Compensation of a Second Harmonic Wave Included in an Incident Ultrasonic Wave for the Precise Measurement of the Acoustic Nonlinearity Parameter

Dong-Gi Song, Sungho Choi, Taehyeon Kim, Kyung Young Jhang2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles a common issue in ultrasonic testing: the presence of a "phantom" second harmonic wave in the initial signal, which skews measurements of a material's true acoustic nonlinearity. The researchers propose and validate a novel compensation method that accurately removes this unwanted component, leading to more reliable and stable measurements of the acoustic nonlinearity parameter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Measuring the acoustic nonlinearity parameter ($\beta$) is a powerful non-destructive technique for assessing material degradation. However, a significant challenge arises from the "incident second harmonic wave" – a spurious second harmonic component that is present in the initial ultrasonic signal itself, rather than being generated by the material's nonlinearity. This phantom signal can originate from the transducer, the contact interface, or other signal-generating equipment. Its presence leads to inaccurate and unstable $\beta$ measurements, especially when using high-power ultrasonic signals. Existing methods struggle to isolate the true material-generated second harmonic from this incident component, particularly when aiming for absolute measurements using the calibration method.

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel compensation method designed to remove the influence of the incident second harmonic wave. The approach is based on developing a numerical model that describes the received second harmonic signal as a combination of two components: one generated by the material's nonlinearity and another from the incident second harmonic.

  1. Numerical Modeling: A semi-analytical approach, the distributed point source method, is used to model the ultrasonic wave field. This model accounts for the propagation of both the fundamental wave and the incident second harmonic wave. The material-generated second harmonic is calculated using the Ingenito and Williams model, where the source strength is proportional to the square of the local fundamental amplitude.
  2. Parameter Estimation: The model incorporates unknown parameters: the material's acoustic nonlinearity parameter ($\beta$) and the magnitude of the incident second harmonic. By comparing the model's predictions to experimental measurements of the second harmonic amplitude as a function of propagation distance, these unknown parameters are determined. This is achieved by finding the best fit between the theoretical curves and the experimental data, often using a least-squares method.
  3. Compensation: Once the incident second harmonic component is quantified, its contribution is subtracted from the experimentally measured total second harmonic signal. This leaves only the second harmonic generated by the material's nonlinearity, allowing for a precise calculation of $\beta$. The method also considers cases where the phase of the incident second harmonic is opposite to that of the material-generated second harmonic.

Datasets

The study utilizes experimental data collected from two types of specimens:

  • Fused Silica: Specimens of varying thicknesses were used to vary the propagation distance.
  • Aluminum Alloy Al6061-T6: Similar to fused silica, specimens of different thicknesses were prepared.

These materials were chosen because they exhibit opposite phase relationships for their material-generated second harmonic waves, allowing for a comprehensive validation of the compensation method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Phantom" Harmonic is a Real Problem: The paper clearly demonstrates that the incident second harmonic can significantly skew $\beta$ measurements, leading to apparent variations with propagation distance that are not representative of the material's true properties.
  • Phase Matters: The method accounts for the crucial detail that the incident second harmonic can either be in-phase or out-of-phase with the material-generated second harmonic, which drastically affects the observed total amplitude.
  • Model-Experiment Synergy: The success hinges on the tight integration of a sophisticated numerical model with experimental data. By fitting the model to observed trends across varying propagation distances, the unknown incident component can be reliably disentangled.
  • Stable Measurements Achieved: The compensation method leads to significantly more stable and consistent measurements of $\beta$ across different propagation distances, a key indicator of its effectiveness.

Key Results

  • The proposed compensation method successfully removed the influence of the incident second harmonic wave.
  • Measurements of the acoustic nonlinearity parameter ($\beta$) became significantly more stable and less dependent on propagation distance after compensation.
  • For fused silica, the average $\beta$ value obtained was 11.04, which falls within the literature range (10.1 to 12.4).
  • For Al6061-T6, the average $\beta$ value was 6.59, which is close to the literature range (4.5 to 6.12).
  • The method was validated on materials with both in-phase and out-of-phase second harmonic generation characteristics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Attenuation: The current numerical model does not explicitly account for attenuation effects. The authors note that for materials with significant attenuation (e.g., steel), this factor would need to be incorporated into the theoretical model for accurate results.
  • Scope of Materials: While validated on fused silica and Al6061-T6, future work could involve extending the theoretical model and experimental validation to a wider range of materials, particularly those with higher attenuation.
  • New Theoretical Model: The authors suggest developing a new theoretical model that explicitly includes attenuation effects to broaden the applicability of their compensation technique.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{song2021compensation,
  author = {Dong-Gi Song and Sungho Choi and Taehyeon Kim and Kyung Young Jhang},
  title = {{Compensation of a Second Harmonic Wave Included in an Incident Ultrasonic Wave for the Precise Measurement of the Acoustic Nonlinearity Parameter}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21093203},
}
Figure