Comprehensive Analysis for the Impact of Hydrogen Blending on the Economic and Environmental Performance of Natural Gas Pipeline Network

Bo Zhang, Ning Xu, Haoran Zhang, Bohong Wang, Rui Qiu, Qi Liao, Yongtu Liang2023 · DOI

This paper, published in Energy Proceedings (2023), explores the technical and economic realities of "hydrogen blending"—the practice of mixing hydrogen into existing natural gas (NG) infrastructure. While often touted as a "green" bridge for the energy transition, hydrogen significantly alters the physical properties of the gas stream. The authors propose a mathematical optimization model to determine how pipeline compressors should adapt to these changes to minimize costs and carbon footprints.

TL;DR

Blending hydrogen into natural gas pipelines requires a fundamental rethink of compressor operations due to changes in gas density and energy content. By using a new optimization model that adjusts compressor speeds based on real-time gas properties, operators can reduce system costs and carbon emissions by an average of 11.48% compared to non-optimized setups.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hydrogen is a promising clean fuel, but building dedicated "pure hydrogen" pipelines is prohibitively expensive. Blending hydrogen into existing natural gas networks is a viable alternative, but it introduces a major engineering challenge: hydrogen is much lighter and less energy-dense (volumetrically) than methane.

When you add hydrogen, the mixture's density, calorific value, and compressibility change. This affects the hydraulics of the pipeline and the efficiency of the centrifugal compressors that keep the gas moving. Most previous studies assumed compressors would run at fixed speeds or pressures regardless of the blend. This paper addresses the gap by asking: How should we optimize compressor operation for different blending ratios and different delivery requirements (e.g., delivering a fixed volume vs. a fixed amount of energy)?

Methods

The authors developed a mathematical programming model focused on the adaptability of the transportation process. Key components include:

  • Objective Function: Minimizing the total energy consumption (power) of all compressors in the network.
  • Physical Constraints: The model uses the gas flow theory and a modified Benedict–Webb–Rubin (BWR) equation of state to account for the non-ideal behavior of gas mixtures.
  • Compressor Modeling: It incorporates "affinity laws" and characteristic maps, specifically accounting for surge (unstable flow at low rates) and chock (maximum flow limits) conditions.
  • Scenario Analysis: The researchers tested four scenarios to reflect real-world boundary conditions:
  • Baseline (BS): Pure natural gas.
  • Setpoint Flow (SF): Maintaining a constant volume of gas delivered.
  • Setpoint Pressure (SP): Maintaining a constant delivery pressure.
  • Setpoint Heat Flow (SH): Maintaining a constant amount of energy delivered (crucial for end-users like power plants).

Datasets

The study uses a simulated "gun barrel" pipeline case study—a single-source, single-offload system.

  • Pipeline Specs: Two segments (100km and 30km) with a 406mm diameter.
  • Equipment: A centrifugal compressor with specific quadratic performance curves (detailed in Table 2 of the paper).
  • Gas Properties: Standard values for methane and hydrogen density and heating values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Energy Density" Trap: The most striking insight is the difference between the SF and SH scenarios. If you only care about moving a certain volume of gas (SF), adding hydrogen makes the gas lighter and easier to pump, reducing costs. However, because hydrogen has a lower volumetric heating value, you must pump significantly more gas to deliver the same amount of energy (SH).
  • Compressor Limits are the Hard Ceiling: The maximum blending ratio isn't just a safety or material issue; it's often limited by the compressor's mechanical range. In the energy-delivery scenario (SH), the maximum blending ratio was a mere 2.52% before the system hit its limits, compared to 27.3% in the volume-delivery scenario.
  • Optimization is Non-Negotiable: Simply adjusting the compressor's rotational speed to account for the new gas mixture (rather than leaving it at a fixed setting) yielded an 11.48% improvement in efficiency.

Key Results

  • Economic Impact: For every 1% of hydrogen added, annual operating costs varied wildly depending on the goal: from a decrease of $0.73 million** (in volume-controlled scenarios) to an **increase of $1.67 million (in energy-controlled scenarios).
  • Environmental Impact: Carbon emissions followed a similar trend. In the SF scenario, max blending (27.3%) reduced annual carbon emissions from 10.63 kilotons to 7.57 kilotons (a 28.73% drop).
  • Efficiency Gains: The optimization model successfully reduced the "transmission power" required by 11.48% compared to baseline non-optimized operations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Network Complexity: The study uses a simple "gun barrel" (linear) pipeline. Real-world networks are complex, meshed grids with multiple sources and offloads, which would make the optimization much more computationally intensive.
  • Algorithmic Speed: The authors acknowledge that their current model (a nonconvex mixed-integer nonlinear program) is slow and suggest that faster algorithms are needed for large-scale applications.
  • Narrow Scope: The paper focuses strictly on hydraulics and economics. It does not account for hydrogen embrittlement (the tendency of hydrogen to make steel pipes brittle), leakage rates, or the compatibility of end-user appliances (like stoves or industrial boilers) with high hydrogen blends.

Summary updated

Abstract

Blending hydrogen into the existing natural gas pipeline network is regarded as a potential mode in the future.However, the influence of hydrogen on the economic and environmental performance of natural gas pipeline networks remained unclear.This paper established a mathematical programming model to get the optimal operation plan of the pipeline system under different hydrogen blending ratios, and the operation costs and carbon emissions of the hydrogen mixed system are analyzed accordingly.The studied case demonstrated that: (1) The optimization model has significant potential in reducing the economic cost and carbon emission of the system with an average decrease of 11.48%.(2) For every 1% of hydrogen added, the annual operating cost varies from minus $0.73 million to positive $1.67 million, and carbon emission varies from minus 0.38 kiloton to $0.76 kiloton.The proposed optimization model can provide theoretical guidance for the further application of this transportation mode.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023comprehensive,
  author = {Bo Zhang and Ning Xu and Haoran Zhang and Bohong Wang and Rui Qiu and Qi Liao and Yongtu Liang},
  title = {{Comprehensive Analysis for the Impact of Hydrogen Blending on the Economic and Environmental Performance of Natural Gas Pipeline Network}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.46855/energy-proceedings-10357},
}
Figure