TL;DR
This retrospective study compares two popular minimally invasive spinal surgeries—Unilateral Biportal Endoscopy (UBE) and Percutaneous Endoscopic Lumbar Discectomy (PELD)—for treating single-level lumbar disc herniation. While both techniques yield nearly identical long-term clinical improvements, PELD is faster and less invasive, whereas UBE significantly reduces radiation exposure for the surgical team and offers a more flexible field of view.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Lumbar disc herniation (LDH) is a leading cause of lower back and leg pain, often requiring surgery when conservative treatments fail. While traditional "open" surgery is effective, it involves significant tissue trauma and long recovery times.
Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) has become the gold standard, with PELD and UBE being the two primary contenders. However, there is a lack of direct comparison regarding their perioperative metrics (like blood loss and surgery time) and long-term outcomes. Surgeons need to know which technique offers the best balance of patient safety, recovery speed, and ease of execution.
Methods
The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 51 patients treated between 2021 and 2023 at Zhaoqing First People's Hospital.
- UBE Group (23 patients): Uses two separate ports—one for the endoscope (viewing) and one for surgical instruments. This is similar to knee or shoulder arthroscopy.
- PELD Group (28 patients): Uses a single, narrow channel for both viewing and operating. It can often be performed under local anesthesia.
The team compared intraoperative data (surgery duration, blood loss, radiation use) and clinical outcomes using standardized metrics: the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain, the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) for function, and the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) score for neurological status.
Datasets
The study utilized a clinical dataset of 51 patients from the Spinal Surgery Department of Zhaoqing First People's Hospital.
- Inclusion criteria: Single-level LDH confirmed by MRI/CT, aged 30-70, and failure of conservative treatment.
- Follow-up: Patients were monitored for at least 12 months post-surgery.
- No external benchmarks or public datasets were used; this was an original clinical cohort study.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Radiation Trade-off: One of the most striking findings was that UBE required significantly fewer fluoroscopy (X-ray) instances than PELD. Because UBE uses an interlaminar approach that is easier to position, surgeons are exposed to less ionizing radiation.
- Invasiveness vs. Visibility: PELD is technically "more" minimally invasive, featuring smaller incisions and less blood loss. However, UBE provides a much wider field of view and greater instrument flexibility because the camera and tools aren't fighting for space in the same tube.
- Anesthesia Flexibility: PELD can be performed under local anesthesia, allowing surgeons to communicate with the patient during the procedure to avoid nerve damage. UBE typically requires general anesthesia to manage the discomfort of the nerve root retractor.
- Clinical Parity: Despite the technical differences in how the surgeries are performed, the "end product"—patient recovery and pain relief—was statistically the same for both groups after one year.
Key Results
- Surgical Efficiency: PELD was faster, with an average procedure time of 121.25 minutes compared to 165.00 minutes for UBE.
- Trauma: PELD resulted in less blood loss (8.89 ml vs. 16.96 ml) and shorter incisions (~10 mm vs. ~22 mm).
- Radiation Safety: UBE required significantly fewer fluoroscopy checks (6.52 instances) compared to PELD (10.43 instances).
- Patient Outcomes: At the one-year mark, both groups showed massive improvements. The "Excellent and Good" rate (Macnab criteria) was 91.3% for UBE and 89.3% for PELD, a statistically insignificant difference.
- Complications: Rare in both; UBE saw two cases of dural sac injury (tears in the spinal cord's outer membrane), while PELD saw one case of nerve root traction injury.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Sample Size: With only 51 patients, the study may lack the statistical power to detect rare complications.
- Learning Curve: PELD had been established at the hospital longer than UBE. The longer surgery times for UBE might reflect the surgeons' earlier stage on the learning curve rather than an inherent flaw in the technique.
- Short Follow-up: A one-year follow-up cannot account for long-term recurrence rates or spinal stability issues that might emerge years later.
Future research should involve multi-center trials with larger cohorts and longer follow-up periods to definitively establish which technique is superior for specific patient profiles.
Summary updated