Comparison of the safety and effectiveness of the four-hook needle and hook wire for the preoperative positioning of localization ground glass nodules

Yongming Wang, Lijun Jing, Changsheng Liang, Junzhong Liu, Shubo Wang, Gongchao WangJournal of Cardiothoracic Surgery 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares two minimally invasive techniques for pre-operative localization of small lung nodules: the four-hook needle and the hook wire. Both methods proved safe and effective for guiding video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS), with the four-hook needle demonstrating a significantly lower dislodgement rate and reduced patient pain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lung cancer screening programs are identifying an increasing number of small pulmonary nodules, many of which are ground-glass nodules (GGNs). While video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) is a preferred treatment due to its minimally invasive nature, precisely locating these often small, deep, or soft nodules during surgery can be challenging. This difficulty can lead to longer operative times, increased risk of resecting healthy tissue, or even the need for more invasive open surgery. Pre-operative localization techniques aim to overcome this by marking the nodule's position before surgery. This paper investigates the comparative safety and effectiveness of two such techniques: the established hook wire and a newer four-hook needle.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective study comparing 133 patients who underwent CT-guided localization for single pulmonary nodules between October 2020 and April 2021. Patients were divided into two groups: one receiving localization with a four-hook needle and the other with a hook wire. Both procedures involved CT guidance to insert the chosen device near the nodule. The four-hook needle consists of a coaxial needle, suture, four-hook anchor, pusher, release buckle, and protection tube. The hook wire is a more traditional device. After localization, all patients proceeded to VATS for nodule resection. The study evaluated several metrics, including localization time, procedure success rate, complication rates (pneumothorax, hemorrhage, dislodgement), and post-procedure pain scores using the visual analog scale (VAS).

Datasets

The study utilized clinical data from 133 patients who underwent preoperative localization at a single institution. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The four-hook needle offers superior stability: The design of the four-hook needle, with its multiple anchoring claws, appears to provide a more secure fixation within the lung tissue compared to the single barb of the hook wire. This is crucial for preventing dislodgement during patient transport or preparation for surgery.
  • Reduced patient discomfort: The four-hook needle's flexible posterior connection allows it to be released into the chest cavity, minimizing irritation to the pleura. This contrasts with the hook wire's rigid external component, which can cause discomfort and even severe pleural reactions in some patients.
  • VATS is highly effective for GGNs: The study reinforces that VATS is a successful treatment modality for GGNs, with all nodules being successfully resected in both localization groups.

Key Results

  • Localization Success: Both methods achieved high success rates: 100% for the four-hook needle group and 98.5% for the hook wire group.
  • Dislodgement Rate: The four-hook needle group had a significantly lower dislodgement rate (0%) compared to the hook wire group (7.46%, P=0.024).
  • Patient Pain: The mean VAS pain score was significantly lower in the four-hook needle group (2.87±0.67) than in the hook wire group (6.10±2.39, P=0.000).
  • Localization Time: There was no significant difference in localization time between the two groups (20.58±2.65 min vs. 21.43±3.06 min, P=0.09).
  • Complications: Pneumothorax and hemorrhage rates were comparable between the groups and did not differ significantly.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study is a single-center retrospective analysis, which limits its generalizability. They also note that postoperative follow-up for the two localization methods was not compared. Future research could involve larger, multicenter, randomized controlled trials to further validate these findings and explore long-term outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Preoperative pulmonary nodule localization with both a four-hook needle and hook wire is safe, convenient and effective.
BibTeX
@article{wang2024comparison,
  author = {Yongming Wang and Lijun Jing and Changsheng Liang and Junzhong Liu and Shubo Wang and Gongchao Wang},
  title = {{Comparison of the safety and effectiveness of the four-hook needle and hook wire for the preoperative positioning of localization ground glass nodules}},
  journal = {Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s13019-024-02497-1},
}
Figure