Complementarity of resonant scalar, vector-like quark and superpartner searches in elucidating new phenomena

Anke Biekötter, JoAnne L. Hewett, Jong Soo Kim, Michael Krämer, Thomas G. Rizzo, Krzysztof Rolbiecki, Jamie Tattersall, T. WeberInternational Journal of Modern Physics A 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The elucidation of the nature of new phenomena requires a multi-pronged approach to understand the essential physics that underlies it. As an example, we study the simplified model containing a new scalar singlet accompanied by vector-like quarks. To be specific, we investigate three models with $SU(2)_L$-doublet, vector-like quarks with Yukawa couplings to a new scalar singlet and which also couple off-diagonally to corresponding Standard Model fermions of the first or third generation through the usual Higgs boson. We demonstrate that three classes of searches can play important and complementary roles in constraining this model. In particular, we find that missing energy searches designed for sparticle production, are also very sensitive to vector-like quarks.

Introduction

In the search for physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM), experimentalists often encounter "bumps" in data—localized excesses that hint at new particles. A prominent historical example was the 750 GeV diphoton excess observed at the LHC. Understanding such signals requires "recasting": taking experimental data designed for one purpose (e.g., finding Supersymmetry) and using it to constrain entirely different theoretical frameworks. This paper demonstrates that a multi-pronged approach, leveraging the complementarity of disparate search strategies, is essential for narrowing down the properties of potential new particles.

The Challenge: Connecting the Dots

New particles rarely exist in isolation. A new scalar particle (like a heavy Higgs, $h_2$) that decays into two photons typically requires other heavy, charged particles—such as Vector-Like Quarks (VLQs)—to mediate that decay via quantum loops. While these VLQs help explain a diphoton signal, they should also be produced directly at the LHC, leading to signatures like high-energy jets and missing transverse energy (MET).

The researchers investigated three specific VLQ doublet models, defined by their representations under the Standard Model gauge groups.

Table 1: Vector-like quark (VLQ) models and their SU(3)c × SU(2)L × U(1)Y representations.

Methodology

The study utilized a sophisticated software pipeline to test these models against real-world ATLAS and CMS data:

  • Theory Implementation: Models were built using FeynRules.
  • Simulation: LHC collisions were generated via MadGraph and Pythia6, with detector effects mimicked by Delphes 3.
  • Recasting: The CheckMATE tool compared simulated data against 105 signal regions from Run 1 (8 TeV) and early Run 2 (13 TeV) searches.

Key Insights: The "SUSY Surprise"

The most striking finding was that searches designed for Supersymmetry (SUSY)—specifically those looking for squarks and gluinos via high MET—were often more sensitive to VLQs than the dedicated VLQ searches.

This occurs because VLQs can decay into $Z$ or $W$ bosons, which subsequently decay into neutrinos. These neutrinos escape detection, creating the "missing energy" signature that SUSY searches are optimized to find. For instance, the SUSY search 'Gtt-1L' (targeting gluinos decaying to tops) provided tighter constraints on certain VLQ models than official VLQ-specific analyses.

Model Viability and Results

The effectiveness of a search depends heavily on which Standard Model quarks the new VLQs "mix" with.

  • 1st Generation Mixing: If VLQs mix with light quarks, the combined data sets a lower mass limit of $m_{VLQ} \gtrsim 650$ GeV.
  • 3rd Generation Mixing: Mixing with top/bottom quarks is more easily distinguished from background, leading to a stricter limit of $m_{VLQ} \gtrsim 1020$ GeV.

Furthermore, the study evaluated which models could actually produce a diphoton signal of the required strength ($R_{\gamma\gamma}$) without being excluded by other decay channels like $WW$, $ZZ$, or $Z\gamma$.

Table 2: Decay ratios and cross-sections for the three VLQ models, highlighting the diphoton signal strength ($R_{\gamma\gamma}$) and other decay channels.

As shown in Table 2, only the $(X, T)$ doublet model could realistically explain a significant diphoton excess while remaining consistent with constraints from other channels.

Conclusion

While the 750 GeV diphoton excess eventually proved to be a statistical fluctuation, the methodology presented here remains a vital blueprint for BSM physics. The authors urge a shift toward "hybrid" searches that utilize missing energy as a primary discriminator for new quarks, rather than treating VLQ and SUSY searches as isolated silos. True discovery lies in the complementarity of our search strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The elucidation of the nature of new phenomena requires a multi-pronged approach to understand the essential physics that underlies it. As an example, we study the simplified model containing a new scalar singlet accompanied by vector-like quarks. To be specific, we investigate three models with [Formula: see text]-doublet, vector-like quarks with Yukawa couplings to a new scalar singlet and which also couple off-diagonally to corresponding Standard Model fermions of the first or third generation through the usual Higgs boson. We demonstrate that three classes of searches can play important and complementary roles in constraining this model. In particular, we find that missing energy searches designed for sparticle production, are also very sensitive to vector-like quarks.
BibTeX
@article{biekotter2017complementarity,
  author = {Anke Biekötter and JoAnne L. Hewett and Jong Soo Kim and Michael Krämer and Thomas G. Rizzo and Krzysztof Rolbiecki and Jamie Tattersall and T. Weber},
  title = {{Complementarity of resonant scalar, vector-like quark and superpartner searches in elucidating new phenomena}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics A},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1142/s0217751x17500324},
}
Figure