: Uniaxial compression tests, elastic modulus, and Poisson's ratio tests were conducted on concrete samples from the existing subway structure to obtain accurate material parameters for the numerical model.
  • Comparative Analysis: The proposed pre-support technology was compared against another common method, the cross diaphragm (CRD) method, through numerical simulations to highlight the advantages of the new approach.

Datasets

Not explicitly detailed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study relies on:

  • Geological Survey Data: Provided parameters for various soil strata.
  • Laboratory Test Results: Data from concrete testing of the existing subway structure.
  • Field Monitoring Data: Measurements collected from the existing Line 2 and the construction site during the undercrossing project. This data was used for model calibration and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Direct Contact Support is Crucial: The pre-support technology, utilizing bored piles and jacks, provides direct physical support to the existing structure. This is a key differentiator from methods that rely solely on ground improvement, which can lead to greater soil disturbance.
  • Minimizing Time Gaps is Key: The study emphasizes the importance of minimizing the time intervals between construction steps (e.g., pile foundation construction and jack placement) to ensure a continuous and effective support system.
  • Deformation Joints are Vulnerable Points: The research highlights that deformation joints in the existing structure are particularly susceptible to displacement during construction, requiring careful monitoring.
  • Pre-support Technology Outperforms CRD: Numerical comparisons show that the pre-support method results in significantly less settlement and stress variation in the existing subway line compared to the CRD method.

Key Results

  • Track Smoothness Maintained: The pre-support technology caused minimal impact on the smoothness of the existing subway rail surface, with fluctuations within -1 to 1 mm.
  • Settlement Control: Settlement deformation of the existing lines was effectively controlled within 1-3 cm.
  • Stress Within Limits: Deformation stress on existing lines remained within the concrete strength range, with tensile stress less than 3 MPa.
  • Maximum Settlement: The pre-support jacking scheme resulted in a maximum settlement of -5.27 mm.
  • Maximum Tensile Stress: The maximum tensile stress observed was 2.29 MPa.
  • CRD Method Comparison: The CRD method resulted in a much larger maximum settlement of -61.28 mm and a maximum tensile stress of 2.47 MPa, indicating a greater impact on the existing structure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope of Monitoring: The numerical model focused on the influence of the underpass construction process itself. The paper acknowledges that the influence of other underground construction activities on the on-site displacement was not considered and suggests this as an area for further study.
  • Geological Conditions: The study's findings are based on the specific geological conditions of the Beijing subway. While the method is presented as applicable to sandy cobble strata, further research might explore its performance in a wider range of geological environments.
  • Optimization: The paper mentions that optimization measures were proposed based on monitoring data and simulation results, but these specific measures are not detailed in the provided text. Future work could elaborate on these optimizations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the long operation period of Beijing Metro Line 2 and the complex surrounding building environment, this paper comprehensively studied the mechanical properties of new tunnels using close-fitting undercrossing based on pre-support technology. To control structural deformation caused by the expansion project, methods such as laboratory tests, numerical simulation, and field tests were adopted to systematically analyze the tunnel mechanics during the undercrossing of existing metro lines. First, field tests were carried out on the existing Line 2 and Line 3 tunnels during the construction period. It was found that the close-fitting construction based on pre-support technology caused small deformation displacement in the subway tunnels, with little impact on the smoothness of the existing subway rail surface. The fluctuation range was −1 to 1 mm, ensuring the safety of existing subway operations. Then, a refined finite difference model for the close-fitting undercrossing construction process based on pre-support technology was established, and a series of field and laboratory tests were conducted to obtain calculation parameters. The reliability of the numerical model was verified by comparing the monitored deformation of existing structures with the simulated structural forces and deformations. The influence of construction methods on the settlement changes of existing line tracks, structures, and deformation joints was discussed. The research results show that this construction method effectively controls the settlement deformation of existing lines. The settlement deformation of existing lines is controlled within 1~3 cm. The deformation stress of the existing lines is within the concrete strength range of the existing structure, and the tensile stress is less than 3 MPa. The maximum settlement and maximum tensile stress of the station in the pre-support jacking scheme are −5.27 mm and 2.29 MPa. The construction scheme with pre-support can more significantly control structural deformation, reduce stress variations in existing line structures, and minimize damage to concrete structures. Based on the monitoring data and simulation results, some optimization measures were proposed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025comprehensive,
  author = {Bin Zhang and Shaohui He and Jianfei Ma and Jiaxin He and Yiming Li and Jinlei Zheng},
  title = {{Comprehensive Substantiation of the Impact of Pre-Support Technology on a 50-Year-Old Subway Station During the Construction of Undercrossing Tunnel Lines}},
  booktitle = {Infrastructures},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/infrastructures10070183},
}
Figure