Comparison of the Detection Characteristics of Trace Species Using Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy and Laser Breakdown Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry

Zhenzhen Wang, Yoshihiro Deguchi, Junjie Yan, Jiping Liu2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper compares two laser-based analytical techniques, Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) and Laser Breakdown Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LB-TOFMS), for detecting trace elements like mercury and iodine. The study demonstrates that LB-TOFMS offers significantly lower detection limits, especially when using short laser pulses and low pressures, making it a more sensitive option for certain applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate and rapid detection of trace elements is crucial for environmental monitoring, industrial process control, and public health. Traditional methods often require lengthy sample preparation, which can be a bottleneck for real-time analysis. While Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) is a fast, non-contact method, its detection limits can be a challenge for very low concentrations. Laser Breakdown Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LB-TOFMS) is another promising technique, but a direct comparison of its detection characteristics against LIBS, particularly under varying experimental conditions like pressure and laser pulse width, is needed to understand their respective strengths and weaknesses. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically comparing LIBS and LB-TOFMS for the detection of mercury and iodine, focusing on how different parameters influence their performance.

Methods

The study employed two primary laser-based analytical techniques:

  • Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS): This technique involves focusing a laser pulse onto a sample to create a plasma. The emitted light from the excited atoms and ions in the plasma is then analyzed by a spectrometer to determine elemental composition. The researchers investigated LIBS under low-pressure conditions (400 Pa to 10 kPa) using nanosecond (ns) and picosecond (ps) pulsed lasers at different wavelengths (1064 nm and 532 nm). Key parameters explored included pressure, laser power, delay time, and pulse width.
  • Laser Breakdown Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LB-TOFMS): In this method, a laser pulse also creates a plasma, but instead of analyzing emitted light, the ions produced are separated and detected based on their time-of-flight. This allows for mass-to-charge ratio determination. The experiments were conducted at very low pressures (typically < 1 Pa) using ns and ps pulsed lasers. The study focused on how pressure, laser power, wavelength, and pulse width affected ion signal intensities and detection limits.

The researchers used samples of mercury (Hg) and methyl iodide (CH3I) as representative trace species, along with other elements like arsenic (As), strontium (Sr), and cesium (Cs), to evaluate the detection capabilities of both systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized prepared gas mixtures and vaporized samples of specific elements rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pressure is Key for LIBS Sensitivity: Reducing pressure significantly improves LIBS detection limits by minimizing continuum emission and electron impact ionization, which are major interference sources at higher pressures.
  • LB-TOFMS Excels at Low Detection Limits: LB-TOFMS, operating at very low pressures (< 1 Pa), inherently offers lower detection limits due to its non-collisional nature and direct ion detection.
  • Short Pulses Enhance Ionization: Shorter laser pulse widths (picosecond) are more effective for multi-photon ionization, leading to higher ion yields in LB-TOFMS and improved signal-to-noise ratios in LIBS, especially for mercury and iodine.
  • Wavelength Matters for Ionization: Shorter wavelengths (e.g., 532 nm) carry higher photon energy, which can be more efficient for multi-photon ionization compared to longer wavelengths (e.g., 1064 nm), particularly in LB-TOFMS.
  • Interference Management is Crucial: For LIBS, managing molecular and atomic emissions from buffer gases (like NO and N) is critical for accurate detection, especially at low pressures. LB-TOFMS is less susceptible to these interferences but can be affected by fragmentation of target ions.

Key Results

  • Detection Limits:
    • LIBS: Mercury detection limit of 3.5 ppb (in N2, ns laser) and iodine detection limit of 60 ppb (in N2, ns laser).
  • LB-TOFMS: Mercury detection limit of 1.2 ppb (35 ps laser) and iodine detection limit of 9.0 ppb (35 ps laser).
  • Enhancement: LB-TOFMS achieved detection limits that were enhanced by approximately 2.9 times for mercury and 6.7 times for iodine compared to LIBS.
  • Pressure Dependence: In LB-TOFMS, ion signals generally increased linearly with pressure up to a certain point (less than 1 Pa), attributed to increased ion number density. In LIBS, the relationship was more complex, influenced by delay time and laser wavelength.
  • Pulse Width: Short pulse width lasers (35 ps) significantly improved the detection ability of both LIBS and LB-TOFMS, particularly by enhancing multi-photon ionization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • LIBS Limitations: While LIBS is fast and non-contact, its detection limits are generally higher than LB-TOFMS, especially for elements like mercury and iodine. Managing spectral interferences from buffer gases and plasma continuum emission remains a challenge, particularly at low pressures.
  • LB-TOFMS Limitations: The primary interference in LB-TOFMS is partial fragmentation of target ions, which can complicate spectral interpretation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the choice between LIBS and LB-TOFMS should depend on the specific application requirements, with LB-TOFMS being preferred for ultra-trace analysis and LIBS for rapid, qualitative screening or when sample preparation is a major constraint. Further optimization of laser parameters and plasma conditions could lead to even greater enhancements in detection capabilities for both techniques. The study also highlights the potential for using short pulse width lasers to improve the detection ability of trace species in various matrices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2015comparison,
  author = {Zhenzhen Wang and Yoshihiro Deguchi and Junjie Yan and Jiping Liu},
  title = {{Comparison of the Detection Characteristics of Trace Species Using Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy and Laser Breakdown Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/s150305982},
}
Figure