Comparison of the symmetric hyperbolic thermodynamically compatible framework with Hamiltonian mechanics of binary mixtures

Martin Sýkora, Michal Pavelka, Ilya Peshkov, Piotr Minakowski, Václav Klika, Evgeniy RomenskiContinuum 2022

TL;DR

This paper compares two advanced frameworks for describing the complex behavior of binary mixtures: the Symmetric Hyperbolic Thermodynamically Consistent (SHTC) framework and the General Equation for Non-Equilibrium Reversible-Irreversible Coupling (GENERIC). While both frameworks aim to capture the dynamics of mixtures, GENERIC, derived from fundamental Hamiltonian mechanics, introduces unique terms related to the self-advection of relative velocity that are absent in SHTC, leading to distinct predictions, especially in the presence of vorticity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Describing the thermodynamic behavior of binary mixtures, especially when each component has its own momentum, is a significant challenge. Traditional approaches often simplify mixtures by assuming a single momentum or equilibrium. However, real-world phenomena like mixing at high relative velocities require models that can account for the individual momenta of constituents and their interactions. This paper addresses the need for a rigorous comparison between two sophisticated theoretical frameworks, SHTC and GENERIC, to understand their similarities, differences, and implications for modeling such complex systems. Specifically, it investigates how these frameworks handle the dynamics of relative velocity and its impact on diffusion, particularly in the presence of vorticity.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach:

  • Analytical Comparison: They derive and compare the governing equations for binary mixtures within both the SHTC and GENERIC frameworks. This involves projecting the Liouville equation (for GENERIC) and examining the resulting Poisson brackets and evolution equations.
  • Reduction Techniques: To highlight key differences, they apply reduction techniques, particularly "Dynamic Maximum Entropy" (DynMaxEnt), to simplify both models. This process involves assuming fast relaxation of certain variables (like relative velocity) to obtain reduced systems that are easier to analyze and compare.
  • Numerical Simulations: The reduced models are then solved numerically to visualize and quantify the differences in their predictions, especially in scenarios involving vorticity and different flow regimes (laminar channel flow, Gresho vortex).
  • Hamiltonian Structure Analysis: A significant part of the work involves ensuring that the derived models possess the correct Hamiltonian structure, including the crucial Jacobi identity, which is fundamental for the self-consistency of Hamiltonian mechanics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical simulations based on initial conditions defined within the paper itself.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GENERIC's Unique Terms: The most striking insight is that GENERIC, when derived from the Liouville equation, naturally incorporates terms describing the self-advection of relative velocity. These terms are absent in the SHTC framework.
  • Vorticity-Dependent Diffusion: The self-advection terms in GENERIC lead to a diffusion matrix that depends on vorticity. This means that in the presence of swirling motion, the diffusion of components is not simply aligned with the chemical potential gradient, a departure from standard theories.
  • SHTC as a Special Case: The SHTC framework can be viewed as a simplified version of GENERIC, particularly when certain terms related to relative velocity self-advection are neglected or when specific conditions (like constant entropy difference) are met.
  • Hamiltonian Consistency: The paper demonstrates that both frameworks can be formulated to be Hamiltonian, satisfying the Jacobi identity, which is crucial for thermodynamic consistency. However, achieving this with a single entropy in GENERIC requires specific "Jacobi closure" relations.
  • Impact on Flow Dynamics: Numerical simulations reveal that the vorticity-dependent terms in GENERIC can lead to faster advection and a breaking of radial symmetry in flow patterns compared to SHTC, especially in the presence of vortices.

Key Results

  • Analytical Equivalence Under Simplification: Under certain conditions (e.g., isothermal regime, neglecting self-advection terms), the SHTC and GENERIC models yield similar equations.
  • Quantitative Differences in Advection: Numerical simulations show that the advection in the reduced GENERIC model can be significantly faster than in the reduced SHTC model, with a coefficient that is influenced by material parameters and vorticity.
  • Symmetry Breaking: In the presence of vortices, the GENERIC model predicts a breaking of radial symmetry in the density profiles, a phenomenon not observed in the SHTC model under similar conditions. This highlights the physical consequences of the additional terms in GENERIC.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Well-Posedness of GENERIC: The authors note that they cannot yet prove the well-posedness of the full GENERIC system with two entropies, which is a significant theoretical challenge.
  • Experimental Validation: While numerical simulations demonstrate differences, direct comparison with experimental data for diffusion in the presence of vorticity is suggested as future work.
  • Generalization to Heterogeneous Mixtures: The current analysis focuses on homogeneous binary mixtures. Extending the framework to heterogeneous mixtures, including volume fractions as state variables, is a natural next step.
  • Isothermal vs. Non-Isothermal: The paper explores both isothermal and non-isothermal cases, but the complexities of achieving a single-entropy Hamiltonian formulation for non-isothermal mixtures are highlighted.
  • Further Exploration of Jacobi Closures: The paper identifies a family of solutions for the entropy difference that satisfy the Jacobi identity in GENERIC. Further investigation into these solutions and their physical implications is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract How to properly describe continuum thermodynamics of binary mixtures where each constituent has its own momentum? The Symmetric Hyperbolic Thermodynamically Consistent (SHTC) framework and Hamiltonian mechanics in the form of the General Equation for Non-Equilibrium Reversible-Irreversible Coupling (GENERIC) provide two answers, which are similar but not identical, and are compared in this article. They are compared both analytically and numerically on several levels of description, varying in the amount of detail. Namely, a reduction to a more common one-momentum setting is shown, where the effects of the second momentum translate into diffusive fluxes. Both SHTC and GENERIC can thus be interpreted as a method specifying diffusive flux in standard theory. The GENERIC equations, stemming from the Liouville equation, contain terms expressing self-advection of the relative velocity by itself, which lead to a vorticity-dependent diffusion matrix after the reduction. The SHTC equations, on the other hand, do not contain such terms. We also discuss the possibility to formulate a theory of mixtures with two momenta and only one temperature that is compatible with the Liouville equation and possesses the Hamiltonian structure, including Jacobi identity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sykora2022comparison,
  author = {Martin Sýkora and Michal Pavelka and Ilya Peshkov and Piotr Minakowski and Václav Klika and Evgeniy Romenski},
  title = {{Comparison of the symmetric hyperbolic thermodynamically compatible framework with Hamiltonian mechanics of binary mixtures}},
  booktitle = {Continuum},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure