Abstract
A comprehensive set of surface phase diagrams addressing the catalytically relevant edges of the (100) surface of MoS₂ catalysts is developed using dispersion-corrected density functional theory and ab initio thermodynamic modeling. The results of the temperature-dependent, free energy-based thermodynamic model are presented over the full range of catalytically relevant temperatures and pressures, in addition to S- and H-coverages ranging from 0 to 100%. The results of this work allow for a full thermodynamic analysis to be performed at the conditions relevant to any promising reaction involving MoS₂, ranging from hydrodesulfurization to dehydrogenation to electrocatalysis. Several methodological recommendations are discussed and implemented with the goal of improving the accuracy of the surface phase diagrams at minimal computational expense. A library of the most stable S- and H-adsorption modes is also developed so that linear scaling relationships can be used to correlate thermodynamic stability with kinetic activity. Applying the results to C–H bond activation of methane with a S₂ oxidant, we predict S-coverages near 100% on the Mo- and S-edges to be thermodynamically favored and S monomers on edge sites with high S-coverages to be kinetically favorable. For H-abstraction on surface S atoms, the Mo-edge is also predicted to be more active than the S-edge.
Introduction
Molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂) is a versatile catalyst, essential for processes ranging from crude oil desulfurization to green hydrogen production. Its catalytic activity is primarily localized at its edges rather than its basal planes. However, these edges are dynamic; their chemical composition—specifically sulfur (S) and hydrogen (H) coverage—varies significantly with reaction conditions. Previous models often provided only "snapshots" for specific processes like hydrodesulfurization (HDS), frequently neglecting vibrational entropy and van der Waals forces. This study addresses these gaps by developing a comprehensive, dispersion-corrected thermodynamic model to map MoS₂ edge structures across a wide range of temperatures and pressures.
Computational Methods
The researchers utilized Density Functional Theory (DFT) enhanced with several high-fidelity features:
- Dispersion Corrections (D3-BJ): Grimme’s D3 corrections with Becke-Johnson damping were included to account for weak interlayer forces, significantly improving structural accuracy.
- Ab Initio Thermodynamics: The Grand Potential formalism was used to determine stable edge structures based on the chemical potentials of S and H.
- Vibrational Analysis: By calculating vibrational frequencies, the team found that H* vibrations are largely decoupled from the lattice, allowing for a simplified scaling approach that maintains accuracy while reducing computational cost.
- Reference State Refinement: Gas-phase H₂S and H₂ were used as reference states instead of bulk sulfur to improve fugacity predictions.
The model was applied to a variety of catalytically relevant conditions, ranging from low-temperature hydrogen evolution to high-temperature methane conversion, as summarized in the table below.
Data and Benchmarking
The study generated a structural library of approximately 150 optimized atomic configurations for Mo- and S-edges (0% to 100% coverage). Validation against X-ray diffraction data showed that dispersion corrections reduced interlayer separation errors from 10% to just 1.5%. A comprehensive database of electronic energies and vibrational modes was also compiled for community use.
Key Insights
- Significance of Dispersion: Including van der Waals forces qualitatively changed the results, showing that high sulfur coverages are more stable than previously predicted, particularly on the Mo-edge.
- Temperature-Dependent Stability: Stability windows for edge structures shift significantly (up to -0.4 eV) as temperature increases from 300 K to 1000 K. This implies that the active site for room-temperature hydrogen evolution may differ entirely from that of high-temperature methane conversion.
- H* Vibrational Decoupling: The independence of H* vibrational modes from surface coverage allows for efficient approximation of free energies for complex surfaces.
- Activity Prediction: Mapping Mo-S bond strengths enabled the prediction of sites capable of C–H bond activation in methane.
Results and Discussion
The paper provides definitive phase diagrams for 300 K, 650 K, and 1000 K.
- Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER): The model confirms Mo-50/33 (50% S, 33% H) and S-100/100 as likely active states at 300 K.
- Methane Conversion: At 1000 K, both Mo- and S-edges are predicted to be 100% saturated with sulfur. The Mo-edge is predicted to be more active for H-abstraction, especially when sulfur monomers are present at high coverages.
Limitations and Future Outlook
The current model assumes specific slab geometries and neglects configurational entropy. Future work could extend this framework to doped MoS₂ (e.g., with Co or Ni) or other transition metal dichalcogenides like MoSe₂. The provided computational tools allow researchers to apply these findings to their specific experimental conditions.
Summary updated