Comparison of the effects of indoor and outdoor exercise on creativity: an analysis of EEG alpha power

Tsukasa Kimura, Teruhiro Mizumoto, Y. Torii, Masumi Ohno, Teruo Higashino, Yasushi YagiFrontiers in Psychology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

While we know that both nature and exercise can boost creativity, this study reveals that combining them—exercising outdoors—significantly increases EEG alpha power in brain regions associated with divergent thinking. Even when behavioral creativity scores remained flat due to test fatigue, participants reported higher "flow" states and showed objective neural signatures of enhanced creative potential after a run in the park compared to a treadmill.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Psychologists have long studied the "green effect" (nature’s ability to restore attention) and the "runner’s high" (exercise’s ability to boost mood and cognition). However, we don't fully understand how these two factors interact to influence creativity at a neural level.

The researchers aimed to bridge this gap by comparing indoor and outdoor exercise while controlling for physical intensity. They specifically looked at divergent thinking—the ability to generate multiple unique solutions to a problem—and used Electroencephalography (EEG) to see if the brain's "creative signature" changed depending on the environment.

Methods

The study employed a within-subjects design with 20 university students. Over a 10-day period, participants rotated through baseline measurements, indoor exercise (treadmill), and outdoor exercise (forest park).

Key methodological features included:

  • Controlled Intensity: To ensure the only variable was the environment, researchers matched the heart rate (HR) and Rating of Perceived Exertion (RPE) between the indoor and outdoor sessions.
  • Alternative Uses Test (AUT): A classic creativity task where participants list as many uses as possible for a common object (e.g., a brick).
  • EEG Monitoring: Researchers focused on alpha band power (8–13 Hz). In creativity research, increased alpha power in the parietal-occipital regions is considered a marker of "internal attention"—the brain's ability to shut out external distractions and recombine stored memories into new ideas.
  • Flow State Scale (FSS): A subjective measure of how much a participant felt "in the zone" (absorption, positive emotion, and sense of control).

Datasets

As this was an original experimental study, the researchers generated their own primary dataset from the 20 participants. They used standard psychometric benchmarks:

  • AUT Scores: Evaluated for Fluency (quantity), Flexibility (categories), and Originality (rarity).
  • EEG Data: Processed using the EEGLAB and ERPLAB toolboxes in MATLAB, with artifacts (like eye blinks) removed via the ADJUST algorithm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Alpha Boost: The most significant finding was that outdoor exercise led to a consistent increase in alpha power in the parietal-occipital region during the creativity task. This suggests that the natural environment "primes" the brain for the type of internal reflection necessary for divergent thinking.
  • Subjective vs. Objective Disconnect: Interestingly, the actual AUT creativity scores didn't show a massive jump between conditions. The authors attribute this to the "Serial Order Effect"—the more times you take a creativity test, the more your performance tends to decline due to boredom or mental fatigue.
  • Nature as a Flow Catalyst: Participants reported significantly higher scores for "positive emotional experience" and "absorption" after outdoor exercise. This suggests that nature doesn't just change how the brain processes information; it changes how we feel about the task, potentially making us more resilient to the fatigue of repetitive creative work.

Key Results

  • Neural Activity: A two-way repeated measures ANOVA showed a significant main effect of the environment on parietal-occipital alpha power ($p = 0.047$, $\eta^2_p = 0.192$). The Bayes Factor ($BF_{10} = 3.845$) provided moderate evidence that outdoor exercise objectively enhanced these neural markers compared to indoor exercise.
  • Flow State: Outdoor exercise led to higher scores in Positive Emotional Experience ($p = 0.031$) and Absorption ($p = 0.024$).
  • Behavioral Scores: No significant difference was found in the raw AUT scores (Fluency, Flexibility, or Originality) between indoor and outdoor conditions ($p > 0.05$), likely due to the aforementioned repetition fatigue.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  1. Sample Size: With only 20 participants, the study is relatively small, though the within-subjects design helps mitigate individual variance.
  2. The "Nature" Variable: "Outdoor" is a broad category. Future research needs to disentangle which specific factors—scenery, wind, temperature, or the variability of terrain—contribute most to the effect.
  3. Task Fatigue: The repeated use of the AUT over 10 days may have masked the behavioral benefits of outdoor exercise. Future studies might use a wider variety of creative tasks to avoid the "floor effect."
  4. Movement Mechanics: Running on a treadmill is a "fixed" movement, whereas running in a park involves "free" movement. The authors suggest that the physical freedom of outdoor movement itself might be a factor in boosting creativity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous research finds that natural environments and exercise enhance creativity. In this within-subjects design study, we examined the influence of outdoor exercise that combined a natural environment with exercise on creativity compared to an indoor exercise control condition by analyzing cognitive activities related to creativity. The participants performed an Alternative Uses Test (AUT), in which ordinary objects are presented to the participants (e.g., a brick), to prompt as many ideas for alternative uses as possible, which are transformed into a creativity score, after indoor running and outdoor running. During the test, brain activity was recorded using electroencephalography (EEG) and a short version flow state scale (FSS) was completed after the experiment. Results showed that while AUT scores did not significantly differ between conditions, alpha band activity at the parietal occipital region involved in divergent creativity increased during the AUT after outdoor exercise while it did not during the AUT after indoor exercise. In addition, FSS scores for positive emotional experience and absorption were higher after outdoor exercise than after indoor exercise. Our results from the FSS suggest that exercise in a natural environment is perceived subjectively differently from indoor exercise, participants report greater experiences of flow compared to indoor exercise, and the EEG measures objectively indicate enhanced cognitive activity in a creativity task after outdoor exercise. This study suggests that outdoor exercise increases neuronal activity in brain regions related to creativity. Further research is needed to understand how this can lead to increased creativity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kimura2023comparison,
  author = {Tsukasa Kimura and Teruhiro Mizumoto and Y. Torii and Masumi Ohno and Teruo Higashino and Yasushi Yagi},
  title = {{Comparison of the effects of indoor and outdoor exercise on creativity: an analysis of EEG alpha power}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1161533},
}
Figure