Compositions and Co-occurrence Patterns of Bacterial Communities Associated With Polymer- and ASP-Flooded Petroleum Reservoir Blocks

Guoling Ren, Jinlong Wang, Lina Qu, Wei Li, Min Hu, Lihong Bian, Yiting Zhang, Jianjun Le, Xumou Dou, Xinhong Chen, Lulu Bai, Yue LiFrontiers in Microbiology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Polymer flooding technology and alkaline-surfactant-polymer (ASP) flooding technology have been widely used in some oil reservoirs. About 50% of remaining oil is trapped, however, in polymer-flooded and ASP-flooded reservoirs. How to further improve oil recovery of these reservoirs after chemical flooding is technically challenging. Microbial enhanced oil recovery (MEOR) technology is a promising alternative technology. However, the bacterial communities in the polymer-flooded and ASP-flooded reservoirs have rarely been investigated. We investigated the distribution and co-occurrence patterns of bacterial communities in ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded oil production wells. We found that Arcobacter and Pseudomonas were dominant both in the polymer-flooded and ASP-flooded production wells. Halomonas accounted for a large amount of the bacterial communities inhabiting in the ASP-flooded blocks, whereas they were hardly detected in the polymer-flooded blocks, and the trends for Acetomicrobium were the opposite. RDA analysis indicated that bacterial communities in ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded oil production wells are closely related to the physical and chemical properties, such as high salinity and strong alkaline, which together accounted for 56.91% of total variance. Co-occurrence network analysis revealed non-random combination patterns of bacterial composition from production wells of ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded blocks, and the ASP-flooded treatment decreased bacterial network complexity, suggesting that the application of ASP flooding technology reduced the tightness of bacterial interactions.

Introduction

In petroleum engineering, "Enhanced Oil Recovery" (EOR) is critical for extracting residual oil from aging reservoirs. Even after primary and secondary recovery phases, nearly 50% of the oil remains trapped within rock pores. Technologies such as polymer flooding and Alkaline-Surfactant-Polymer (ASP) flooding are deployed to mobilize this oil; however, these methods are costly and eventually reach a point of diminishing returns.

Microbial Enhanced Oil Recovery (MEOR)—utilizing indigenous bacteria to produce surfactants or gases that loosen oil—represents a promising, sustainable alternative. To implement MEOR effectively, it is essential to characterize the existing microbial populations in chemically treated reservoirs. This study addresses the knowledge gap regarding how different chemical flooding methods reshape the microbial landscape and their ecological interactions.

Methodology

Researchers sampled production water from 121 wells (45 polymer-flooded and 76 ASP-flooded) at the Daqing Oil Field in China. The study utilized a total of 6,641,650 16S rRNA sequences generated via the Illumina MiSeq platform.

The analysis employed several high-throughput and statistical techniques:

  • 16S rRNA Gene Sequencing: Used to identify bacterial species via genetic "barcodes."
  • Bioinformatics Pipeline: Utilized QIIME2 and UPARSE to cluster sequences into Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs).
  • Redundancy Analysis (RDA): Correlated bacterial community changes with environmental factors such as pH, salinity, and temperature.
  • Co-occurrence Network Analysis: Determined the interaction patterns between different bacterial genera to assess community complexity.

Results and Discussion

Community Composition and Environmental Filtering

The study revealed significant shifts in microbial community structure between the two flooding treatments. Arcobacter and Pseudomonas were identified as dominant generalists in both reservoir types. These genera are known for their ability to degrade hydrocarbons and survive harsh industrial environments, making them prime candidates for future MEOR efforts.

Bacterial community compositions at the genus level from production wells at ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded blocks.

However, the extreme alkaline conditions of ASP-flooded blocks (average pH 10.76) acted as a powerful environmental filter. This favored alkali-tolerant groups like Halomonas, which were prevalent in ASP-flooded wells but nearly absent in polymer-flooded blocks. Conversely, Acetomicrobium was common in the more neutral polymer-flooded blocks (pH 8.2) but was largely eliminated by ASP treatment.

Comparison of the proportions of dominant bacterial genera and their 95% confidence intervals between ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded treatments.

Statistical analysis through RDA confirmed that physical and chemical properties—primarily pH and salinity—accounted for 56.91% of the total variance in bacterial composition.

Network Erosion and Ecological Interactions

A striking finding was the impact of ASP flooding on the "social networks" of the bacteria. Co-occurrence network analysis showed that ASP flooding significantly reduced the complexity and tightness of bacterial interactions. While the polymer-flooded network consisted of 1,242 nodes and 39,614 edges, the ASP-flooded network, despite having a similar number of nodes (1,200), had only 10,073 edges. This suggests that the extreme chemical stress of ASP flooding breaks down established ecological relationships between species.

Conclusion

This research provides a high-resolution map of the microbial landscape in chemically treated oil reservoirs. While identifying potential candidates for MEOR, the study also highlights the challenges posed by extreme environmental conditions. Future work must bridge the "functional gap" by determining the metabolic activity of these microbes through metagenomics and metatranscriptomics. Understanding the temporal dynamics of these communities will be essential for developing effective, long-term MEOR strategies in the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Polymer flooding technology and alkaline-surfactant-polymer (ASP) flooding technology have been widely used in some oil reservoirs. About 50% of remaining oil is trapped, however, in polymer-flooded and ASP-flooded reservoirs. How to further improve oil recovery of these reservoirs after chemical flooding is technically challenging. Microbial enhanced oil recovery (MEOR) technology is a promising alternative technology. However, the bacterial communities in the polymer-flooded and ASP-flooded reservoirs have rarely been investigated. We investigated the distribution and co-occurrence patterns of bacterial communities in ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded oil production wells. We found that Arcobacter and Pseudomonas were dominant both in the polymer-flooded and ASP-flooded production wells. Halomonas accounted for a large amount of the bacterial communities inhabiting in the ASP-flooded blocks, whereas they were hardly detected in the polymer-flooded blocks, and the trends for Acetomicrobium were the opposite. RDA analysis indicated that bacterial communities in ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded oil production wells are closely related to the physical and chemical properties, such as high salinity and strong alkaline, which together accounted for 56.91% of total variance. Co-occurrence network analysis revealed non-random combination patterns of bacterial composition from production wells of ASP-flooded and polymer-flooded blocks, and the ASP-flooded treatment decreased bacterial network complexity, suggesting that the application of ASP flooding technology reduced the tightness of bacterial interactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2020compositions,
  author = {Guoling Ren and Jinlong Wang and Lina Qu and Wei Li and Min Hu and Lihong Bian and Yiting Zhang and Jianjun Le and Xumou Dou and Xinhong Chen and Lulu Bai and Yue Li},
  title = {{Compositions and Co-occurrence Patterns of Bacterial Communities Associated With Polymer- and ASP-Flooded Petroleum Reservoir Blocks}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2020.580363},
}
Figure