Complementarity of indirect and accelerator dark matter searches

Gianfranco Bertone, D. G. Cerdeño, Mattia Fornasa, L. Pieri, Roberto Ruiz de Austri, Roberto TrottaPhysical 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how combining data from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) with indirect dark matter detection experiments (like Fermi-LAT and future CTA) can overcome ambiguities in identifying dark matter candidates. The study shows that indirect searches, even with null results, are crucial for pinpointing the correct dark matter properties, especially when LHC data alone leaves multiple viable solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A major challenge in dark matter (DM) research is not just detecting potential DM particles, but definitively proving they are the dominant component of the universe's dark matter. Even if the LHC discovers new particles predicted by theories like supersymmetry (SUSY), distinguishing the "correct" dark matter candidate from other possibilities can be incredibly difficult. Specifically, LHC data alone might yield multiple "solutions" for the dark matter particle's properties, leading to a degeneracy problem. This paper addresses how to break this degeneracy by combining LHC data with information from indirect detection experiments, which look for the byproducts of dark matter annihilation or decay.

Methods

The authors employ a Bayesian statistical analysis framework, using the SuperBayes code extended to a 24-dimensional parameter space of a specific Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) benchmark point. This point is chosen from the "coannihilation region," where the dark matter candidate (a neutralino) is nearly degenerate in mass with another particle (a stau), a scenario relevant for explaining the observed relic abundance of dark matter.

The core of their method involves:

  • Simulating LHC Data: They use mock high-luminosity LHC data (300 fb⁻¹) to constrain the SUSY parameters.
  • Incorporating Indirect Detection Constraints: They integrate constraints from:
  • Fermi-LAT: Null searches for gamma-rays from dwarf spheroidal galaxies (dSphs).
  • Planck: Projected constraints on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) from its reionization history.
  • CTA (Cherenkov Telescope Array): A hypothetical future detection of gamma-rays from the Draco dSph.
  • Bayesian Inference: They update prior probabilities of the SUSY parameters based on the likelihood of the experimental data, generating posterior probability distributions. This allows them to assess which parameter regions are favored or excluded.
  • Consistency Check: A key assumption is that the neutralino discovered at the LHC constitutes 100% of the non-baryonic dark matter in the universe. This "consistency check" is crucial for ruling out spurious solutions.

Datasets

  • Simulated LHC Data: Mock data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 300 fb⁻¹ at 14 TeV.
  • Fermi-LAT Data: Real data from the Fermi Large Area Telescope, specifically the combined analysis of 10 dwarf spheroidal galaxies (dSphs) searching for gamma-ray emission.
  • Planck Data: Projected constraints derived from the expected impact of Planck satellite data on the reionization history of the universe.
  • CTA Data: Hypothetical data from a future Cherenkov Telescope Array observation of the Draco dSph.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LHC Alone is Insufficient: Even with substantial LHC data, the paper demonstrates that it's difficult to uniquely identify the dark matter particle's properties and its relic abundance. Multiple "modes" or solutions can persist.
  • Indirect Detection is Crucial: Null results from indirect detection experiments (like Fermi-LAT) are surprisingly powerful. They can effectively rule out "spurious" solutions that would otherwise remain viable with LHC data alone.
  • Complementarity is Key: The study strongly emphasizes that a multi-pronged approach, combining accelerator physics (LHC) with indirect detection, is essential for a robust identification of dark matter.
  • dSphs as Powerful Probes: Dwarf spheroidal galaxies, despite their low mass, are excellent targets for indirect detection due to their high dark matter density and low astrophysical backgrounds.
  • Future Experiments Offer Significant Gains: Upcoming experiments like Planck and CTA are projected to provide even stronger constraints, further refining our understanding of dark matter properties.
  • Astrophysical Uncertainties Can Be Managed: The paper shows that even with significant astrophysical uncertainties (e.g., in DM distribution within galaxies), indirect detection constraints can still be very effective.

Key Results

  • Fermi-LAT Ruling Out Wino-like Solutions: Current Fermi-LAT limits on gamma-ray fluxes from dSphs are shown to be capable of ruling out a "Wino-like" dark matter solution that would survive LHC-only analysis. This leads to a more precise identification of the correct cosmological solution.
  • Planck's Similar Impact: Projected Planck constraints on the CMB reionization history are found to have a similar constraining power to Fermi-LAT, excluding regions of parameter space with high annihilation cross-sections and low relic densities.
  • CTA's Dramatic Improvement: A hypothetical detection of just 7 photons from the Draco dSph by CTA would drastically reduce the uncertainty in the dark matter annihilation cross-section, collapsing it from 6 orders of magnitude to about 1 order. This would allow for a much tighter constraint on the relic abundance.
  • Improved Relic Density Constraints: Combining LHC data with indirect detection constraints significantly narrows down the possible values for the neutralino relic abundance, bringing it closer to the true value.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Benchmark Model Dependence: The study focuses on a specific benchmark SUSY model in the coannihilation region. While illustrative, the generality of the findings to other models would require further investigation.
  • Simplified Likelihood Implementation: For Fermi-LAT constraints, the paper uses a simplified approach by assigning a likelihood of zero to samples exceeding the 95% upper limit. A more detailed analysis would involve incorporating the full likelihood function.
  • Astrophysical Factor Assumption: For CTA, an informative prior for the astrophysical factor of Draco is used, and the analysis assumes this factor is close to the mean of the prior.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that a more detailed analysis incorporating the full likelihood functions of indirect detection experiments would be beneficial. They also highlight the importance of a multi-pronged approach to DM identification, combining accelerator, direct, and indirect detection methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Even if supersymmetric particles are found at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), it will be difficult to prove that they constitute the bulk of the dark matter (DM) in the Universe using LHC data alone. We study the complementarity of LHC and DM indirect searches, working out explicitly the reconstruction of the DM properties for a specific benchmark model in the coannihilation region of a 24-parameters supersymmetric model. Combining mock high-luminosity LHC data with presentday null searches for gamma rays from dwarf galaxies with the Fermi Large Area Telescope, we show that current Fermi Large Area Telescope limits already have the capability of ruling out a spurious wino-like solution which would survive using LHC data only, thus leading to the correct identification of the cosmological solution. We also demonstrate that upcoming Planck constraints on the reionization history will have a similar constraining power and discuss the impact of a possible detection of gamma rays from DM annihilation in the Draco dwarf galaxy with a Cherenkov-Telescope-Array-like experiment. Our results indicate that indirect searches can be strongly complementary to the LHC in identifying the DM particles, even when astrophysical uncertainties are taken into account.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bertone2012complementarity,
  author = {Gianfranco Bertone and D. G. Cerdeño and Mattia Fornasa and L. Pieri and Roberto Ruiz de Austri and Roberto Trotta},
  title = {{Complementarity of indirect and accelerator dark matter searches}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.85.055014},
}
Figure