Complex Reasoning in Natural Language

Wenting Zhao, Mor Geva, Bill Yuchen Lin, Michihiro Yasunaga, Aman Madaan, Tao YuACL 2023

This tutorial provides a comprehensive overview of complex reasoning tasks in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and surveys recent advancements in tackling these challenges. It aims to equip researchers and practitioners with a structured understanding of state-of-the-art approaches beyond standard fine-tuning of large language models.

TL;DR

This tutorial addresses the limitations of standard fine-tuning for complex NLP reasoning tasks, where models often learn superficial patterns. It surveys recent approaches that explicitly incorporate problem structures, including knowledge augmentation, few-shot prompting, neuro-symbolic methods, and rationale-based techniques, to build more robust and interpretable reasoning systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Natural Language Processing (NLP) has long aimed to enable machines to reason over text. While fine-tuning pre-trained language models (LMs) on specific downstream tasks has been a common strategy, recent research reveals this approach is often brittle. Models can achieve high performance by exploiting superficial data patterns rather than genuine reasoning. For instance, performance on question-answering tasks can remain high even when questions are removed from the input, and models trained on multi-hop reasoning may fail on simpler single-hop questions. This indicates that current models lack robust reasoning capabilities. Consequently, there's a growing need for techniques that augment LMs to make them more effective and reliable for complex reasoning.

Methods

The tutorial categorizes promising approaches into four main groups:

  • Knowledge-Augmented Methods: These methods aim to incorporate external knowledge into LMs.
  • Fine-Tuning: Knowledge can be retrieved and fused with LM-based modules during fine-tuning. This includes using structured knowledge graphs (e.g., ConceptNet), unstructured knowledge corpora (e.g., Wikipedia), and instance-based knowledge (annotated examples).
  • Pretraining: Knowledge is integrated during the pretraining phase. This includes retrieval-augmented pretraining (feeding relevant documents) and incorporating structured knowledge graphs to create additional pretraining objectives or direct inputs.
  • Few-Shot Prompting Approaches: With the rise of large LMs like GPT-3, few-shot prompting has become powerful. However, these methods can be sensitive to prompt design and exhibit peculiar failure modes in complex reasoning. Techniques discussed include:
  • Prompt Design: Methods like chain-of-thought and least-to-most prompting guide LMs to generate reasoning steps.
  • Dynamic Prompting: Techniques that adapt prompts based on input queries, such as selecting training examples or editing prompts based on feedback.
  • Code-Generation Models: Leveraging models like Codex for structured commonsense reasoning, algorithmic reasoning, and generating chain-of-thought reasoning chains in Python.
  • Neuro-Symbolic Approaches: These methods combine neural networks with symbolic reasoning. While neural models excel at end-to-end mapping, they lack interpretability. Symbolic approaches provide explicit intermediate representations (logical forms, reasoning paths) that are interpretable and robust. This category explores combining neural modules with symbolic components, using domain-specific languages, and leveraging models like GPT-3 Codex to generate executable programs.
  • Rationale-Based Approaches: These methods extract parts of the input (tokens, sentences, documents) as "rationales" to explain predictions, enhancing trustworthiness and interpretability. They can be used as additional supervision to improve reasoning or build more robust NLP systems. Approaches include multi-task loss functions, specialized architectures, and semi-supervised/unsupervised methods.

Datasets

The paper references numerous datasets used in the field of complex reasoning, including:

  • Compositional Reasoning: Geva et al. (2021), Trivedi et al. (2022)
  • Knowledge Retrieval: Yang et al. (2018), Kwiatkowski et al. (2019)
  • Grounding: Budzianowski et al. (2018), Xie et al. (2022), Shi et al. (2021)
  • Commonsense Reasoning: Talmor et al. (2021a), Lin et al. (2020)
  • Multi-modal Benchmarks: Chen et al. (2020b), Talmor et al. (2021b), Pasupat and Liang (2015), Chen et al. (2020a)
  • Open-Domain Setups: Geva et al. (2021), Onoe et al. (2021), Ferguson et al. (2020), Talmor and Berant (2018)
  • Specific Datasets Mentioned: HotpotQA, DROP, MuSiQue, CommonsenseQA 2.0, MultiWOZ, Natural Questions, Creak.

The paper also highlights the importance of key practices for dataset creation that increase data diversity and minimize annotation biases and reasoning shortcuts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Brittleness of Standard Fine-Tuning: The core problem is that standard fine-tuning often leads to models that learn superficial correlations rather than true reasoning, making them unreliable.
  • Explicit Structure is Key: The most promising directions for complex reasoning involve explicitly incorporating problem structures, whether through knowledge, step-by-step reasoning processes, or symbolic representations.
  • Neuro-Symbolic Synergy: Combining the pattern recognition of neural networks with the interpretability and robustness of symbolic methods offers a powerful path forward.
  • Rationale as Supervision: Using rationales (explanations) as part of the training process can significantly improve model robustness and trustworthiness.
  • Prompt Engineering is Crucial (and Tricky): While few-shot prompting is powerful, its effectiveness is highly dependent on prompt design, highlighting the need for more robust prompting techniques.

Key Results

The paper is a tutorial and survey, so it doesn't present new empirical results. Instead, it synthesizes findings from numerous prior works. The key "results" are the identification of effective strategies and the categorization of approaches that have shown promise in improving complex reasoning capabilities of LMs. These include:

  • Knowledge augmentation (retrieval, graph integration) improving performance on knowledge-intensive tasks.
  • Chain-of-thought prompting demonstrating significant gains in reasoning tasks by eliciting intermediate steps.
  • Neuro-symbolic methods showing potential for more interpretable and robust reasoning.
  • Rationale-based methods improving model trustworthiness and performance.

Limitations and Future Work

The tutorial acknowledges that despite advancements, complex reasoning remains a challenging area. Limitations and future directions implied or discussed include:

  • Interpretability and Robustness: While progress is being made, achieving truly interpretable and robust reasoning systems is an ongoing challenge.
  • Generalization: Models often struggle to generalize across different reasoning tasks or domains.
  • Data Requirements: Many neuro-symbolic methods still require significant human design and large amounts of training data.
  • Prompt Sensitivity: Few-shot prompting methods remain sensitive to prompt design, requiring further research into more stable techniques.
  • Scalability: Developing methods that scale effectively to larger models and more complex reasoning chains is crucial.
  • Dataset Quality: Continued focus on creating high-quality, diverse datasets that minimize shortcuts is essential for progress.

The tutorial itself is presented as a step towards addressing these challenges by providing a structured overview of current research directions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023complex,
  author = {Wenting Zhao and Mor Geva and Bill Yuchen Lin and Michihiro Yasunaga and Aman Madaan and Tao Yu},
  title = {{Complex Reasoning in Natural Language}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure