Comprehensive Profiling of Gene Copy Number Alterations Predicts Patient Prognosis in Resected Stages I–III Lung Adenocarcinoma

Xiaohong Han, Qiaoyun Tan, Sheng Yang, Junling Li, Jianping Xu, Xuezhi Hao, Xingsheng Hu, Puyuan Xing, Yutao Liu, Lin Lin, Lin Gui, Yan Qin, Jianliang Yang, Peng Liu, Xingyuan Wang, Wumin Dai, Yuankai ShiFrontiers in Oncology 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that patterns of gene copy number alterations (CNAs) in lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD) can predict patient prognosis and response to adjuvant chemotherapy. Specifically, amplifications in genes like 12p12.1 and KDM5A are linked to worse outcomes, while ERBB2 amplification and 4q34.3 deletion are associated with early relapse after treatment, suggesting CNAs as potential biomarkers for personalized LUAD therapy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD) is a major cause of cancer deaths, and even after surgical resection of early to mid-stage tumors (Stages I-III), a significant portion of patients experience relapse, leading to a poor 5-year survival rate. Current prognostic tools, primarily based on tumor stage (TNM staging), don't fully capture the variability in patient outcomes. This highlights the critical need to identify new, more precise prognostic biomarkers that can better predict which patients are at higher risk of relapse and could benefit from specific therapeutic strategies. Somatic copy number alterations (CNAs), which are changes in the number of copies of DNA segments, are known drivers of tumor evolution and have been implicated in various cancers. This paper aims to investigate the prognostic value of CNA profiling in resected LUAD patients, particularly in the context of adjuvant chemotherapy.

Methods

The researchers utilized the Oncoscan MIP array to analyze the patterns of CNAs in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tumor specimens from 163 patients with resected Stages I-III LUAD. This array technology allows for genome-wide scanning of copy number variations. Following DNA extraction from FFPE samples, the data was processed using Affymetrix's OncoScan Console software and analyzed with ASCAT for genome-wide segmentation. To identify recurrent CNA peaks associated with prognosis, they employed GISTIC 2.0 analysis. Non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) was used to classify LUAD tumors into distinct molecular subtypes based on their CNA profiles. Statistical analyses, including Cox regression and Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, were performed to assess the association between CNAs and patient outcomes, as well as clinical variables.

Datasets

The primary dataset consisted of FFPE tumor specimens from 163 LUAD patients who underwent surgical resection for Stages I-III disease. A significant portion of these patients (145) also received platinum-based adjuvant chemotherapy.

For validation purposes, the study utilized two external datasets:

  1. Imielinski et al. cohort: This dataset included 159 LUAD patients.
  2. TCGA (The Cancer Genome Atlas) database: This provided whole-genome CNA and mRNA expression data from 506 LUAD patients.

These validation datasets were crucial for confirming the findings from the primary cohort.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CNAs as a Prognostic Compass: The study strongly suggests that CNA profiling is not just a descriptive tool but can serve as a powerful prognostic classifier for resected LUAD. This moves beyond traditional staging to offer a more granular prediction of patient outcomes.
  • Specific CNA Signatures for Worse Prognosis: The identification of amplifications in 12p12.1 (including genes like KRAS) and KDM5A as being significantly correlated with worse overall survival is a major finding. This points to specific genomic regions that could be targeted for therapeutic intervention or closely monitored.
  • ERBB2 and Chemotherapy Resistance: The discovery that ERBB2 amplification and 4q34.3 deletion are specifically associated with relapse in patients who received adjuvant chemotherapy is particularly impactful. This suggests these CNAs might be key drivers of resistance to standard treatments, opening avenues for personalized treatment strategies.
  • LUAD Subtypes Defined by CNAs: The classification of LUAD into five distinct subtypes based on CNA profiles provides a new framework for understanding tumor heterogeneity. The LUAD4 subtype, characterized by TERC and ERBB2 amplification, showed a significantly poorer prognosis, highlighting the clinical relevance of these subtypes.
  • KDM5A: A Novel Prognostic Marker: The study is the first to report a significant association between KDM5A CNA and prognosis in resected LUAD, adding a new player to the list of potential prognostic biomarkers.

Key Results

  • Recurrence Rates: Of the 163 patients, 91 (55.8%) recurred within 3 years of surgery.
  • Common Aberrations: Frequent copy number gains were observed on chromosomes 1q, 5p, 5q, 7p, 8q, 14p, 16p, 17q, and 20q, while losses were common on 8p, 9p, 13p, 16q, and 18q.
  • Prognostic Genes: Amplifications of 12p12.1 (including CMAS, GOLT1B, YS2, LDHB, RECQL, ETNK1, IAPP, PYROXD1, KRAS) and KDM5A were significantly correlated with worse prognosis in their cohort and validated in the TCGA dataset.
  • LUAD Subtypes: The NMF analysis identified five distinct LUAD subtypes, with LUAD4 showing a significantly poorer prognosis.
  • Adjuvant Chemotherapy Relapse Markers: Focal amplification of ERBB2 and deletion of 4q34.3 were identified as specific CNAs in patients who relapsed after adjuvant chemotherapy, and this was validated in an independent cohort.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size for Validation: While the primary cohort was of reasonable size (163 patients), the validation of specific findings, particularly regarding ERBB2 amplification and 4q34.3 deletion in relapse, was performed on smaller independent cohorts. Larger validation studies would further solidify these findings.
  • Mechanistic Understanding: The paper identifies associations between CNAs and prognosis/treatment response but does not delve deeply into the underlying biological mechanisms. Future work could focus on elucidating how these specific CNA events drive tumor progression, metastasis, and drug resistance.
  • Integration with Other Omics: The study primarily focuses on CNA data. Integrating this with other omics data, such as gene expression, mutations, and epigenetics, could provide a more comprehensive understanding of LUAD pathogenesis and improve prognostic accuracy.
  • Clinical Implementation: While the findings suggest potential for clinical application, further research is needed to establish standardized protocols for CNA profiling and to demonstrate the clinical utility and cost-effectiveness of these biomarkers in routine practice. The authors suggest that further studies involving large LUAD cohorts with complete clinical data and other omics data may facilitate guiding therapeutic strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD) possesses a poor prognosis with a low 5-year survival rate even for stages I-III resected patients, it is thus critical to understand the determinants that affect the survival and discover new potentially prognostic biomarkers. Somatic copy number alterations (CNAs) are major source of genomic variations driving tumor evolution, CNAs screening may identify prognostic biomarkers. <b>Methods:</b> Oncoscan MIP array was used to analyze the patterns of CNAs on formalin fixed paraffin embedded(FFPE) tumor specimens from 163 consecutive stage I-III resected LUAD patients, 145 out of which received platinum-based adjuvant chemotherapy. <b>Results:</b> Of the 163 patients, 91(55.8%) were recurred within 3 years after surgery. The most common aberrations in our cohort were 1q, 5p, 5q, 7p, 8q, 14p, 16p, 17q, 20q for copy number gains and 8p, 9p, 13p, 16q, 18q for losses. The GISTIC2 analysis produced 45 amplification peaks and 40 deletion peaks, involving some reported genes <i>TERT, EGFR, MYC, CCND1, CDK4, MDM2, ERBB2, NKX2-1, CCNE1</i>, and <i>CDKN2A</i>, most of which were consistent with TCGA database. The amplifications of 12p12.1 (<i>CMAS, GOLT1B, YS2, LDHB, RECQL, ETNK1, IAPP, PYROXD1, KRAS</i>) and <i>KDM5A</i> were correlated with worse prognosis in our cohort, this result was further validated in 506 LUAD patients from TCGA. In addition, 163 patients could be well-classified into five groups, and the clinical outcomes were significantly different based on threshold copy number at reoccurring alteration peaks. Among the 145 patients who received adjuvant chemotherapy, focal amplification of <i>ERBB2</i> and deletion of 4q34.3 were found to be specific in relapsed patients, this result was validated in an independent group of Imielinski et al., demonstrating these two CNAs may contribute to resected LUAD recurrence after adjuvant chemotherapy. <b>Conclusion:</b> This study suggests that CNAs profiling may be a potential prognostic classifier in resected LAUD patients. Amplifications of 12p12.1 and <i>KDM5A</i> might be prognostic biomarkers for LUAD, and amplification of <i>ERBB2</i> and deletion of 4q34.3 predicted early relapse after adjuvant chemotherapy. These novel findings may provide implication for better implementation of precision therapy for lung cancer patients.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2019comprehensive,
  author = {Xiaohong Han and Qiaoyun Tan and Sheng Yang and Junling Li and Jianping Xu and Xuezhi Hao and Xingsheng Hu and Puyuan Xing and Yutao Liu and Lin Lin and Lin Gui and Yan Qin and Jianliang Yang and Peng Liu and Xingyuan Wang and Wumin Dai and Dongmei Lin and Hua Lin and Yuankai Shi},
  title = {{Comprehensive Profiling of Gene Copy Number Alterations Predicts Patient Prognosis in Resected Stages I–III Lung Adenocarcinoma}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2019.00556},
}
Figure