Comprehensive Assessment of Eutrophication in Xiamen Bay and Its Implications for Management Strategy in Southeast China

Yang Luo, Jinwen Liu, Jian Wu, Zheng Yuan, Jiwei Zhang, Chao Gao, Zhiyu LinInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces an improved method for assessing coastal eutrophication by integrating an "area ratio method" into the ASSETS framework, specifically applied to Xiamen Bay. This approach effectively mitigates the overestimation of eutrophication caused by localized "hotspots," providing a more accurate picture of the overall bay's health and informing targeted management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal eutrophication, characterized by excessive algal growth due to nutrient enrichment, is a significant environmental issue globally, particularly in China's offshore areas. Accurately assessing the severity and spatial distribution of eutrophication is crucial for effective pollution control and environmental protection. Traditional methods, often relying on nutrient concentrations or simple indicator averages, can be skewed by small areas with extremely high pollution levels, leading to an overestimation of the overall problem. This can obscure the true state of the broader ecosystem and hinder the development of appropriate management strategies. The paper aims to address this by refining assessment methodologies to provide a more robust and representative evaluation of eutrophication status.

Methods

The core innovation of this study is the integration of an area ratio method into the Assessment of the Estuarine Trophic Status (ASSETS) framework. The ASSETS method, a "phase II" approach, assesses eutrophication based on symptoms rather than solely on nutrient levels, categorizing indicators into "pressure," "state," and "response."

The key novelty lies in how the characteristic values of indicators for the entire assessed area (Xiamen Bay) are calculated. Instead of using simple mean values or quantiles across all monitoring stations, the area ratio method calculates the overall indicator value by weighting the values from individual assessment units (defined by sampling stations) by their respective areas. This ensures that larger areas with moderate pollution contribute proportionally more to the overall assessment than small, highly polluted areas.

The study also employs a multi-indicator approach, considering:

  • Pressure Indicators: Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), Dissolved Inorganic Nitrogen (DIN), and Dissolved Inorganic Phosphorus (DIP).
  • State Indicators: Chlorophyll-a concentration (primary symptom) and bottom layer Dissolved Oxygen (DO) and red tide occurrence (secondary symptoms).
  • Response Indicator: The estimated annual change rate of nutrient emissions.

These indicators are graded using a five-tier system (low to high), and a matrix analysis is used for the final eutrophication status determination.

Datasets

The study utilized annual water quality monitoring data from 17 monitoring stations in Xiamen Bay for the year 2016. This data was collected by the Xiamen Environmental Monitoring Station. Additionally, information on red tide occurrences and nutrient discharge rates was obtained from the Xiamen Municipal Marine Environmental State Bulletin for previous years and the years 2016-2017.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Hotspot" Problem: The paper highlights how localized areas with extreme pollution can disproportionately influence overall eutrophication assessments, leading to an overestimation of the problem in larger water bodies.
  • Area Ratio Method's Advantage: The area ratio method effectively dampens the impact of these localized "hotspots," providing a more scientifically sound representation of the overall eutrophication status, especially in complex bays with varied water quality.
  • Xiamen Bay's Specifics: The study reveals that Xiamen Bay's eutrophication is driven by concentrated pollution sources (particularly from the Jiulong River) and poor hydrodynamic conditions in the western and northern parts of the bay.
  • Seasonal Variation is Key: Eutrophication in Xiamen Bay is most severe in autumn and least severe in spring, with flood seasons being a critical period for pollutant discharge from the Jiulong River.
  • Maluan Bay as a Critical Zone: Maluan Bay emerges as the area with the most severe eutrophication, characterized by high chlorophyll-a and surface DO, but low bottom DO, indicating concentrated pollution and poor water circulation.

Key Results

  • In 2016, Xiamen Bay's eutrophication status was assessed as moderate.
  • The pressure indicator scored "high" (one point), the state indicator scored "medium" (three points), and the response indicator scored "low" (five points).
  • The area ratio method yielded characteristic values that were significantly lower than those calculated using the mean value method, demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing overestimation.
  • The western and northern sea areas of Xiamen Bay exhibited higher eutrophication pressure than the eastern and southern areas.
  • Maluan Bay and the Jiulong River Estuary were identified as the areas requiring the most urgent management interventions.
  • Controlling pollution discharge from the Jiulong River during flood seasons was identified as a critical strategy for reducing eutrophication in Xiamen Bay.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: While the area ratio method is shown to be effective even with limited observational data, the study acknowledges that more comprehensive data would further enhance the assessment.
  • Management Strategy Focus: The paper implies the need for stricter measures in Maluan Bay, focusing on nutrient input limitation and hydrodynamic improvements, and emphasizes controlling Jiulong River discharge during flood seasons. Future work could involve developing detailed, site-specific management plans based on these findings.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors suggest that the developed method is applicable to other similar bays globally, indicating potential for future comparative studies and broader environmental management applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The eutrophication of coastal water has been a critical environmental problem in China's offshore areas. How to effectively assess the status of coastal waters is key for pollution treatment and environmental protection. In recent years, eutrophication-symptom-based and multi-indicator methods, termed "phase II" methods, have been gradually adopted to assess the eutrophication status in some coastal waters in China and have achieved success. The cumulative quantile is typically selected to determine the characteristic value of an indicator in "phase II" methods. The influence of small-scale damaged water bodies on eutrophication assessment may be exaggerated, which often leads to the overassessment of the eutrophication status. In this study, the area ratio method was integrated into the assessment of the estuarine trophic status (ASSETS) method in order to assess the eutrophication status of Xiamen Bay in 2016. The results indicated that, in 2016, the eutrophication status of Xiamen Bay coastal waters was moderate and exhibited spatiotemporal variation. The area ratio method can effectively reduce the effect of small-scale coastal waters with extremely high eutrophication on the overassessment of eutrophication at the broader scale, allowing the eutrophication status to be better reflected, even with limited observation data. The centralized distribution of pollution sources and poor hydrodynamic conditions are the main reasons for the aforementioned phenomenon. Controlling the pollution discharge from the Jiulong River in flood seasons is key to reducing eutrophication in Xiamen coastal waters.
BibTeX
@article{luo2022comprehensive,
  author = {Yang Luo and Jinwen Liu and Jian Wu and Zheng Yuan and Jiwei Zhang and Chao Gao and Zhiyu Lin},
  title = {{Comprehensive Assessment of Eutrophication in Xiamen Bay and Its Implications for Management Strategy in Southeast China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192013055},
}
Figure