Abstract
A comprehensive investigation of the input parameters in a plasma-liquid interaction (PLI) for the removal of methylene blue (MB) in artificial wastewater was conducted using a cold atmospheric pressure Ar plasma jet (jet temperature ≤ 40 °C). The Ar plasma jet was generated by a gliding arc configuration and driven with a 50 Hz AC high voltage. The effects of key parameters on MB removal efficiency were systematically examined, including stirring solution, distance from the plasma jet source to the liquid surface, interaction time, initial MB concentration, and Ar flow rate. These results indicate that increasing the Ar flow rate, treatment time, and stirring solution improved the MB removal efficiency. In contrast, the efficiency decreased with distance and the initial MB solution. To evaluate the magnitude of these factors, a quadratic equation was developed to predict MB removal efficiency, demonstrating good agreement with the experimental data. Consequently, the relative importance of the factors based on first-order coefficients was determined as follows: treatment time > Ar flow rate > initial MB concentration > distance > stirring solution. These findings provide valuable insights for optimizing the plasma configuration and operating conditions for efficient MB removal via PLI treatment. Remarkably, 99% of MB degradation in the feed (20 mg L⁻¹) was achieved within 50 minutes of treatment, with an energy efficiency of 82.76 mg MB per kW per h, corresponding to 241.67 kW h m⁻³ for an initial MB of 20 mg L⁻¹. This process is environmentally friendly owing to its low electrical energy consumption and the fact that no chemicals are used.
Introduction
The textile and dyeing industries generate massive volumes of wastewater containing synthetic dyes like methylene blue (MB). MB is heterocyclic, aromatic, and toxic to both aquatic life and humans, making it notoriously difficult to treat. Traditional treatment methods—such as physical adsorption, chemical flocculation, or biological degradation—often suffer from slow kinetics, high operational costs, or the generation of secondary hazardous sludge.
Atmospheric-pressure non-thermal plasma (NTP) has emerged as a powerful Advanced Oxidation Process (AOP). It generates reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS) that can mineralize organic pollutants directly at the liquid interface. However, the interaction between plasma and liquid is complex. This study addresses the lack of a comprehensive, multi-variable analysis to determine which experimental conditions most significantly impact treatment efficiency and energy consumption.
Experimental Methodology
The researchers utilized a cold atmospheric pressure Argon (Ar) plasma jet generated via a gliding arc configuration and driven by a 50 Hz AC high voltage. The "cold" nature of the jet, maintaining a temperature ≤ 40 °C, is crucial for energy efficiency and safety in treating heat-sensitive wastewater.
Key Methodological Components:
- Experimental Design: A systematic variation of five parameters: stirring speed, nozzle-to-liquid distance, interaction time, initial MB concentration, and Ar flow rate.
- Statistical Modeling: A Box-Behnken design (BBD) and Design-Expert software were used to develop a quadratic equation to predict removal efficiency and quantify the relative importance of each factor.
- Analytical Characterization:
- UV-Vis Spectroscopy: Used to measure MB concentration via absorbance at 665 nm.
- Optical Emission Spectroscopy (OES): Used to identify reactive species (OH, O, $N_2^*$, etc.) produced in the plasma plume.
- FTIR Spectroscopy: Employed to analyze chemical structural changes in the MB molecules post-treatment.
Artificial wastewater was prepared using Methylene Blue trihydrate in distilled water at concentrations ranging from 5 to 20 mg/L. The resulting experimental matrix was used to train and validate the quadratic model.
Results and Discussion
Hierarchy of Influence
The study determined a clear order of importance for operational factors: Treatment time > Ar flow rate > Initial MB concentration > Distance > Stirring solution. This hierarchy provides a roadmap for engineers to prioritize parameters during system scale-up.
Degradation and Mineralization
FTIR analysis confirmed that the plasma treatment actively breaks the aromatic ring structures of the MB molecule, converting it into lighter, less harmful molecules and eventually mineralizing it into products like $NO_3^-$, $SO_4^{2-}$, and $CO_2$. The system achieved 99% degradation of a 20 mg/L MB solution within 50 minutes.
Energy Performance and Stability
The process reached an energy efficiency of 82.76 mg MB per kW·h, which is significantly higher than traditional flat Dielectric Barrier Discharge (DBD) systems (typically ~46.7 mg/kWh). Electrical analysis showed that the MB solution behaves like a dielectric surface, ensuring the plasma discharge remains stable and consistent throughout the treatment process.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The developed quadratic model showed excellent agreement with experimental data (predicted $R^2$ of 0.9099). While the results are promising, transitioning this to a large-scale industrial flow-through system remains a significant engineering hurdle, particularly regarding the plasma exposure area. Future designs should focus on maximizing the plasma-liquid contact area to reduce treatment times further and improve throughput for industrial applications. This study demonstrates that plasma-liquid interaction is a highly efficient and "green" pathway for advanced water treatment without the need for chemical additives.
Summary updated