Comparison of Small RNA Profiles of Glycine max and Glycine soja at Early Developmental Stages

Yuzhe Sun, Zeta Mui, Xuan Liu, Aldrin Kay‐Yuen Yim, Hao Qin, Fuk‐Ling Wong, Ting‐Fung Chan, Siu Ming Yiu, Hon‐Ming Lam, Boon Leong LimInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares the small RNA (sRNA) profiles of cultivated soybean (Glycine max) and its wild relative (Glycine soja) across various developmental stages and tissues. They developed a novel computational pipeline to identify phased small interfering RNAs (phasiRNAs) and their origins, revealing differences in phasiRNA abundance between the two species, particularly during germination, and highlighting the role of disease resistance genes in phasiRNA production.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cultivated soybean (Glycine max) is a vital crop, but domestication may have led to a loss of genetic information compared to its wild progenitor, Glycine soja. Small RNAs, including microRNAs (miRNAs) and phasiRNAs, are crucial regulators of plant development. Understanding how sRNA profiles differ between cultivated and wild soybeans could shed light on genetic changes during domestication and their impact on traits like development and stress response. However, comprehensively characterizing these sRNA populations, especially phasiRNAs and their regulatory pathways, across different tissues and developmental stages in these two species presents a significant challenge.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Small RNA Sequencing: They generated 14 small RNA libraries from various tissues (roots, aerial parts, trifoliates) of both G. max (C08) and G. soja (W05) at three developmental stages (germinated, young, and seedling).
  • miRNA Identification and Differential Expression Analysis: Known and novel miRNAs were identified. Differential expression analysis was performed to compare miRNA abundance between species, tissues, and developmental stages.
  • Novel PHAS Loci and PhasiRNA Identification Pipeline: A key contribution is a newly developed computational pipeline. This pipeline uses a sliding window method to predict PHAS loci (regions that generate phasiRNAs) and then identifies phasiRNAs originating from these loci. Stringent criteria were applied to filter for high-confidence phasiRNAs.
  • miRNA Target Prediction: To understand how miRNAs might initiate phasiRNA biogenesis, miRNA targets were predicted using psRNATarget.
  • Quantitative RT-PCR (qRT-PCR): Selected miRNA and phasiRNA expression patterns were validated using qRT-PCR to confirm sequencing data.

Datasets

The study utilized small RNA sequencing data from 14 libraries generated from Glycine max (C08) and Glycine soja (W05) accessions. These libraries covered multiple tissues (roots, aerial parts, trifoliates) and developmental stages (germinated, young, and seedling). The G. max genome (Wm82.a2.v1) was used as the reference for mapping and analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Conserved miRNA Profiles, Divergent PhasiRNA Dynamics: While the overall miRNA profiles were largely similar between G. max and G. soja, the study revealed significant differences in phasiRNA abundance, particularly in germinated seedlings, suggesting that phasiRNA regulation might be more dynamic and species-specific.
  • PHAS Loci Rich in Disease Resistance Genes: A substantial proportion of identified PHAS loci were associated with TIR-NB-LRR genes, which are known to be involved in plant disease resistance. This suggests a potential link between sRNA pathways and plant defense mechanisms.
  • Developmental and Tissue-Specific sRNA Regulation: The study highlighted that both developmental stage and tissue type significantly influence sRNA profiles, with distinct patterns observed for miRNAs and phasiRNAs in leaves versus roots.
  • Novel Pipeline for PHAS/PhasiRNA Discovery: The development of a robust computational pipeline for identifying PHAS loci and phasiRNAs is a significant methodological contribution, enabling more comprehensive analysis of these regulatory elements.

Key Results

  • sRNA Libraries: A total of 85,327,846 and 86,812,643 clean reads were obtained from C08 and W05, respectively.
  • miRNAs: 621 known miRNAs and 15 novel miRNAs were identified. 443 known and 15 novel miRNAs showed differential accumulation.
  • PHAS Loci and PhasiRNAs: The developed pipeline identified 50 PHAS loci generating 55 phasiRNAs in C08, and 41 PHAS loci generating 46 phasiRNAs in W05.
  • PhasiRNA Abundance: PhasiRNAs were more abundant in germinated seedlings of G. max (C08) compared to G. soja (W05).
  • Gene Families Involved: PHAS loci were frequently associated with TIR-NB-LRR genes, as well as genes encoding NAC transcription factors, DCL2, PPR, and AFB3 proteins.
  • miRNA-Triggered PhasiRNAs: 17 C08 miRNAs and 15 W05 miRNAs were predicted to trigger phasiRNA biogenesis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genome Annotation Differences: The study notes that differences in gene annotation between G. max and G. soja genomes made direct integration of miRNA and phasiRNA information challenging, potentially leading to the loss of some G. soja-specific sRNA information.
  • Functional Validation: While the study identified numerous miRNAs and phasiRNAs and predicted their targets and pathways, extensive experimental validation of the functional roles of these sRNAs in specific developmental processes or stress responses would be a logical next step.
  • Domestication Impact: Further research could delve deeper into how specific sRNA differences between wild and cultivated soybeans contribute to the phenotypic traits that were selected for or lost during domestication.
  • Broader sRNA Categories: While focusing on miRNAs and phasiRNAs, exploring other sRNA classes and their interactions could provide a more complete picture of gene regulation in soybean.

Summary updated

Abstract

Small RNAs, including microRNAs (miRNAs) and phased small interfering RNAs (phasiRNAs; from <i>PHAS</i> loci), play key roles in plant development. Cultivated soybean, <i>Glycine max</i>, contributes a great deal to food production, but, compared to its wild kin, <i>Glycine soja</i>, it may lose some genetic information during domestication. In this work, we analyzed the sRNA profiles of different tissues in both cultivated (C08) and wild soybeans (W05) at three stages of development. A total of 443 known miRNAs and 15 novel miRNAs showed varying abundances between different samples, but the miRNA profiles were generally similar in both accessions. Based on a sliding window analysis workflow that we developed, 50 <i>PHAS</i> loci generating 55 21-nucleotide phasiRNAs were identified in C08, and 46 phasiRNAs from 41 <i>PHAS</i> loci were identified in W05. In germinated seedlings, phasiRNAs were more abundant in C08 than in W05. Disease resistant <i>TIR-NB-LRR</i> genes constitute a very large family of <i>PHAS</i> loci. PhasiRNAs were also generated from several loci that encode for NAC transcription factors, Dicer-like 2 (DCL2), Pentatricopeptide Repeat (PPR), and Auxin Signaling F-box 3 (AFB3) proteins. To investigate the possible involvement of miRNAs in initiating the <i>PHAS</i>-phasiRNA pathway, miRNA target predictions were performed and 17 C08 miRNAs and 15 W05 miRNAs were predicted to trigger phasiRNAs biogenesis. In summary, we provide a comprehensive description of the sRNA profiles of wild versus cultivated soybeans, and discuss the possible roles of sRNAs during soybean germination.
BibTeX
@article{sun2016comparison,
  author = {Yuzhe Sun and Zeta Mui and Xuan Liu and Aldrin Kay‐Yuen Yim and Hao Qin and Fuk‐Ling Wong and Ting‐Fung Chan and Siu Ming Yiu and Hon‐Ming Lam and Boon Leong Lim},
  title = {{Comparison of Small RNA Profiles of Glycine max and Glycine soja at Early Developmental Stages}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms17122043},
}
Figure