Comparisons of objective and subjective refraction with and without cycloplegia using binocular wavefront optometer with autorefraction and retinoscopy in school-age children

Yadi Lei, Xun Chen, Mingrui Cheng, Boliang Li, Yinjie Jiang, Yilin Xu, Xiaoying WangGraefe 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces and evaluates a novel binocular wavefront optometer (BWFOM) for measuring refractive errors in children. The BWFOM offers a faster, more convenient, and potentially more accurate method for both objective and subjective refraction compared to traditional techniques like autorefraction and retinoscopy, especially when cycloplegia is used.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate refractive error assessment in children is crucial for early detection and intervention of vision impairments like myopia, which is a growing global health concern. However, children's developing accommodation can significantly affect the accuracy of standard refraction methods, making cycloplegic refraction (which temporarily paralyzes the ciliary muscle) the gold standard for research and often for clinical practice. Traditional cycloplegic methods, such as retinoscopy, require trained professionals, dark rooms, and can be time-consuming and challenging for young patients. While autorefractors are faster, their accuracy can be limited for precise prescription. This paper addresses the need for a more efficient, accurate, and child-friendly method for refractive error assessment in pediatric populations.

Methods

The study employed a cross-sectional design involving 86 children aged 6-15 years. The core of the methodology was the comparison of a new device, the Binocular Wavefront Optometer (BWFOM), with established methods.

Here's a breakdown of the key techniques:

  • BWFOM: This device utilizes wavefront aberration and adaptive optics technology, measured by a Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor. It can perform both objective (automatically measured) and subjective (patient-guided) refractions. A key feature is its ability to provide prescriptions in 0.05-D intervals, a finer resolution than the traditional 0.25-D. The BWFOM can operate in a bright room and uses cloud storage for data.
  • Cycloplegia: To account for accommodative influence, cycloplegia was induced using 0.5% tropicamide phenylephrine eye drops.
  • Comparison Methods:
    • Autorefraction: A Nidek ARK-1 autorefractor was used for objective cycloplegic refraction.
  • Retinoscopy: Traditional manual retinoscopy was performed for subjective cycloplegic refraction.
  • Data Analysis: Paired t-tests were used to compare measurements, and Bland-Altman plots were employed to assess agreement between different methods and conditions (cycloplegic vs. non-cycloplegic).

Datasets

The study used data collected from 86 school-aged children (6-15 years old) who underwent various refractive examinations. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing clinical data was used for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Finer Resolution Matters: The BWFOM's 0.05-D interval for refraction appears to offer greater precision, potentially leading to more accurate prescriptions and better patient adaptation to subtle optical changes.
  • Cycloplegia Still Key for Accuracy: While BWFOM shows good agreement with other methods, the study reinforces that cycloplegic refraction provides more accurate results, especially for objective and spherical equivalence measurements, compared to non-cycloplegic assessments.
  • BWFOM's Convenience Advantage: The device significantly reduces examination time and is more cooperative for children, making it a more practical option for pediatric eye care.
  • Wavefront and Adaptive Optics in Practice: The study demonstrates the successful application of wavefront aberration and adaptive optics technologies in a clinical optometric device for both objective and subjective refraction.

Key Results

  • Accuracy Comparison (Cycloplegic):
    • BWFOM objective refraction showed significantly more negative sphere, spherical equivalence, and J45 compared to autorefraction.
  • BWFOM subjective refraction showed a less myopic sphere and more negative cylinder and J45 compared to retinoscopy.
  • Despite statistical differences, Bland-Altman plots indicated good agreement between BWFOM and autorefraction/retinoscopy for spherical equivalence.
  • Non-cycloplegia vs. Cycloplegia: For both objective and subjective refraction using BWFOM, non-cycloplegic measurements were significantly more myopic than cycloplegic ones, particularly for sphere and spherical equivalence.
  • Time Efficiency: The BWFOM examination time was significantly shorter (264.88±90.67 s) than the combined time for autorefraction and retinoscopy (315.89±95.31 s).
  • Agreement: Bland-Altman plots showed good agreement between BWFOM and other methods, with most points falling within the 95% confidence intervals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Age Segmentation: The authors acknowledge the relatively small sample size and the absence of age-segmented comparisons as limitations. They plan to conduct future studies to address these.
  • Clinical Significance of Differences: While some statistical differences were noted between BWFOM and traditional methods, the authors suggest these might not be clinically significant, especially given the finer 0.05-D interval of the BWFOM. Further investigation into the clinical impact of these subtle differences is warranted.
  • Future Development: The paper highlights the potential for BWFOM in pediatric refraction and suggests that its 0.05-D interval and accuracy make it a promising tool for future development in this area.

Summary updated

Abstract

BWFOM is a new device that realizes both objective and subjective refraction. For children's refractive errors, it is more convenient and quicker to obtain the proper prescription at a 0.05-D interval, and it is more accurate than autorefraction and retinoscopy under cycloplegia.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lei2022comparisons,
  author = {Yadi Lei and Xun Chen and Mingrui Cheng and Boliang Li and Yinjie Jiang and Yilin Xu and Xiaoying Wang},
  title = {{Comparisons of objective and subjective refraction with and without cycloplegia using binocular wavefront optometer with autorefraction and retinoscopy in school-age children}},
  booktitle = {Graefe},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s00417-022-05936-8},
}
Figure