Comparison of three‐dimensional accuracy between digital models obtained from impression scan and model scan

Ji-Hye Jung, Kyung‐Eun Lee, Danbi KimClinical 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Background Recently, the use of CAD CAM system to obtain precise digital model is increasing in the field of dentistry. Using this system, the process of obtaining accurate digital model is essential for producing prostheses. The methods of obtaining digital images of teeth include stone model scan, impression scan and intra-oral scan. As technologies continue to evolve, it is necessary to be updated with more clinically practical methods. Aim/Hypothesis The purpose of the study is to compare and analyze the accuracy of digital images obtained from impression and stone model with model scanner and to find out clinical effectiveness. Material and Methods A mandibular left first molar resin tooth was made for abutment with CAD CAM. Digital models were obtained with a same model scanner (Ceramill Map 400, Amann Girrbach, Austria), (1) Fabricated resin model was scanned (Group C). (2) 10 impressions were taken with putty and polyvinyl siloxane, then were scanned (Group I). (3) Type IV stone was poured in each impressions made in step (2) and 10 stone models were scanned (Group S). 3 dimensional super-impositional program (Geomagic control X, 3D Systems, USA) was used to analyze the STL files. Statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS program (SPSS Inc., IBM, Chicago, USA). The data were statistically analyzed with T-test. Results Stone model scan (Group S) showed lower deviation than impression scan (Group I) compared to the control group (P < 0.001). Both Group I and Group S showed signs of expansion in the occlusion surface and margin surface while showing contraction in the axial surface. The deviations were smaller in order of occlusal plane, horizontal plane of margin and axial plane. Within the limited boundary of this study, the digital model obtained from stone model scan showed smaller deviation than the digital model obtained from impression scan. Conclusions and Clinical Implications In the limitation of this study, using the model scanner, the digital model obtained from stone model scan is more accurate than the digital model obtained from impression scan.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jung2018comparison,
  author = {Ji-Hye Jung and Kyung‐Eun Lee and Danbi Kim},
  title = {{Comparison of three‐dimensional accuracy between digital models obtained from impression scan and model scan}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1111/clr.42\_13358},
}

Loading related content...

Figure