Comparisons of the Emissions of Ethanol/Diesel and n-Pentanol/Diesel Fuel Blends: Engine Test and Kinetic Modeling Study

Xiaohui Yang, Xin Huang, Wei Zhang, Wei Peng, Shaoping XuIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Abstract

A comparative study of the effects of ethanol/diesel (DE) and n-pentanol/diesel (DP) blends on the engine performance and emission in a direct-injection diesel engine was carried out. The results show that brake specific fuel consumption increases with increasing alcohol fraction for both DE and DP fuel blends. Nevertheless, DE and DP fuel additions show no significant influence on brake thermal efficiency. Besides, ethanol and/or n-pentanol slightly increase the brake specific gaseous pollutant emissions such as the brake specific total unburned hydrocarbon (BSHC), carbon monoxide (BSCO), and nitrogen oxides (BSNOx), while dramatically reduce particulate emissions. The DE and DP blends show approximately the same level of BSCO and BSHC emissions, while DP blends result in slightly higher BSNOx and particulate emissions. A detailed kinetic model was proposed to calculate the soot formation precursors such as benzene and pyrene. The modeling results show that the length of carbon chain has only slight effect on soot reduction under relatively low oxygen mass content, while ethanol/diesel blend exhibits lower soot formation under high oxygen concentration.

Introduction

Diesel engines are the primary power sources for heavy-duty transportation and industrial machinery due to their high thermal efficiency and durability. However, they face a significant environmental challenge: the "NOx-PM trade-off," where strategies to reduce nitrogen oxides (NOx) often lead to an increase in particulate matter (PM) or soot.

Bio-alcohols, such as ethanol and n-pentanol, have emerged as promising renewable additives to break this trade-off. While ethanol is widely available, it suffers from poor miscibility with diesel and low energy density. Higher-chain alcohols like n-pentanol offer better miscibility and higher energy density, potentially serving as a superior "drop-in" fuel. This study investigates whether the longer carbon chain of n-pentanol provides a tangible advantage over ethanol when controlled for identical oxygen content.

Experimental Methodology

The research utilized a four-cylinder, direct-injection diesel engine (ISUZU 4HF1) operated at a constant speed of 1800 rpm across various loads. To ensure a rigorous comparison, the researchers developed Ethanol/Diesel (DE) and n-Pentanol/Diesel (DP) blends with matched oxygen mass concentrations of 1.8%, 3.6%, and 5.4%.

Schematic of the experimental engine test rig including fuel supply, combustion analysis, and emission measurement systems.

The experimental setup, as shown in the schematic above, allowed for the simultaneous measurement of engine performance parameters and detailed emission profiles, including gaseous pollutants and particulate mass.

Kinetic Modeling and Validation

To understand the chemical pathways of soot formation, a detailed kinetic model was developed using the SENKIN code. The model combined an n-heptane base (as a diesel surrogate) with specific sub-mechanisms for n-pentanol oxidation and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). This allowed the team to track soot precursors like benzene (A1) and pyrene (A4).

Validation of the kinetic model comparing calculated ignition delay times for n-heptane and ethanol using the LLNL NH V3.1 and tailored mechanisms.

The model was validated against experimental ignition delay data for both n-heptane and ethanol across different pressures (10 bar and 50 bar). As illustrated in the validation plots, the tailored mechanism closely aligns with established LLNL models, providing a reliable foundation for predicting soot precursor behavior.

Key Results and Discussion

Engine Performance

Both alcohol blends introduced a "consumption tax." Due to the lower heating values of ethanol and n-pentanol compared to neat diesel, the Brake Specific Fuel Consumption (BSFC) increased for all blends. However, the Brake Thermal Efficiency (BTE) remained largely unaffected, indicating that the conversion of fuel energy into mechanical work is not compromised by these additives.

Gaseous and Particulate Emissions

  • Particulates: Both alcohols were highly effective at reducing soot. DP blends reduced particulate mass by 15–40%, while DE blends achieved a more significant reduction of 36–57%.
  • Gaseous Pollutants: There was a slight increase in NOx, CO, and unburned hydrocarbons (HC). This is attributed to the high latent heat of evaporation of alcohols, which can lead to lower combustion temperatures and localized quenching.

The Impact of Carbon Chain Length

The kinetic modeling revealed that at low oxygen concentrations, the alcohol's carbon chain length has a negligible effect on soot precursors. However, at higher oxygen concentrations (5.4%), ethanol—the shorter-chain alcohol—was more effective at suppressing benzene and pyrene formation. This suggests that ethanol's higher volatility and specific chemical structure provide a slight edge in soot reduction over the heavier n-pentanol.

Conclusion

While n-pentanol offers superior miscibility and energy density, making it an attractive "drop-in" fuel, ethanol remains more effective at reducing particulate emissions at high oxygen concentrations. The study highlights that the primary driver for soot reduction is the oxygen content of the fuel, though physical properties like volatility also play a critical role in real-world engine performance. Future work should focus on transient engine conditions and the physical spray dynamics to further optimize these renewable fuel blends.

Summary updated

Abstract

A comparative study of the effects of ethanol/diesel (DE) and n-pentanol/diesel (DP) blends on the engine performance and emission in a direct-injection diesel engine was carried out. The results show that brake specific fuel consumption increases with increasing alcohol fraction for both DE and DP fuel blends. Nevertheless, DE and DP fuel additions show no significant influence on brake thermal efficiency. Besides, ethanol and/or n-pentanol slightly increase the brake specific gaseous pollutant emissions such as the brake specific total unburned hydrocarbon (BSHC), carbon monoxide (BSCO), and nitrogen oxides (BSNOx), while dramatically reduce particulate emissions. The DE and DP blends show approximately the same level of BSCO and BSHC emissions, while DP blends result in slightly higher BSNOx and particulate emissions. A detailed kinetic model was proposed to calculate the soot formation precursors such as benzene and pyrene. The modeling results show that the length of carbon chain has only slight effect on soot reduction under relatively low oxygen mass content, while ethanol/diesel blend exhibits lower soot formation under high oxygen concentration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2019comparisons,
  author = {Xiaohui Yang and Xin Huang and Wei Zhang and Wei Peng and Shaoping Xu},
  title = {{Comparisons of the Emissions of Ethanol/Diesel and n-Pentanol/Diesel Fuel Blends: Engine Test and Kinetic Modeling Study}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2928315},
}

Loading related content...

Figure