Comprehensive evaluation and dynamic evolution analysis of urban vulnerability of old industrial bases in Heilongjiang Province, China

Jingyuan Yuan, Yuze Li, Xiaoguang LiuProceedings of the 57th ISOCARP World Planning Congress 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Urban vulnerability is a critical metric for assessing the health and sustainability of urban development. This study focuses on 12 prefecture-level cities in Heilongjiang Province, China’s largest old industrial base, characterized by a history of heavy industry and resource dependence. By constructing an evaluation index system across ecological, resource, social, and economic subsystems, we analyze spatial patterns and dynamic evolution from 2010 to 2019. Results indicate that urban vulnerability peaked in 2013 before steadily declining and becoming more evenly distributed. While ecological and resource risks have stabilized, social vulnerability has emerged as a primary concern. Future revitalization efforts should prioritize economic transformation and social infrastructure.

Introduction

In the context of urban planning, "vulnerability" refers to a city's sensitivity to internal and external stressors and its inherent capacity for recovery. For the "rust belt" regions of Northeast China, particularly Heilongjiang Province, this concept is vital. Historically, these cities operated under a planned economy dominated by heavy industry and intensive resource extraction. This legacy resulted in unsustainable industrial structures, environmental degradation, and a long-term reliance on finite natural resources.

As China implements its "Northeast Revitalization" strategy, understanding the quantitative trajectory of urban resilience is essential. This paper provides a multi-dimensional evaluation of 12 cities to determine if policy interventions are effectively reducing urban fragility.

Methodology

The research employs a three-tiered quantitative framework to assess vulnerability:

  1. Index System Construction: 35 indicators were selected across four subsystems: Resources, Ecology, Society, and Economy.
  2. The Entropy Method: An objective mathematical approach was used to assign weights to indicators, minimizing human bias. Notably, the "ratio of heavy industry to gross industrial output" was identified as a high-weight factor (0.1271), underscoring its impact on regional stability.
  3. Grey Relational Analysis & Spatial Autocorrelation: These tools identified the primary drivers of vulnerability and analyzed geographic clustering (using the Moran’s I index) to see if high-risk areas were concentrated.

Data was sourced from the Statistical Yearbook of Chinese Cities and the Statistical Yearbook of Heilongjiang Province for the years 2010, 2013, 2015, 2017, and 2019.

Key Findings

Temporal Evolution and the 2013 Turning Point

The study reveals an "inverted U" trend in urban vulnerability. Between 2010 and 2013, vulnerability actually increased. This suggests that early revitalization efforts may have initially struggled, as cities continued to rely on heavy industry to stimulate growth, thereby increasing their sensitivity to economic and environmental shocks. However, after 2013, a steady decline was observed through 2019.

Shifting Drivers of Risk

The primary factors contributing to urban vulnerability have evolved significantly over the decade:

  • 2010: Ecological factors (pollution and environmental damage) were the dominant drivers.
  • 2013–2015: Economic factors, specifically the over-reliance on single-pillar industries, became the primary source of vulnerability.
  • 2019: Social vulnerability emerged as the strongest correlate. This indicates that while environmental and economic risks are being managed, infrastructure and social security (e.g., healthcare and education) have become the new bottlenecks for resilience.

Spatial Distribution

In 2015, the province experienced a distinct clustering of high-vulnerability areas. By 2019, this pattern shifted toward a more even distribution. The narrowing gap between cities suggests that provincial policies are successfully balancing resource allocation and preventing "laggard" cities from falling further behind.

Conclusion and Policy Recommendations

By 2019, all 12 studied cities moved into "low vulnerability" or "micro-vulnerable" categories (scores below 0.4). However, the shift toward social vulnerability as a primary driver suggests that the next phase of revitalization must move beyond environmental remediation.

To ensure high-quality, sustainable development, Heilongjiang Province should:

  • Accelerate Economic Transformation: Continue optimizing industrial structures to reduce dependence on heavy industry.
  • Strengthen Social Infrastructure: Increase investment in education, medical facilities, and social security to address current resilience bottlenecks.
  • Enhance Resource Efficiency: Improve the utilization rate of natural resources while maintaining ecological civilization standards.

This study underscores that urban resilience is a dynamic target, requiring planners to pivot their focus as cities transition from industrial hubs to modern, sustainable centers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban vulnerability has always been the main component of urban planning research, and it is an important basis for judging whether urban development is healthy and sustainable. As the largest old industrial bases in the country, northeast China has embarked on a development path dominated by heavy industry under the planned economy system. Its industrial structure is not sustainable, and it requires long-term reliance on natural resources. The ecological environment has been destroyed. Studying the urban vulnerability of old industrial bases in northeast China is of great significance for their revitalization as well as the promotion of high-quality urban development in China. Using 12 prefecture-level cities in the Heilongjiang Province in northeast China as the research subjects, an evaluation index system was constructed from four subsystems: ecological environment, resources, society, and economy. The spatial pattern and dynamic evolution of urban vulnerability from 2010 to 2019 were analyzed using the entropy method, comprehensive index method, and grey relational grade. The results were as follows. (1) Spatially, the urban vulnerability pattern of Heilongjiang Province in 2015 showed clustering of highvulnerability areas, and then the overall urban vulnerability decreased and tended to be evenly distributed. ( Resource vulnerability, ecological vulnerability, and social vulnerability steadily decreased, whereas economic vulnerability first increased and then decreased. (3) The correlation between urban comprehensive vulnerability and ecological vulnerability in Heilongjiang Province was the highest in 2010, and the correlation between urban vulnerability and economic vulnerability was the highest in 2013-2015, and then the correlation shifted to social vulnerability. In the future, during the revitalization of the old industrial bases, Heilongjiang Province should strengthen economic transformation, optimize the industrial structure, strengthen ecological civilization, and improve the utilization rate of resources.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yuan2021comprehensive,
  author = {Jingyuan Yuan and Yuze Li and Xiaoguang Liu},
  title = {{Comprehensive evaluation and dynamic evolution analysis of urban vulnerability of old industrial bases in Heilongjiang Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 57th ISOCARP World Planning Congress},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.47472/8zd9zkyn},
}
Figure