Comparisons of annual modulations in MINOS with the event rate modulation in CoGeNT

P. Adamson, I. M. Anghel, G. Barr, M. Bishai, A. Blake, G. J. Bock, D. Bogert, S. Cao, S. Childress, J. A. B. Coelho, L. A. Corwin, D. Cronin-Hennessy, J. M. G. H. J. de Jong, A. V. Devan, N. E. Devenish, M. Diwan, C. O. Escobar, J. J. Evans, E. Falk, G. J. Feldman, M. V. Frohne, H. Gallagher, R. A. Gomes, M. C. Goodman, P. Gouffon, N. Graf, R. Gran, K. Grzelak, A. Habig, J. Hartnell, R. Hatcher, A. Himmel, A. Holin, J. Hylen, G. M. Irwin, Z. Isvan, D. E. Jaffe, C. James, D. Jensen, T. Kafka, S. M. S. Kasahara, G. Koizumi, S. Köpp, M. Kordosky, A. Kreymer, K. Lang, J. Ling, P. J. Litchfield, P. Lucas, W. A. Mann, M. L. Marshak, M. Mathis, N. Mayer, A. M. McGowan, M. M. Medeiros, R. Mehdiyev, J. R. Meier, M. D. Messier, William H. Miller, S. Mishra, S. Moed Sher, C. D. Moore, L. Mualem, J. Musser, D. Naples, J. K. Nelson, H. B. Newman, R. J. Nichol, J. Nowak, J. Michael O’Connor, W. P. Oliver, M. Orchanian, R. B. Pahlka, J. Paley, R. B. Patterson, G. Pawloski, S. Phan-Budd, R. Plunkett, Xin Qiu, A. Radovic, B. Rebel, C. Rosenfeld, H. A. Rubin, M. C. Sánchez, J. Schneps, A. Schreckenberger, P. Schreiner, R. Sharma, A. Sousa, N. Tagg, R. L. Talaga, J. Thomas, M. Thomson, R. Toner, D. Torretta, G. Tzanakos, J. Urheim, P. Vahle, B. Viren, A. WeberPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The CoGeNT Collaboration has recently published results from a fifteen month data set which indicate an annual modulation in the event rate similar to what is expected from weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) interactions. It has been suggested that the CoGeNT modulation may actually be caused by other annually modulating phenomena, specifically the flux of atmospheric muons underground or the radon level in the laboratory. We have compared the phase of the CoGeNT data modulation to that of the concurrent atmospheric muon and radon data collected by the MINOS experiment which occupies an adjacent experimental hall in the Soudan Underground Laboratory. The results presented are obtained by performing a shape-free $\chi^2$ data-to-data comparison and from a simultaneous fit of the MINOS and CoGeNT data to phase-shifted sinusoidal functions. Both tests indicate that the phase of the CoGeNT modulation is inconsistent with the phases of the MINOS muon and radon modulations at the $3.0\sigma$ level.

Introduction: The CoGeNT Controversy

In the search for Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs), a primary signature is an "annual modulation" in the detection rate. This variation arises as the Earth orbits the Sun while the solar system moves through the galactic dark matter halo, with a predicted peak around June 2nd. The CoGeNT experiment, located in the Soudan Underground Laboratory, reported a modulation consistent with this expectation. However, skepticism arose regarding whether seasonal environmental factors—specifically atmospheric muon flux and radon levels—could be mimicking a dark matter signal.

Experimental Setup and Data

The MINOS experiment is situated in a cavern adjacent to CoGeNT within the Soudan mine, sharing the same overburden and ventilation system. This proximity makes MINOS an ideal "control" for monitoring the local environment. For this study, researchers analyzed data collected concurrently between December 4, 2009, and March 6, 2011.

The datasets included:

  • CoGeNT Event Rate: 15 months of data from a 0.44 kg germanium detector.
  • MINOS Muon Flux: Downward-going muon tracks recorded by the MINOS Far Detector.
  • MINOS Radon Levels: Daily averages from high-precision monitors.
Residuals of the CoGeNT event rate, MINOS muon flux, and MINOS radon levels over the 15-month study period.

Analysis Methods

Three statistical approaches were used to test the relationship between the datasets:

  1. Sinusoidal Fitting: Fitting the data to a standard cosine function to determine the modulation phase ($t_0$) and period ($T$).
  2. Shape-Free $\chi^2$ Test: A data-to-data comparison that does not assume a specific functional form, accounting for non-sinusoidal "weather" events like sudden stratospheric warming.
  3. Correlation Analysis: Calculating Pearson’s correlation coefficients to check if day-to-day residuals in CoGeNT tracked with MINOS backgrounds.

Results: Phase and Period Inconsistency

The primary finding is a significant "phase mismatch." While the CoGeNT signal peaks in late April or early May, the atmospheric muon flux peaks in early July, and radon levels peak in early August. Quantitatively, the CoGeNT signal leads the muon flux by approximately 75 days and the radon levels by 110 days.

Confidence intervals (68% and 90% C.L.) for the modulation period and phase of CoGeNT, MINOS muon, and MINOS radon data.

Statistical tests show that the CoGeNT phase is inconsistent with the muon modulation at $3.0\sigma$ and the radon modulation at $3.1\sigma$. Furthermore, the amplitude of the CoGeNT modulation (16.6%) is nearly an order of magnitude larger than the muon modulation (~2%), making it physically unlikely for muons to be the source even if detection efficiency were high. Correlation coefficients were near zero (0.19 for muons, -0.29 for radon), confirming no meaningful day-to-day relationship between the datasets.

Conclusion

By leveraging the proximity of the MINOS and CoGeNT experiments, this study effectively rules out atmospheric muons and radon as the primary drivers of the reported CoGeNT modulation. While this does not confirm a dark matter origin—as the signal remains in tension with other experiments—it clarifies that these common seasonal backgrounds are not the culprits. Future investigations will focus on other potential sources, such as rock-induced neutrons, and longer-term data acquisition to see if the modulation phase remains stable over multiple years.

Summary updated

Abstract

The CoGeNT Collaboration has recently published results from a fifteen month data set which indicate an annual modulation in the event rate similar to what is expected from weakly interacting massive particle interactions. It has been suggested that the CoGeNT modulation may actually be caused by other annually modulating phenomena, specifically the flux of atmospheric muons underground or the radon level in the laboratory. We have compared the phase of the CoGeNT data modulation to that of the concurrent atmospheric muon and radon data collected by the MINOS experiment which occupies an adjacent experimental hall in the Soudan Underground Laboratory. The results presented are obtained by performing a shape-free ${\ensuremath{\chi}}^{2}$ data-to-data comparison and from a simultaneous fit of the MINOS and CoGeNT data to phase-shifted sinusoidal functions. Both tests indicate that the phase of the CoGeNT modulation is inconsistent with the phases of the MINOS muon and radon modulations at the $3.0\ensuremath{\sigma}$ level.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adamson2013comparisons,
  author = {P. Adamson and I. M. Anghel and G. Barr and M. Bishai and A. Blake and G. J. Bock and D. Bogert and S. Cao and S. Childress and J. A. B. Coelho and L. A. Corwin and D. Cronin-Hennessy and J. M. G. H. J. de Jong and A. V. Devan and N. E. Devenish and M. Diwan and C. O. Escobar and J. J. Evans and E. Falk and G. J. Feldman and M. V. Frohne and H. Gallagher and R. A. Gomes and M. C. Goodman and P. Gouffon and N. Graf and R. Gran and K. Grzelak and A. Habig and J. Hartnell and R. Hatcher and A. Himmel and A. Holin and J. Hylen and G. M. Irwin and Z. Isvan and D. E. Jaffe and C. James and D. Jensen and T. Kafka and S. M. S. Kasahara and G. Koizumi and S. Köpp and M. Kordosky and A. Kreymer and K. Lang and J. Ling and P. J. Litchfield and P. Lucas and W. A. Mann and M. L. Marshak and M. Mathis and N. Mayer and A. M. McGowan and M. M. Medeiros and R. Mehdiyev and J. R. Meier and M. D. Messier and William H. Miller and S. Mishra and S. Moed Sher and C. D. Moore and L. Mualem and J. Musser and D. Naples and J. K. Nelson and H. B. Newman and R. J. Nichol and J. Nowak and J. Michael O’Connor and W. P. Oliver and M. Orchanian and R. B. Pahlka and J. Paley and R. B. Patterson and G. Pawloski and S. Phan-Budd and R. Plunkett and Xin Qiu and A. Radovic and B. Rebel and C. Rosenfeld and H. A. Rubin and M. C. Sánchez and J. Schneps and A. Schreckenberger and P. Schreiner and R. Sharma and A. Sousa and N. Tagg and R. L. Talaga and J. Thomas and M. Thomson and R. Toner and D. Torretta and G. Tzanakos and J. Urheim and P. Vahle and B. Viren and A. Weber},
  title = {{Comparisons of annual modulations in MINOS with the event rate modulation in CoGeNT}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.87.032005},
}
Figure