Complete waveform model for compact binaries on eccentric orbits

E. A. Huerta, P. Kumar, Bhanu Agarwal, D. George, Hsi-Yu Schive, Harald Pfeiffer, Roland Haas, Wei Ren, Tony Chu, Michael Boyle, Daniel A. Hemberger, Larry Kidder, Mark Scheel, Béla SzilágyiPhysical 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new waveform model, "ax-model," for simulating the entire gravitational wave signal from compact binary mergers, including inspiral, merger, and ringdown, specifically for systems on eccentric orbits. This model is crucial for accurately detecting and characterizing these eccentric binary systems with current and future gravitational wave observatories like LIGO.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gravitational wave astronomy has entered a new era with the direct detection of binary black hole (BBH) mergers. While most current waveform models focus on nearly circular orbits, astrophysical simulations suggest that a significant fraction of compact binaries, especially those formed in dense stellar environments like globular clusters, can retain significant eccentricity when they enter the LIGO detection band. These eccentric orbits lead to distinct gravitational wave signals that are not well-captured by existing models, potentially hindering detection and accurate parameter estimation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive waveform model for eccentric compact binaries.

Methods

The authors developed an "advanced x-model" (ax-model) that combines several key advancements:

  • Third-order Post-Newtonian (PN) Expansion: The inspiral phase is modeled using 3PN accurate equations for both the binary's motion and its far-zone radiation field. This includes contributions from tails, tails-of-tails, and non-linear memory effects.
  • Higher-Order Corrections: To improve phase accuracy, they incorporated 3.5PN corrections for quasi-circular orbits and gravitational self-force corrections to the binding energy.
  • Merger and Ringdown: A fully analytical prescription for the merger-ringdown phase is constructed by calibrating the Implicit Rotating Source (IRS) formalism against a catalog of numerical relativity (NR) simulations.
  • Hybridization: The inspiral and merger-ringdown phases are smoothly stitched together using a carefully chosen attachment time.
  • Eccentricity Decay: The model accounts for the decay of eccentricity due to gravitational wave emission, showing that most moderately eccentric systems circularize before reaching the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO).

Datasets

  • Numerical Relativity (NR) Simulations: The authors utilized a catalog of NR simulations for both quasi-circular and eccentric BBH systems. These simulations were crucial for calibrating the merger-ringdown model and validating the eccentric inspiral-merger-ringdown model. Specifically, they used NR simulations for mass ratios up to 10 for quasi-circular systems and for mass ratios of 1 and 2 for eccentric systems.
  • SEOBNRv2 Waveforms: These are state-of-the-art quasi-circular, spin-aligned waveform models used for comparison and validation of the ax-model in the zero-eccentricity limit.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Eccentricity Matters for Detection: The study highlights that even moderate eccentricities (e.g., $e_0 \ge 0.1$) can significantly reduce the overlap between eccentric signals and quasi-circular templates, making detection challenging.
  • Signal Manifolds are Orthogonal: For eccentricities $e_0 \ge 0.1$, the signal manifold of eccentric binaries appears largely orthogonal to that of quasi-circular binaries (both non-spinning and spin-aligned). This implies that current search strategies might miss these signals.
  • Circularization is Key: The model relies on the observation that most compact binaries, even those starting with moderate eccentricity, circularize significantly by the time they reach the ISCO. This allows for a hybrid approach combining eccentric inspiral with quasi-circular merger-ringdown.
  • Spin Alignment Doesn't Fully Compensate: For eccentric signals with $e_0 \ge 0.1$, using spin-aligned templates does not significantly improve recovery compared to non-spinning templates, suggesting that spin degrees of freedom don't fully capture the eccentricity effect.

Key Results

  • Accurate Model for Eccentric Binaries: The ax-model accurately reproduces the dynamics of eccentric BBH mergers, showing good agreement with NR simulations for mass ratios of 1 and 2.
  • High Overlap with Quasi-Circular Models (Zero Eccentricity): In the zero-eccentricity limit, the ax-model shows high overlap ( $\ge 0.95$) with the SEOBNRv2 model across a wide range of BBH parameter space accessible to LIGO.
  • Detectability of GW Transients: The study estimates that GW150914 could be recovered with a fitting factor (FF) $\ge 0.95$ if its initial eccentricity was $e_0 \le 0.15$, and GW151226 with FF $\ge 0.94$ if $e_0 \le 0.1$.
  • Poor Recovery of Moderately Eccentric Systems: For systems with astrophysically motivated eccentricities ($e_0 \sim 0.1$), recovery with quasi-circular templates is poor (FF $\le 0.85$), indicating the need for new detection algorithms.
  • Computational Efficiency: The ax-model is computationally efficient, generating a waveform in about 0.5 seconds for a typical system, making it suitable for large-scale data analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Modeling Errors in Zero Eccentricity: The authors acknowledge that in the low-eccentricity regime ($e_0 \le 0.05$), the overlap between the ax-model and quasi-circular templates might be influenced by modeling errors of the ax-model itself in the zero-eccentricity limit.
  • Merger-Ringdown Prescription: The accuracy of the merger-ringdown prescription (gIRS model) deteriorates several cycles before merger. Future work will focus on developing a more robust merger-ringdown model that extends further back in time.
  • Higher-Order PN and Self-Force Corrections: The model will be further improved by incorporating second-order corrections in the symmetric mass-ratio for PN calculations and by including missing $n^2$ corrections in the energy flux expression.
  • Spinning Eccentric Binaries: A significant future direction is to develop waveform models that can describe eccentric binaries with non-zero spins, which are expected to be more common.
  • New Data Analysis Algorithms: The authors emphasize the necessity of developing new data analysis algorithms specifically designed to target eccentric GW sources.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a time domain waveform model that describes the inspiral, merger and ringdown of compact binary systems whose components are nonspinning, and which evolve on orbits with low to moderate eccentricity. The inspiral evolution is described using third-order post-Newtonian equations both for the equations of motion of the binary, and its far-zone radiation field. This latter component also includes instantaneous, tails and tails-of-tails contributions, and a contribution due to nonlinear memory. This framework reduces to the post-Newtonian approximant TaylorT4 at third post-Newtonian order in the zero-eccentricity limit. To improve phase accuracy, we also incorporate higher-order post-Newtonian corrections for the energy flux of quasicircular binaries and gravitational self-force corrections to the binding energy of compact binaries. This enhanced prescription for the inspiral evolution is combined with a fully analytical prescription for the merger-ringdown evolution constructed using a catalog of numerical relativity simulations. We show that this inspiral-merger-ringdown waveform model reproduces the effective-one-body model of Ref. [Y. Pan et al., Phys. Rev. D 89, 061501 (2014).] for quasicircular black hole binaries with mass ratios between 1 to 15 in the zero-eccentricity limit over a wide range of the parameter space under consideration. Using a set of eccentric numerical relativity simulations, not used during calibration, we show that our new eccentric model reproduces the true features of eccentric compact binary coalescence throughout merger. We use this model to show that the gravitational-wave transients GW150914 and GW151226 can be effectively recovered with template banks of quasicircular, spin-aligned waveforms if the eccentricity ${e}_{0}$ of these systems when they enter the aLIGO band at a gravitational-wave frequency of 14 Hz satisfies ${e}_{0}^{\mathrm{GW}150914}\ensuremath{\le}0.15$ and ${e}_{0}^{\mathrm{GW}151226}\ensuremath{\le}0.1$. We also find that varying the spin combinations of the quasicircular, spin-aligned template waveforms does not improve the recovery of nonspinning, eccentric signals when ${e}_{0}\ensuremath{\ge}0.1$. This suggests that these two signal manifolds are predominantly orthogonal.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huerta2017complete,
  author = {E. A. Huerta and P. Kumar and Bhanu Agarwal and D. George and Hsi-Yu Schive and Harald Pfeiffer and Roland Haas and Wei Ren and Tony Chu and Michael Boyle and Daniel A. Hemberger and Larry Kidder and Mark Scheel and Béla Szilágyi},
  title = {{Complete waveform model for compact binaries on eccentric orbits}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.95.024038},
}
Figure