Competitive Intensity Modulates the Pain Empathy Response: An Event-Related Potentials Study

Pinchao Luo, Yu Pang, Beibei Li, Jing Jie, Mengdi Zhuang, Shuting Yang, Xifu ZhengFrontiers in Psychology 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Previous studies have widely reported that competition modulates an individual's ability to empathize with pain experienced by others. What remains to be clarified, however, is how modulations in the intensity of competition might affect this type of empathy. This study investigated this by setting different competitive intensity contexts (High, Medium, and Low) using an Eriksen Flanker task. Participants then performed a recognition task while event-related potentials (ERP) were recorded as they viewed images of body parts in painful and non-painful situations. Results showed that high competitive intensity (HCI) eliminated early N2 differentiation between pain and no-pain stimuli and down-regulated late LPP responses. These findings suggest that high-stakes competition inhibits the early automatic arousal and bottom-up processing of an opponent's pain.

Introduction

Psychologists have long observed that social context significantly alters our empathetic responses. We often feel less empathy for rivals or out-group members, sometimes even experiencing schadenfreude. However, most research has treated competition as a simple binary state. In reality, competition exists on a spectrum of intensity. This study explores whether the intensity of competition—defined by the probability of winning and the perceived threat to one's goals—modulates the neural temporal dynamics of pain empathy. Specifically, it examines whether high-intensity competition affects early, automatic stages of empathy or only later, controlled evaluative stages.

Methods

The researchers recruited 45 college students for a two-part experimental design involving context manipulation and an empathy assessment task.

1. Context Setting: The Flanker Task

Participants first performed an Eriksen Flanker task, believing they were competing against an opponent in another room. Competitive intensity was manipulated by assigning participants to three groups with different probabilities of winning:

  • High Competitive Intensity (HCI): 10% chance of winning (high threat).
  • Medium Competitive Intensity (MCI): 50% chance of winning.
  • Low Competitive Intensity (LCI): 90% chance of winning (low threat).
The Eriksen Flanker task used to establish competitive intensity contexts.

2. The Empathy Task

While recording EEG data, participants viewed 60 digital color images (30 painful, 30 non-painful) depicting everyday accidents involving hands or feet. They were told these images represented their opponent from the previous task.

The trial sequence for the empathy task, showing painful and non-painful stimulus examples.

3. Neural Markers

The study focused on two specific ERP components:

  • N2 (220–250 ms): An index of early, automatic, "bottom-up" emotional sharing.
  • LPP (350–600 ms): An index of later, controlled, "top-down" cognitive evaluation and regulation.

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed that competitive pressure fundamentally alters how the brain processes another person's suffering:

  • Early Blockage of Empathy: In LCI and MCI conditions, a clear N2 differentiation was observed between painful and non-painful stimuli. However, in the HCI condition, this early differentiation was completely absent. This suggests that high-intensity competition creates a "threat state" that inhibits the brain's automatic resonance with an opponent's pain.
  • Late-Stage Regulation: While all groups showed some differentiation at the LPP stage, the HCI group exhibited significantly smaller amplitudes compared to the other groups, indicating a down-regulation of conscious empathetic evaluation.
  • Recognition vs. Empathy: Behavioral data showed that all participants could correctly identify painful stimuli. This confirms that the observed neural effects relate specifically to the feeling of empathy, not a failure to recognize the situation.

Conclusion

These results provide neuroscientific evidence that high competitive intensity leads to a deficit in early automatic arousal in response to an opponent's pain. By inhibiting bottom-up processing, extreme competition may prioritize self-preservation and goal achievement over social resonance, effectively "blinding" the brain to the suffering of a high-threat rival.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous studies have widely reported that competition modulates an individual's ability to empathize with pain experienced by others. What remains to be clarified, however, is how modulations in the intensity of competition might affect this type of empathy. To investigate this, we first used a Eriksen Flanker task to set different competitive intensity context (high competitive intensity, HCI; medium competitive intensity, MCI; low competitive intensity, LCI). Then we used a recognition task as a competitive task, in which we recorded event-related potentials (ERP) while participants viewed static images of body parts in painful and non-painful situations. Participants were informed that both sets of images depicted an opponent that they were required to play against in the recognition task that varied in levels of competitive intensity according to condition (HCI, MCI, and LCI). We observed an early N2 differentiation between pain and no-pain stimuli over the frontal area under MCI and LCI conditions, but this was not detected under HCI condition. Moreover, we observed a pattern of pain and no-pain differentiation for the late LPP over the frontal and centro-parietal regions under HCI, MCI, and LCI condition. As the pain empathy response is indexed by pain and no-pain differentiation, these results indicate a down-regulation of pain empathy response attributable to a high level of competition. With its very early onset, this effect appears to inhibit bottom-up processing of the ability to perceive pain experienced by an opponent. Our results provide neuroscientific evidence for a deficit in early automatic arousal in response to the pain of the opponent under the influence of high competitive intensity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2018competitive,
  author = {Pinchao Luo and Yu Pang and Beibei Li and Jing Jie and Mengdi Zhuang and Shuting Yang and Xifu Zheng},
  title = {{Competitive Intensity Modulates the Pain Empathy Response: An Event-Related Potentials Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01854},
}
Figure