Comprehensive Modeling and Safety Protection Strategy for Thermal Runway Propagation in Lithium-Ion Battery Modules under Multi-Factor Influences

Zhixiong Chai, Junqiu Li, Ziming Liu, Zhengnan Liu, Xin JinBatteries 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical issue of thermal runaway propagation (TRP) in lithium-ion battery modules by developing a comprehensive, multi-factor TRP model. They then use this model to design and validate an effective aerogel-based safety protection strategy that significantly mitigates TRP risks with minimal impact on energy density.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lithium-ion batteries are ubiquitous in electric vehicles and other high-energy applications, but their safety remains a paramount concern. A single cell experiencing thermal runaway (TR) can trigger a cascading failure, leading to TRP throughout the entire battery module. This phenomenon poses significant fire and explosion risks. While TR mechanisms are understood, predicting and preventing TRP in complex battery modules, especially under various influencing factors like ambient temperature, trigger type, and the number of initial TR cells, is a significant challenge. Existing safety strategies often focus on single-factor scenarios, leaving a gap in understanding and mitigating TRP under realistic, multi-faceted conditions.

Methods

The authors developed a multi-stage modeling approach:

  1. Cell Thermal Runaway Model: They first established a cell-level TR model by analyzing the triggering mechanisms (SEI decomposition, electrode reactions, electrolyte oxidation) and their exothermic rates using Arrhenius' formula. This model was calibrated using experimental data from Accelerating Rate Calorimetry (ARC) and needle penetration tests.
  2. Battery Module TRP Model: This cell-level model was then integrated into a three-dimensional finite element model of a battery module. This allowed for the simulation of heat transfer and propagation between cells, considering the module's geometry.
  3. Multi-Factor Analysis: The validated TRP model was used to simulate TRP under various conditions, including different thermal runaway trigger methods (fault evolution vs. sudden abuse), varying numbers of initially triggered cells, different protective materials (aerogel vs. insulation sheets), and a range of environmental temperatures.
  4. Safety Protection Strategy Design: Based on the multi-factor analysis, an optimal safety protection strategy was designed, focusing on the thickness and type of protective material (aerogel).

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data from:

  • ARC experiments: To calibrate the cell thermal runaway model.
  • Cell needle penetration and overcharge experiments: To calibrate fault evolution and sudden abuse trigger models.
  • Battery module TRP experiments: To validate the developed TRP model for both fault evolution and sudden abuse scenarios. These experiments involved triggering TR in specific cells within a module and monitoring temperature propagation using thermocouples and thermal imaging.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing experimental setups were used for model calibration and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TRP is a complex, multi-factor problem: The study strongly emphasizes that TRP is not solely dependent on the initial TR event but is significantly influenced by ambient temperature, the nature of the trigger (gradual vs. sudden), and the number of cells involved.
  • Aerogel is a highly effective TRP mitigation material: Aerogel demonstrated superior thermal insulation properties compared to conventional insulation films, significantly reducing TRP risk.
  • Optimizing protection involves a trade-off: While thicker aerogel provides better protection, it impacts the volumetric energy density of the battery module. The study identified an optimal thickness (2.5 mm) that balances safety and energy density.
  • Valve leakage temperature as a critical boundary: The study highlights the importance of the pressure relief valve opening temperature (around 141.20 °C) as a key threshold for preventing thermal propagation.
  • Model accuracy is crucial for safety design: The high goodness-of-fit (R² values often above 0.97) achieved in model validation underscores the reliability of their TRP model for designing effective safety strategies.

Key Results

  • A comprehensive TRP model for battery modules was successfully developed and validated against experimental data, showing high accuracy (average goodness of fit for cell temperatures around 0.97-0.98).
  • The study identified two distinct TR triggering modes: "fault evolution" (gradual) and "sudden abuse" (rapid).
  • Simulations showed that a 2.5 mm thick aerogel layer effectively prevented TRP in a battery module under various challenging conditions, including a 50 °C ambient temperature and multiple triggered cells.
  • The proposed 2.5 mm aerogel protection strategy resulted in only a 5.68% reduction in the volumetric energy density of the battery module, demonstrating a favorable balance between safety and performance.
  • The study found that fault evolution TR poses a greater risk of propagation than sudden abuse due to the longer duration of heat conduction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Energy density trade-off: While the 2.5 mm aerogel thickness was deemed optimal, the 5.68% reduction in volumetric energy density might still be a concern for certain applications.
  • Limited number of cells in module model: The module model included five cells, which might not fully represent larger, more complex battery packs.
  • Focus on LiFePO4: The study specifically focused on LiFePO4 batteries. Future work could explore the applicability of the model and protection strategies to other lithium-ion chemistries.
  • Further optimization of protection: While 2.5 mm aerogel was effective, further research could investigate even thinner protective layers or alternative materials for enhanced energy density.
  • Long-term degradation effects: The study primarily focused on fresh batteries. Investigating the impact of battery aging and degradation on TRP behavior and the effectiveness of protection strategies would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper addresses the challenge of thermal runaway propagation in lithium-ion battery modules and presents a safety protection design method based on a thermal propagation model. Firstly, it systematically analyzes the triggering mechanisms of thermal runaway in batteries, establishes a model for cell thermal runaway, and calibrates the model parameters through experiments. Secondly, by integrating the cell thermal runaway model and considering the three-dimensional structure of the battery module, a comprehensive thermal runaway propagation model is developed and validated. Subsequently, a simulation study on thermal runaway propagation, incorporating multi-factor influences and typical operating conditions, is conducted using the established thermal propagation model for the battery module. The study elucidates the thermal runaway propagation characteristics of the battery module under different safety protection strategies. The findings highlight that the proposed safety protection strategy effectively mitigates thermal propagation within the battery module, particularly when the thermal runaway is influenced by multiple factors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chai2024comprehensive,
  author = {Zhixiong Chai and Junqiu Li and Ziming Liu and Zhengnan Liu and Xin Jin},
  title = {{Comprehensive Modeling and Safety Protection Strategy for Thermal Runway Propagation in Lithium-Ion Battery Modules under Multi-Factor Influences}},
  booktitle = {Batteries},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/batteries10010031},
}
Figure