Competition between protein aggregation and protein complex formation

Sebastian Pechmann, Emmanuel D. Levy, Gian Gaetano Tartaglia, Michele VendruscoloBMC 2008 · DOI

Abstract

Interactions between proteins are fundamental to cellular life, driven by physico-chemical complementarity. However, this same "stickiness" poses a significant risk: the potential for aberrant, uncontrolled protein aggregation. This study explores the evolutionary pressure to promote functional complex formation while simultaneously preventing pathological clumping, revealing that protein interfaces are inherent aggregation hotspots managed by "negative design" principles.

Introduction

In the densely packed environment of a living cell, molecular recognition is a high-stakes game. Proteins must navigate a sea of potential partners to find specific targets. The forces driving these functional interactions—hydrophobicity and structural fit—are remarkably similar to the forces that lead to the formation of toxic aggregates associated with neurodegenerative diseases. This research addresses a fundamental biological conflict: how proteins evolve surfaces that are functional enough to bind partners but stable enough to avoid clumping together with everything else.

Methodology

To investigate this, researchers utilized the Zyggregator algorithm, a computational tool that calculates aggregation propensity by integrating hydrophobicity, electrical charge, and specific structural patterns. Unlike simple hydrophobicity scales, Zyggregator identifies regions likely to form the cross-β structures characteristic of aggregates.

Computational mapping of aggregation propensity onto a 3D protein structure.

These 1D propensity profiles were then mapped onto 3D structures from the "3D complex" database. This allowed for a direct comparative analysis between interface patches (where proteins touch) and the general protein surface across a wide variety of structural classes.

Results: Interfaces as Aggregation Hotspots

The primary discovery is that protein interfaces are significantly more prone to aggregation than the rest of the protein surface. In fact, aggregation propensity proved to be a more effective predictor of interface locations than simple hydrophobicity. This suggests that the "stickiness" required for biological function is intrinsically linked to the risk of aggregation; the regions proteins use to communicate are their most vulnerable points.

Interface region 'A' highlighted as a high-propensity aggregation hotspot.

The Role of Negative Design

To mitigate this inherent risk, evolution utilizes "negative design." While "positive design" ensures a protein fits its partner like a key in a lock, negative design acts as a set of "bumpers" that prevent the key from sticking to the wrong door. The authors identified disulfide bonds and salt bridges as key structural safeguards. These elements stabilize the functional complex in a way that specifically penalizes or prevents the transition into an uncontrolled aggregate. For instance, in the 'mainly-β' homodimer (PDB: 1XSO), a disulfide bond specifically stabilizes an otherwise dangerous aggregation-prone interface.

Conclusion

The study highlights a delicate evolutionary balance. Proteins that must remain monomeric, such as human myoglobin (PDB: 2MM1), evolve highly aggregation-resistant surfaces. In contrast, proteins that form complexes must manage "hot" interfaces through sophisticated structural safeguards. Understanding these negative design principles offers new avenues for protein engineering and therapeutic strategies for diseases where these safeguards fail, leading to protein misfolding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background Interactions between proteins are vital for essentially every process in a living cell. Physico-chemical complementarity, which can be considered as the driving force for molecular recognition, has been found to not consistently explain protein-ligand interactions. As aberrant interactions should be avoided in order to maintain cell viability, promoting complex formation and preventing protein aggregation are two opposite requirements on the physico-chemical properties of protein surfaces.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pechmann2008competition,
  author = {Sebastian Pechmann and Emmanuel D. Levy and Gian Gaetano Tartaglia and Michele Vendruscolo},
  title = {{Competition between protein aggregation and protein complex formation}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1186/1471-2105-9-s10-o2},
}
Figure