Comparison of Three Different Types of Two-Implant-Supported Magnetic Attachments on the Stress Distribution in Edentulous Mandible

Fengling Hu, Yiming Gong, Zhen Bian, Xiaoying Zhang, Bin Xu, Jianguo Zhang, Xiaojun Shi, Youcheng Yu, Liang SongComput. Math. Methods Medicine 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses 3D finite element analysis to compare how three different types of magnetic attachments (flat, dome, and cushion) affect stress distribution in two-implant-supported overdentures for edentulous mandibles. The findings suggest that dome and cushion-type attachments are better choices than the flat-type, particularly under oblique loading, to reduce stress on the peri-implant bone and mucosa.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Complete tooth loss in the mandible often leads to significant bone resorption, making it challenging to achieve stable and functional dentures. Overdentures, particularly those supported by dental implants, offer a promising solution. Magnetic attachments have been favored for their ease of use and consistent retentive force. However, there are different types of magnetic attachments available, and their biomechanical performance under various loading conditions, especially in the context of two-implant support, is not fully understood. This paper aims to address this gap by comparing the stress distribution in the peri-implant bone, implants, and mucosa when using three distinct magnetic attachment designs (flat, dome, and cushion) under simulated chewing forces.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-dimensional finite element analysis (FEA) to model the edentulous mandible, overdenture, implants, and magnetic attachments.

  • Model Creation: A 3D model of a mandible and a resin denture was created from CT scan data of a volunteer. Implants (4.3 mm diameter, 10.0 mm length) were positioned bilaterally in the canine region. Three types of magnetic attachments (flat, dome, and cushion) were modeled based on manufacturer specifications.
  • Material Properties: Standard material properties for bone (cortical and trabecular), titanium (implant and abutment), acrylic resin, and magnets were assigned.
  • Interface Conditions: Absolute osseointegration was assumed between the implants and bone. Sliding friction with a coefficient of 0.334 was applied at the overdenture-mucosa interface to simulate functional movement.
  • Loading and Constraints: The models were constrained at the mandible. Four loading conditions were applied to the overdenture: 100 N vertical load on the lower incisors (VI), 100 N vertical load on the right canine (VC), 100 N vertical load on the right first molar (VM), and a 100 N oblique load (45° buccolingual) on the right first molar (OM).
  • Analysis: The FEA software calculated stress and strain distribution in the peri-implant bone, dental implants, and mucosa under these loading conditions for each attachment type.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized CT scan data from a single 63-year-old female volunteer to create the anatomical models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oblique Loading is Detrimental: Oblique forces, simulating chewing, significantly increase stress and deformation in the peri-implant bone and mucosa compared to vertical loads. This highlights the importance of considering multidirectional forces in dental implant research.
  • Attachment Design Matters: The design of the magnetic attachment plays a crucial role in how forces are distributed. Flat-type attachments, while offering strong retention, concentrate stress, whereas dome and cushion types allow for some movement, acting as stress distributors.
  • Resilience is Key: The "stress-breaking" ability of dome and cushion-type attachments, allowing for slight displacement or rotation, is beneficial in mitigating high stresses on the bone and implants, especially under challenging loading conditions.
  • Mucosa Plays a Protective Role: The cushion-type attachment, in particular, seems to effectively transfer forces to the oral mucosa, reducing the direct vertical load on the dental implant.

Key Results

  • Peri-Implant Bone Stress: The flat-type attachment consistently exhibited the highest maximum equivalent stress in the peri-implant bone across VI, VC, and OM loading conditions.
  • Oblique Load Impact: Under oblique molar loading (OM), the maximum equivalent stress in the peri-implant bone was approximately double that of vertical molar loading (VM).
  • Mucosa Pressure and Deformation: Maximum pressures and deformations on the mucosa were higher under VI, VC, and OM loading compared to VM. The cushion-type attachment generally showed the highest maximum mucosa pressures, particularly in the VI condition. Oblique loading (OM) resulted in the largest mucosa deformation, approximately double that of VM.
  • Implant Stress: Similar to the peri-implant bone, the flat-type attachment showed the highest equivalent stress in the dental implant under VC loading, while the lowest implant stress was observed under VM loading.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study used a simplified, isotropic, homogeneous, and linearly elastic model for the structures.
  • Perfect osseointegration was assumed, which might not fully represent real-world scenarios.
  • Only one oblique force direction was simulated; actual occlusal forces are multidirectional.
  • The study was based on a single volunteer's CT data.
  • Future Work:
    • Long-term clinical studies are needed to assess the effects of different magnetic attachment types on mandibular injuries and denture function.
  • Further research should explore the impact of multidirectional occlusal forces and more complex material properties.
  • Investigating the influence of varying implant numbers and positions would also be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{hu2019comparison,
  author = {Fengling Hu and Yiming Gong and Zhen Bian and Xiaoying Zhang and Bin Xu and Jianguo Zhang and Xiaojun Shi and Youcheng Yu and Liang Song},
  title = {{Comparison of Three Different Types of Two-Implant-Supported Magnetic Attachments on the Stress Distribution in Edentulous Mandible}},
  journal = {Comput. Math. Methods Medicine},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1155/2019/6839517},
}
Figure